skip to main content


Title: Heavy metal removal capacity of individual components of permeable reactive concrete
Permeable reactive barriers (PRBs) are a well-known technique for groundwater remediation using industrialized reactive media such as zero-valent iron and activated carbon. Permeable reactive concrete (PRC) is an alternative reactive medium composed of relatively inexpensive materials such as cement and aggregate. A variety of multimodal, simultaneous processes drive remediation of metals from contaminated groundwater within PRC systems due to the complex heterogeneous matrix formed during cement hydration. This research investigated the influence coarse aggregate, portland cement, fly ash, and various combinations had on the removal of lead, cadmium, and zinc in solution. Absorption, adsorption, precipitation, co-precipitation, and internal diffusion of the metals are common mechanisms of removal in the hydrated cement matrix and independent of the aggregate. Local aggregates can be used as the permeable structure also possessing high metal removal capabilities, however calcareous sources of aggregate are preferred due to improved removal with low leachability. Individual adsorption isotherms were linear or curvilinear up, indicating a preferred removal process. For PRC samples, metal saturation was not reached over the range of concentrations tested. Results were then used to compare removal against activated carbon and aggregate-based PRBs by estimating material costs for the remediation of an example heavy metal contaminated Superfund site located in the Midwestern United States, Joplin, Missouri.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1439378
NSF-PAR ID:
10063131
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of contaminant hydrology
Volume:
196
ISSN:
0169-7722
Page Range / eLocation ID:
52-61
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Although most manufacturers stopped using long-chain per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs), including perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS), short-chain PFASs are still widely employed. Short-chain PFASs are less known in terms of toxicity and have different adsorption behavior from long-chain PFASs. Previous studies have shown electrostatic interaction with the adsorbent to be the dominant mechanism for the removal of short-chain PFASs. In this study, we designed a high charge density cationic quaternized nanocellulose (QNC) to enhance the removal of both short- and long-chain PFASs from contaminated water. Systematic batch adsorption tests were conducted using the QNC adsorbent to compare its efficiency against PFASs with varying chain lengths and functional groups. From the kinetic study, PFBA (perfluorobutanoic acid), PFBS (perfluorobutanesulfonic acid) and PFOS showed rapid adsorption rates, which reached near equilibrium values (>95% of removal) between 1 min to 15 min, while PFOA required a relatively longer equilibration time of 2 h (it obtained 90% of removal within 15 min). According to the isotherm results, the maximum adsorption capacity ( Q m ) of the QNC adsorbent exhibited the following trend: PFOS ( Q m = 559 mg g −1 or 1.12 mmol g −1 ) > PFOA ( Q m = 405 mg g −1 or 0.98 mmol g −1 ) > PFBS ( Q m = 319 mg g −1 or 1.06 mmol g −1 ) > PFBA ( Q m = 121 mg g −1 or 0.57 mmol g −1 ). This adsorption order generally matches the hydrophobicity trend among four PFASs associated with both PFAS chain length and functional group. In competitive studies, pre-adsorbed short-chain PFASs were quickly desorbed by long-chain PFASs, suggesting that the hydrophobicity of the molecule played an important role in the adsorption process on to QNC. Finally, the developed QNC adsorbent was tested to treat PFAS-contaminated groundwater, which showed excellent removal efficiency (>95%) for long-chain PFASs (C7–C9) even at a low adsorbent dose of 32 mg L −1 . However, short-chain PFASs ( i.e. , PFBA and perfluoropentanoic acid (PFPeA)) were poorly removed by the QNC adsorbent (0% and 10% removal, respectively) due to competing constituents in the groundwater matrix. This was further confirmed by controlled experiments that revealed a drop in the performance of QNC to remove short-chain PFASs at elevated ionic strength (NaCl), but not for long-chain PFASs, likely due to charge neutralization of the anionic functional group of PFASs by inorganic cations. Overall, the QNC adsorbent featured improved PFAS adsorption capacity at almost two-fold of PFAS removal by granular activated carbons, especially for short-chain PFASs. We believe, QNC can complement the use of common treatment methods such as activated carbon or ionic exchange resin to remove a wide range of PFAS pollutants, heading towards the complete remediation of PFAS contamination. 
    more » « less
  2. Nitrogen and phosphorus contained in stormwater runoff contaminate both surface and groundwaters, causing problems for natural aquatic systems and human health. Pervious concrete specifically designed for pollutant removal, otherwise known as permeable reactive concrete (PRC), may be used as a novel component of existing infrastructure to remove nutrients from runoff. This research compares the removal and retention of dissolved, inorganic nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N) and orthophosphate-phosphorus (PO4-P) for three PRC mixtures. The control PRC was ordinary portland cement (OPC) and was compared against other mixtures containing 25% replacement with Class C fly ash or with drinking water treatment residual waste (DWTR). Concrete specimens were jar-tested for 72 h in three different concentrations of nitrate or phosphate. The control mixture removed 60% of NO3-N and more than 80% PO4-P, and the fly ash mixture removed up to 39% of NO3-N and more than 91% PO4-P. The DWTR mixture leached NO3-N while removing more than 80% PO4-P. Linear isotherms were determined for the range of nutrient concentrations tested. Column leach tests were conducted on specimens after initial jar testing and used as an indication of removal permanence. Inorganic removal mechanisms were investigated, including crystallographic substitution, adsorption, and physical solute filtering in cement pore space. Results indicate PRC can be one of the leading methods to remove nitrate from surface waters and is as efficient as other methods for orthophosphate removal. 
    more » « less
  3. Catastrophic release of heavy metals from the King River mine in Colorado and the Minas Gerais dam in Brazil have brought to the forefront the importance of contaminant stabilization and remediation in surface waters. Permeable reactive materials are currently utilized for the remediation of heavy metals and other pollutants by employing reactive media to remove contaminants. This research investigated the use of fly ashes with loss on ignition or sulfur trioxide exceeding ASTM C618 limits to enhance pollutant removal in pervious concrete. The high carbon and sulfur contents of the noncompliant fly ashes provide additional capacity to remove lead, cadmium, and zinc. High-sulfur and high-carbon fly ashes were less effective in metal removal at higher metal concentrations but improved removal at lower concentrations. These results suggest pervious concrete can be designed as an effective remedial technique for use in many infrastructure applications, including beneath permeable pavement, permeable asphalt, revetment, permeable shoulders, gabions for slope stability, mine tailing dams, and emergency surface water cleanup. 
    more » « less
  4. null (Ed.)
    Rice husks are an agricultural residue of great annual production and have a high cellulose content. In this study, we have prepared highly charged carboxyl cellulose nanofibers (CNFs) from rice husks using the TEMPO-oxidation method and the extracted CNFs were evaluated as an adsorbent for the removal of lead( ii ) and lanthanum( iii ) (Pb( ii ) and La( iii )) ions from contaminated water. Three different forms of nanocellulose adsorbents were prepared: suspension, freeze-dried, and nanocomposite containing magnetic nanoparticles, where their adsorption performance was tested against the removal of the two chosen heavy metal ions. The maximum adsorption capacity of rice husk based CNFs was found to be the highest in the nanocellulose suspension, i.e. , 193.2 mg g −1 for Pb( ii ) and 100.7 mg g −1 for La( iii ). The separation of the used adsorbent in the suspension was further facilitated by the gelation of the CNFs and metal cations, where the resulting floc could be removed by gravity-driven filtration. The absorption mechanism of the investigated CNF system is mainly due to electrostatic interactions between negatively charged carboxylate groups and multivalent metal ions. It was found that 90% lanthanum content in the form of lanthanum oxychloride (determined by X-ray powder diffraction) could be obtained by incinerating the CNF/LaCl 3 gel. This study demonstrates a viable and sustainable solution to upcycle agricultural residues into remediation nanomaterials for the removal and recovery of toxic heavy metal ions from contaminated water. 
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    High concentrations of trace metal(loid)s exported from abandoned mine wastes and acid rock drainage pose a risk to the health of aquatic ecosystems. To determine if and when the hyporheic zone mediates metal(loid) export, we investigated the relationship between streamflow, groundwater–stream connectivity, and subsurface metal(loid) concentrations in two ~1-km stream reaches within the Bonita Peak Mining District, a US Environmental Protection Agency Superfund site located near Silverton, Colorado, USA. The hyporheic zones of reaches in two streams—Mineral Creek and Cement Creek—were characterized using a combination of salt-tracer injection tests, transient-storage modeling, and geochemical sampling of the shallow streambed (<0.7 m). Based on these data, we present two conceptual models for subsurface metal(loid) behavior in the hyporheic zones, including (1) well-connected systems characterized by strong hyporheic mixing of infiltrating stream water and upwelling groundwater and (2) poorly connected systems delineated by physical barriers that limit hyporheic mixing. The comparatively large hyporheic zone and high hydraulic conductivities of Mineral Creek created a connected stream–groundwater system, where mixing of oxygen-rich stream water and metal-rich groundwater facilitated the precipitation of metal colloids in the shallow subsurface. In Cement Creek, the precipitation of iron oxides at depth (~0.4 m) created a low-hydraulic-conductivity barrier between surface water and groundwater. Cemented iron oxides were an important regulator of metal(loid) concentrations in this poorly connected stream–groundwater system due to the formation of strong redox gradients induced by a relatively small hyporheic zone and high fluid residence times. A comparison of conceptual models to stream concentration–discharge relationships exhibited a clear link between geochemical processes occurring within the hyporheic zone of the well-connected system and export of particulate Al, Cu, Fe, and Mn, while the poorly connected system did not have a notable influence on metal concentration–discharge trends. Mineral Creek is an example of a hyporheic system that serves as a natural dissolved metal(loid) sink, whereas poorly connected systems such as Cement Creek may require a combination of subsurface remediation of sediments and mitigation of upstream, iron-rich mine drainages to reduce metal export. 
    more » « less