Abstract Accurate prediction of tropical cyclone (TC) intensity remains a significant challenge partially due to physics deficiencies in forecast models. Improvement of boundary layer physics in the turbulent “gray zone” requires a better understanding of spatiotemporal variations of turbulent properties in low-level high-wind regions. To fill the gap, this study utilizes Anduril’s Altius 600, a small uncrewed aircraft system (sUAS), that collected data in the eye and eyewall regions of category 5 Hurricane Ian (2022) at altitudes below 1.4 km. The highest observed wind speed (WSPD) exceeded 105 m s−1at 650-m altitude. The Altius measured turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) and momentum fluxes that were in good agreement with previous crewed aircraft observations. This study explores the scale-awareness turbulent structure by quantifying turbulence-scale (100 m–2 km) and mesoscale (2–10 km) contributions to the total flux and TKE. The results show that mesoscale eddies dominate the horizontal wind variances compared to turbulent eddies. The horizontal wind variances contribute 70%–90% of the total TKE, while the vertical wind variances contribute 10%–30% of the total TKE. Spectral and wavelet analyses demonstrate eddy scales from a few hundred meters up to 10 km, with unique distributions depending on where observations were taken (e.g., eye vs eyewall). These findings underscore the complex and multiscale nature of TKE and momentum fluxes in intense hurricanes and highlight the critical need for advanced observational tools within the high-wind hurricane boundary layer environment. Significance StatementIt is crucial to improve the understanding of turbulent processes in the low-level high-wind regions of tropical cyclones (TCs) for accurate intensity forecasts. Traditional data collection methods involving crewed aircraft are too risky to access these critical regions. This study demonstrates the use of a small uncrewed aircraft system (sUAS) to collect data at low levels within an intense Hurricane Ian (2022). The wind speed measured by the sUAS exceeded 105 m s−1. Important turbulence parameters are estimated and presented as a function of wind speed, height, and radial locations. We found that mesoscale (2–10 km) eddies contributed to a significant portion of the total momentum transfer relative to turbulence-scale (100 m–2 km) eddies. This work demonstrates the usefulness of sUASs for improving the basic understanding of key physical processes in the high-wind hurricane boundary layer.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on June 1, 2027
An Observation–Model Comparison Framework for Diagnosing Tropical Cyclone Thermodynamic Change: Application to Hurricane Sam (2021)
Abstract Biases in tropical cyclone model forecasts impact track, intensity, and structural predictions. Yet, not all of these biases can be assessed using traditional comparisons with observations. This paper fills this research gap by introducing a new model evaluation framework that compares single forecasts to aircraft data from individual flights. Measurements from the novel compact Raman lidar are supplemented by dropsonde and tail Doppler radar data to explore how low-level tropical cyclone kinematics and thermodynamics evolve, particularly in the atmospheric boundary layer. The compact Raman lidar is essential in this framework, as it provides extensive thermodynamic data coverage in the tropical cyclone eye and rainbands. As a demonstration, observations are compared to short lead-time Coupled Ocean–Atmosphere Mesoscale Prediction System (COAMPS)–Tropical Cyclone (TC) forecasts of Hurricane Sam (2021) over three sampling periods to diagnose model biases. Two important low-level biases consistently appear: The modeled rainband atmospheric boundary layer has a positive moisture bias, and the modeled low-level eye has a cold bias. Despite these consistent thermodynamic differences, Sam’s primary and secondary circulations vary between flights, suggesting that mean tropical cyclone kinematics alone do not drive these temperature and moisture biases. This unique analysis framework focuses on individual flight legs, hinges on the high spatial density of the compact Raman lidar thermodynamic data, and provides an avenue for future model improvement via atmospheric boundary layer scheme adjustments. Significance StatementTropical cyclones rely on the transfer of heat and moisture from the ocean to the lower atmosphere to maintain their structure and intensity. Despite the importance of low-level thermodynamics, these fields are poorly constrained in tropical cyclone models. This study uses a new methodology to compare unique aircraft measurements of temperature and moisture with model forecasts for one storm. Key systematic errors in the model with respect to observations are found, including increased low-level moisture and colder temperatures in the eye of the storm. These model biases alter the characteristics of the simulated storm, partially explaining intensity forecast errors. In the future, if we can correct these thermodynamic biases by improving model physics, a more accurate depiction of tropical cyclones could be achieved.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10709259
- Publisher / Repository:
- American Meteorological Society
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Monthly Weather Review
- Volume:
- 154
- Issue:
- 6
- ISSN:
- 0027-0644
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 1171 to 1192
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract Tropical cyclones in Earth’s atmosphere form due to a combination of warm ocean waters, high atmospheric humidity, persistent deep convection, and preexisting low-level vorticity. Although Saturn’s largest moon, Titan, has a global Earth-like tropical climate with a volatile methane cycle and sufficient convective activity to power the energetics of a mature cyclone, no such storm has yet been observed. Previous work has suggested that Titan’s polar lakes could be suitable for tropical cyclone development, based on inferences of low-level absolute vorticity and surface heat fluxes. However, key background variables, such as temperature and specific humidity, differ between the atmospheres of Earth and Titan, making direct comparisons difficult. By systematically varying rotation rate, condensable volatility, and equatorial landmass, we reveal how modest adjustments to planetary parameters can restructure the balance between dynamical forcing, thermodynamic potential, and environmental ventilation. The picture that emerges is one in which Earth-like systems naturally support broad regions of cyclogenesis in the deep tropics, whereas Titan-like systems shift environmental favorability to narrow, poleward bands where vorticity, air–sea disequilibrium, and atmospheric moisture align only episodically. These results not only refine our understanding of Titan’s potential for tropical cyclone activity but also highlight the sensitivity of cyclogenesis pathways to planetary-scale controls. More broadly, the framework developed here provides a new foundation for exploring cyclone-favorable climates across a wide range of terrestrial worlds, underscoring that the familiar paradigms of Earth’s tropical cyclone behavior may represent just one expression within a much wider spectrum of atmospheric possibilities. Significance StatementTropical cyclones are vital to Earth’s climate, yet their presence on other planets is poorly understood. Here, we ask the question: How does the variation of planetary parameters affect the large-scale favorability of tropical cyclones between Earth-like and Titan-like states? Using a global climate model, we transform an Earth-like aquaplanet into a Titan-like planet by varying rotation rate, water vapor concentration, and equatorial landmass width. By systematically varying these parameters, we reveal how modest adjustments to planetary parameters can restructure the balance between dynamical forcing, thermodynamic potential, and environmental ventilation. The picture that emerges is one in which Earth-like systems naturally support broad regions of cyclogenesis in the deep tropics, whereas Titan-like systems shift environmental favorability to narrow, poleward bands where vorticity, air–sea disequilibrium, and atmospheric moisture align only episodically. These results not only refine our understanding of Titan’s potential for tropical cyclone activity but also highlight the sensitivity of cyclogenesis pathways to planetary-scale controls. More broadly, the framework developed here provides a new foundation for exploring cyclone-favorable climates across a wide range of terrestrial worlds, underscoring that the familiar paradigms of Earth’s tropical cyclone behavior may represent just one expression within a much wider spectrum of atmospheric possibilities.more » « less
-
Abstract Low‐level clouds in the tropical cyclone (TC) rainbands modulate the radial inflow of warm, moist boundary layer air, which can impact TC intensity. Yet, precisely measuring rainband cloud boundaries with existing remote sensing techniques remains a challenge. To address this observational gap, this work leverages compact Raman lidar (CRL) backscattered power data collected by a NOAA P‐3 aircraft to distinguish between low‐level convective clouds, shallow clouds, stratiform precipitation, and clear air in the TC rainbands. CRL data are analyzed together with traditional tail Doppler radar (TDR) and in situ observations. An empirical CRL classification scheme finds that convective cloud, stratiform rainfall, and clear air sectors have unique kinematic and precipitation properties. A case study of Hurricane Sam (2021) demonstrates how this method resolves cloud structures with enhanced horizontal detail compared to the TDR. For the first time, the horizontal scales of low‐level convection and shallow clouds are determined. Environmental shear‐relative analyses reveal that the downshear‐left quadrant contains the most low‐level convective coverage and the least clear air. Meanwhile, the upshear‐right quadrant has little low‐level convection and plentiful clear air. Increasing environmental shear from low to moderate magnitudes amplifies these TC shear‐induced precipitation asymmetries. A conceptual framework is developed to highlight the unique information provided by the CRL when classifying cloud and precipitation structures.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)Abstract The thermodynamic effect of downdrafts on the boundary layer and nearby updrafts are explored in idealized simulations of category-3 and category-5 tropical cyclones (Ideal3 and Ideal5). In Ideal5, downdrafts underneath the eyewall pose no negative thermodynamic influence because of eye-eyewall mixing below 2-km altitude. Additionally, a layer of higher θ e between 1 and 2 km altitude associated with low-level outflow that extends 40 km outward from the eyewall region creates a “thermodynamic shield” that prevents negative effects from downdrafts. In Ideal3, parcel trajectories from downdrafts directly underneath the eyewall reveal that low-θ e air initially moves radially inward allowing for some recovery in the eye, but still enters eyewall updrafts with a mean θ e deficit of 5.2 K. Parcels originating in low-level downdrafts often stay below 400 m for over an hour and increase their θ e by 10-14 K, showing that air-sea enthalpy fluxes cause sufficient energetic recovery. The most thermodynamically unfavorable downdrafts occur ~5 km radially outward from an updraft and transport low-θ e mid-tropospheric air towards the inflow layer. Here, the low-θ e air entrains into the updraft in less than five minutes with a mean θ e deficit of 8.2 K. In general, θ e recovery is a function of minimum parcel altitude such that downdrafts with the most negative influence are those entrained into the top of the inflow layer. With both simulated TCs exposed to environmental vertical wind shear, this study underscores that storm structure and individual downdraft characteristics must be considered when discussing paradigms for TC intensity evolution.more » « less
-
Abstract Storm surge is a weather hazard that can generate dangerous flooding and is not fully understood in terms of timing and atmospheric forcing. Using observations along the Northeast United States, surge is sorted based on duration and intensity to reveal distinct time-evolving behavior. Long-duration surge events slowly recede, while strong, short-duration events often involve negative surge in quick succession after the maximum. Using Lagrangian track information, the tropical and extratropical cyclones and atmospheric blocks that generate the surge events are identified. There is a linear correlation between surge duration and surge maximum, and the relationship is stronger for surge caused by extratropical cyclones as compared to those events caused by tropical cyclones. For the extremes based on duration, the shortest-duration strong surge events are caused by tropical cyclones, while the longest-duration events are most often caused by extratropical cyclones. At least half of long-duration surge events involve anomalously strong atmospheric blocking poleward of the cyclone, while strong, short-duration events are most often caused by cyclones in the absence of blocking. The dynamical influence of the blocks leads to slow-moving cyclones that take meandering paths. In contrast, for strong, short-duration events, cyclones travel faster and take a more meridional path. These unique dynamical scenarios provide better insight for interpreting the threat of surge in medium-range forecasts.more » « less
An official website of the United States government
