skip to main content


Title: Proceedings of the 2018 IISE annual conference
Food insecurity affects more than 41 million people annually in the United States. Within the Feeding America network, approximately 200 food banks are working throughout the US to serve people in need with donated food. Satisfying hunger need of food insecure people with limited supply is a challenge for these food banks. A numerical study is performed on data from Food Bank of Central and Eastern North Carolina (FBCENC) to capture the major attributes controlling its food distribution system. FBCENC seeks to distribute donated food equitably so that each service area (county) receives food proportional to its demand while minimizing the undistributed food donations. In addition to seeking equitable and effective food distribution policies, FBCENC wants to identify distribution branches to maximize the accessibility of the counties to donated food. An assignment and distribution model is developed to minimize the cost of maintaining a user-specified cap on the maximum inequity in food distribution. A sensitivity analysis between the user-specified maximum inequity cap and effectiveness shows the effectiveness of donated food distribution can be improved significantly by sacrificing equitable distribution slightly.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1718672
NSF-PAR ID:
10066350
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Modeling for Efficient Assignment of Multiple Distribution Centers for the Equitable and Effective Distribution of Donated Food
Page Range / eLocation ID:
141-145
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Food banks operate with an objective to serve as many of food-insecure people as possible with the limited supply available to them. This paper presents a mixed-integer programming model to identify the efficient assignment of demand zones (counties) to distribution centers (branches) and equitable allocation of donated food from the food bank branches to the demand zones. The model objective function minimizes the total cost of branch operation, the cost of receiving and distributing food, the cost of undistributed food while maintaining the maximum allowed deviation from perfect equity. Data from the Food Bank of Central and Eastern North Carolina (FBCENC) are used to characterize the major attributes controlling the food distribution system of a food bank. Results from the optimization model using FBCENC data show that the optimal allocation under perfect equity follows a particular structure depending on the shipping cost and the cost of undistributed supply. Sensitivity analyses exploring the trade-offs between efficiency and effectiveness as a function of the cost of shipping, truck capacity, and a user-specified maximum inequity cap show that marginal sacrifice in equity can significantly improve effectiveness. The corresponding improvement in effectiveness is greater when comparatively larger trucks are used and the cost of shipping is relatively higher. The analyses also suggest that while efficiency is less sensitive to the allowable limit on the deviation from perfect equity, it is sensitive to truck size. A comparison of direct shipping to branches to operating a local hub suggests the former option to be more cost efficient. 
    more » « less
  2. According to Feeding America, prior to the pandemic, 1 in 5 African-American/Black, 1 in 6 Hispanic, and 1 in 4 Native American households were food insecure compared to 1 in 11 White households. The pandemic is expected to exacerbate these disparities given its disproportionate economic and health impact on historically marginalized racial and ethnic populations. Food banks are non-profit organizations that work to alleviate food insecurity within their service regions by distributing donated food to households in need. Equitable distribution of donated food is an important criteria for food banks. Existing food banking operations literature primarily focus on geographic equity, i.e., where each geographic block of a food bank's service region receives food in proportion to its demand. However, hunger-relief organizations such as food banks are gradually incorporating demography-based equity in their distribution of donated food in light of the disparities that exist within different demographic groups, such as race, age, and religion. However, the notion of demographic equity has not received attention in the food banking operations literature. This study aims to fill in the gap by developing a multi-criteria optimization model to identify optimal distribution policies for a food bank considering a two-dimensional equity criterion, geographic and demographic, in the presence of effectiveness (undistributed food minimization) and efficiency (distribution cost minimization) criteria. We apply the model to our partner food bank's data to (i) explore the trade-off between geographic and demographic equity as a function of effectiveness, and efficiency, and (ii) identify policy insights. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    In the United States, food banks play an important role in helping to reduce the rate of food insecurity by distributing donated food among the population in need. One of the challenges that food banks face is to equitably distribute food donations among their clients such that, ideally, each recipient receives the same amount of food. They aim to do so while minimizing waste that occurs due to spoilage and capacity limitations. Perishable food items present specific challenges since they are susceptible to spoilage and need to be distributed before their expiry dates. Based on our longstanding partnership with a large food bank located in the southeastern United States, we present a capacitated, multiperiod, multiproduct network flow model to help them equitably and effectively distribute perishable food donations among the food‐insecure population in their service region. The model is applied within the context of a case study and reveals managerial insights that would be useful to practitioners. Our findings show that although equity is one of the food bank's highest priorities, inequities cannot be eliminated completely. Given the inevitability of inequitable food allocations in practice, this paper provides food banks guidance on how to strategically control inequities using two approaches: (i) by increasing the number of periods for which equity should be satisfied or () by allowing deviations from a perfectly equitable distribution. The results show that modest deviations from perfect equity using either approach can lead to significant improvements in both the quality and quantity of food distributed and can also reduce food waste. While approach () is preferable, the most desirable outcomes occur when both are applied simultaneously. We also find that county capacities inhibit a food bank's ability to achieve balance between equity and effectiveness when distributing perishables. Our framework provides food banks the flexibility to balance the trade‐off between effectiveness and equity based on their preferences.

     
    more » « less
  4. The United Nations Sustainable Development Goals provide a road map for countries to achieve peace and prosperity. In this study, we address two of these sustainable development goals: achieving food security and reducing inequalities. Food banks are nonprofit organizations that collect and distribute food donations to food‐insecure populations in their service regions. Food banks consider three criteria while distributing the donated food: equity, effectiveness, and efficiency. The equity criterion aims to distribute food in proportion to the food‐insecure households in a food bank's service area. The effectiveness criterion aims to minimize undistributed food, whereas the efficiency criterion minimizes the total cost of transportation. Models that assume predetermined weights on these criteria may produce inaccurate results as the preference of food banks over these criteria may vary over time, and as a function of supply and demand. In collaboration with our food bank partner in North Carolina, we develop a single‐period, weighted multi‐criteria optimization model that provides the decision‐maker the flexibility to capture their preferences over the three criteria of equity, effectiveness, and efficiency, and explore the resulting trade‐offs. We then introduce a novel algorithm that elicits the inherent preference of a food bank by analyzing its actions within a single‐period. The algorithm does not require direct interaction with the decision‐maker. The non‐interactive nature of this algorithm is especially significant for humanitarian organizations such as food banks which lack the resources to interact with modelers on a regular basis. We perform extensive numerical experiments to validate the efficiency of our algorithm. We illustrate results using historical data from our food bank partner and discuss managerial insights. We explore the implications of different decision‐maker preferences for the criteria on distribution policies.

     
    more » « less
  5. The amount of food waste generated by the U.S. is staggering, both expensive in economic cost and environmental side effects. Surplus food, which could be used to feed people facing food insecurity, is instead discarded and placed in landfills. Institutions, universities, and non-profits have noticed this issue and are beginning to take action to reduce surplus food waste, typically by redirecting it to food banks and other organizations or having students transport or eat the food. These approaches present challenges such as transportation, volunteer availability, and lack of prioritization of those in need. In this paper, we introduce PittGrub, a notification system to intelligently select users to invite to events that have leftover food. PittGrub was invented to help reduce food waste at the University of Pittsburgh. We use reinforcement learning to determine how many notifications to send out and a valuation model to determine whom to prioritize in the notifications. Our goal is to produce a system that prioritizes feeding students in need while simultaneously eliminating food waste and maintaining a fair distribution of notifications. As far as we are aware, PittGrub is unique in its approach to eliminating surplus food waste while striving for social good. We compare our proposed techniques to multiple baselines on simulated datasets to demonstrate effectiveness. Experimental results among various algorithms show promise in eliminating food waste while helping those facing food insecurity and treating users fairly. Our prototype is currently in beta and coming soon to the Apple App Store. 
    more » « less