Search for: All records

Quartz‐in‐garnet elastic geobarometry (QuiG) pressures in rocks from two Barrovian metamorphic terranes in the western US Cordilleran hinterland exceed pressures determined using chemical thermodynamics by 3–4 kbar. For this study, 135 quartz inclusions from the Funeral Mountains, California, were analysed using QuiG in five garnets from three locations representing metamorphic grades of upper greenschist, lower amphibolite, and middle amphibolite facies. From a second Barrovian terrane, the Wood Hills in northeastern Nevada, 125 quartz inclusions were analysed using QuiG in 14 garnets from a single rock sample metamorphosed to middle amphibolite facies. Pressures determined for rocks in the Funeral Mountains using QuiG and methods rooted in equilibrium thermodynamics yielded consistent pressure differences between locations, but QuiG pressures are higher. Similarly, QuiG pressures determined for rocks in the Wood Hills are higher than pressures determined by equilibrium thermodynamic approaches. Possible explanations for the pressure differences include garnet compositions not reflecting equilibrium, sources of error in thermodynamic calculations such as thermodynamic data or a‐X models, or an unknown source of systematic error that causes QuiG to overestimate pressures of entrapment. To test Raman spectroscopy's ability to reproduce inclusion pressures, pressures were calculated using Raman spectroscopy and synchrotron X‐ray diffraction, which yielded consistent pressures and support the use of the single mode‐shift of the 464 cm⁻¹band of quartz for geobarometry, which simplifies the method by assuming hydrostatic compression of quartz. These results are compared with pressures obtained using Grüneisen tensors and show consistency between these different approaches.