Title: Constructing Cell‐Type Taxonomy by Optimal Transport With Relaxed Marginal Constraints
ABSTRACT The rapid emergence of single‐cell data has facilitated the study of many different biological conditions at the cellular level. Cluster analysis has been widely applied to identify cell types, capturing the essential patterns of the original data in a much more concise form. One challenge in the cluster analysis of cells is matching clusters extracted from datasets of different origins or conditions. Many existing algorithms cannot recognize new cell types present in only one of the two samples when establishing a correspondence between clusters obtained from two samples. Additionally, when there are more than two samples, it is advantageous to align clusters across all samples simultaneously rather than performing pairwise alignment. Our approach aims to construct a taxonomy for cell clusters across all samples to better annotate these clusters and effectively extract features for downstream analysis. A new system for constructing cell‐type taxonomy has been developed by combining the technique of optimal transport with relaxed marginal constraints (OT‐RMC) and the simultaneous alignment of clusters across multiple samples. OT‐RMC allows us to address challenges that arise when the proportions of clusters vary substantially between samples or when some clusters do not appear in all the samples. Experiments on more than 20 datasets demonstrate that the taxonomy constructed by this new system can yield highly accurate annotation of cell types. Additionally, sample‐level features extracted based on the taxonomy result in accurate classification of samples.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2205004
PAR ID:
10708933
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley Periodicals LLC.
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Statistical Analysis and Data Mining: An ASA Data Science Journal
Volume:
18
ISSN:
1932-1864
Page Range / eLocation ID:
e70049
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. null (Ed.)
    Optimal transport (OT) is a principled approach for matching, having achieved success in diverse applications such as tracking and cluster alignment. It is also the core computation problem for solving the Wasserstein metric between probabilistic distributions, which has been increasingly used in machine learning. Despite its popularity, the marginal constraints of OT impose fundamental limitations. For some matching or pattern extraction problems, the framework of OT is not suitable, and post-processing of the OT solution is often unsatisfactory. In this paper, we extend OT by a new optimization formulation called Optimal Transport with Relaxed Marginal Constraints (OT-RMC). Specifically, we relax the marginal constraints by introducing a penalty on the deviation from the constraints. Connections with the standard OT are revealed both theoretically and experimentally. We demonstrate how OT-RMC can easily adapt to various tasks by three highly different applications in image analysis and single-cell data analysis. Quantitative comparisons have been made with OT and another commonly used matching scheme to show the remarkable advantages of OT-RMC. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract SummaryNew advances in single-cell multi-omics experiments have allowed biologists to examine how various biological factors regulate processes in concert on the cellular level. However, measuring multiple cellular features for a single cell can be quite resource-intensive or impossible with the current technology. By using optimal transport (OT) to align cells and features across disparate datasets produced by separate assays, Single Cell alignment using Optimal Transport + (SCOT+), our unsupervised single-cell alignment software suite, allows biologists to align their data without the need for any correspondence. SCOT+ implements a generic optimal transport solution that can be reduced to multiple different previously studied OT optimization procedures including SCOT, SCOTv2, SCOOTR, and AGW for single cell, each of which provides state-of-the-art single-cell alignment performance. Outside of giving a unified framework to interact with prior formulations, the generality of SCOT+ optimization naturally gives rise to a new OT loss, Unbalanced Augmented Gromov-Wasserstein (UAGW), and a corresponding optimizer. With our user-friendly website and tutorials, this new package will help improve biological analyses by allowing for more accurate downstream analyses on multi-omics single-cell measurements. Implementation and AvailabilityOur algorithm is implemented in Pytorch and available on PyPI and GitHub (https://github.com/scotplus/scotplus). Additionally, we have many tutorials available in a separate GitHub repository (https://github.com/scotplus/book_source) and on our website (https://scotplus.github.io/). 
    more » « less
  3. Rigoutsos, Isidore (Ed.)
    Consensus clustering has been widely used in bioinformatics and other applications to improve the accuracy, stability and reliability of clustering results. This approach ensembles cluster co-occurrences from multiple clustering runs on subsampled observations. For application to large-scale bioinformatics data, such as to discover cell types from single-cell sequencing data, for example, consensus clustering has two significant drawbacks: (i) computational inefficiency due to repeatedly applying clustering algorithms, and (ii) lack of interpretability into the important features for differentiating clusters. In this paper, we address these two challenges by developing IMPACC: Interpretable MiniPatch Adaptive Consensus Clustering. Our approach adopts three major innovations. We ensemble cluster co-occurrences from tiny subsets of both observations and features, termed minipatches, thus dramatically reducing computation time. Additionally, we develop adaptive sampling schemes for observations, which result in both improved reliability and computational savings, as well as adaptive sampling schemes of features, which lead to interpretable solutions by quickly learning the most relevant features that differentiate clusters. We study our approach on synthetic data and a variety of real large-scale bioinformatics data sets; results show that our approach not only yields more accurate and interpretable cluster solutions, but it also substantially improves computational efficiency compared to standard consensus clustering approaches. 
    more » « less
  4. null (Ed.)
    In many machine learning applications, it is necessary to meaningfully aggregate, through alignment, different but related datasets. Optimal transport (OT)-based approaches pose alignment as a divergence minimization problem: the aim is to transform a source dataset to match a target dataset using the Wasserstein distance as a divergence measure. We introduce a hierarchical formulation of OT which leverages clustered structure in data to improve alignment in noisy, ambiguous, or multimodal settings. To solve this numerically, we propose a distributed ADMM algorithm that also exploits the Sinkhorn distance, thus it has an efficient computational complexity that scales quadratically with the size of the largest cluster. When the transformation between two datasets is unitary, we provide performance guarantees that describe when and how well aligned cluster correspondences can be recovered with our formulation, as well as provide worst-case dataset geometry for such a strategy. We apply this method to synthetic datasets that model data as mixtures of low-rank Gaussians and study the impact that different geometric properties of the data have on alignment. Next, we applied our approach to a neural decoding application where the goal is to predict movement directions and instantaneous velocities from populations of neurons in the macaque primary motor cortex. Our results demonstrate that when clustered structure exists in datasets, and is consistent across trials or time points, a hierarchical alignment strategy that leverages such structure can provide significant improvements in cross-domain alignment. 
    more » « less
  5. Birol, Inanc (Ed.)
    Abstract MotivationSingle-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) is widely used for analyzing gene expression in multi-cellular systems and provides unprecedented access to cellular heterogeneity. scRNA-seq experiments aim to identify and quantify all cell types present in a sample. Measured single-cell transcriptomes are grouped by similarity and the resulting clusters are mapped to cell types based on cluster-specific gene expression patterns. While the process of generating clusters has become largely automated, annotation remains a laborious ad hoc effort that requires expert biological knowledge. ResultsHere, we introduce CellMeSH—a new automated approach to identifying cell types for clusters based on prior literature. CellMeSH combines a database of gene–cell-type associations with a probabilistic method for database querying. The database is constructed by automatically linking gene and cell-type information from millions of publications using existing indexed literature resources. Compared to manually constructed databases, CellMeSH is more comprehensive and is easily updated with new data. The probabilistic query method enables reliable information retrieval even though the gene–cell-type associations extracted from the literature are noisy. CellMeSH is also able to optionally utilize prior knowledge about tissues or cells for further annotation improvement. CellMeSH achieves top-one and top-three accuracies on a number of mouse and human datasets that are consistently better than existing approaches. Availability and implementationWeb server at https://uncurl.cs.washington.edu/db_query and API at https://github.com/shunfumao/cellmesh. Supplementary informationSupplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online. 
    more » « less