An official website of the United States government
The objective of this paper is to establish a meta-network framework to identify constituents in Disaster Management System-of-Systems (DM-SoS), conceptualize relationships and interactions among the constituents, and formulate quantitative measurements of DM-SoS performance for achieving network-centric operation and coordination in the context of disasters. With increasingly serious impacts of disasters on interdependent and heterogeneous systems, the improvement of effective and integrative disaster response and coordination is needed. However, some existing literature only proposed some frameworks for modeling disaster management systems, while another stream of studies only examined the social network analysis (SNA) for understanding the interactions between stakeholders. Thus, quantitative and integrative measurements in DM-SoS are missing. To address this knowledge gap, the authors created and discussed a metanetwork framework integrating various types of entities and relationships for quantitatively analyzing the performance of DM-SoS. First, this framework defined nodes and links in meta-metrics for abstracting constituents in disaster management. Second, some performance indicators (e.g., effectiveness, the extent of information sharing, and the extent of self-organization) were created to show the capacities of disaster systems, and the potential perturbations in disaster environment were translated by network theory. Finally, we examined the impacts of perturbations on the indicators and assessed the performance by integrating overall indicators. This study highlighted the significance of quantitative measurements and an integrative perspective on analyzing efficiency and effectiveness of disaster response and coordination. The study also provides implications for making comparisons of different response strategies for decision makers to achieve resilient disaster management systems.
more »
« less
Establishing a Framework for Disaster Management System-of-Systems
The objective of this paper is to propose a System-of- Systems (SoS) framework for disaster management systems and processes to better analyze, design and operate the heterogeneous, interconnected, and distributed systems involved in disasters. With increasing frequency and severity of disasters, improvement of efficiency and effectiveness of disaster management systems and processes is critical. However, the current approaches for conceptualization and analysis of disaster management processes do not provide a holistic perspective for analysis of multiple heterogeneous systems and processes that are interconnected and embedded in networks across various spatial and temporal scales. In this paper, a disaster management system-of-systems (DM-SoS) framework was proposed to identify the dimensions of analysis and characteristics towards a more integrative approach to disaster management. Three dimensions of analysis (definition, abstraction, and implementation) and their corresponding components for examining disaster management SoS are explored. The DM-SoS framework would enable specification and characterization of system attributes and interdependencies, as well as capturing emergent properties and cross-scale interactions.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1759537
- PAR ID:
- 10075881
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- IEEE SysCon
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
ObjectiveWe aimed to identify opportunities for application of human factors knowledge base to mitigate disaster management (DM) challenges associated with the unique characteristics of the COVID-19 pandemic. BackgroundThe role of DM is to minimize and prevent further spread of the contagion over an extended period of time. This requires addressing large-scale logistics, coordination, and specialized training needs. However, DM-related challenges during the pandemic response and recovery are significantly different than with other kinds of disasters. MethodAn expert review was conducted to document issues relevant to human factors and ergonomics (HFE) in DM. ResultsThe response to the COVID-19 crisis has presented complex and unique challenges to DM and public health practitioners. Compared to other disasters and previous pandemics, the COVID-19 outbreak has had an unprecedented scale, magnitude, and propagation rate. The high technical complexity of response and DM coupled with lack of mental model and expertise to respond to such a unique disaster has seriously challenged the response work systems. Recent research has investigated the role of HFE in modeling DM systems’ characteristics to improve resilience, accelerating emergency management expertise, developing agile training methods to facilitate dynamically changing response, improving communication and coordination among system elements, mitigating occupational hazards including guidelines for the design of personal protective equipment, and improving procedures to enhance efficiency and effectiveness of response efforts. ConclusionThis short review highlights the potential for the field’s contribution to proactive and resilient DM for the ongoing and future pandemics.more » « less
-
The social media have been increasingly used for disaster management (DM) via providing real time data on a broad scale. For example, some smartphone applications (e.g. Disaster Alert and Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) App) can be used to increase the efficiency of prepositioning supplies and to enhance the effectiveness of disaster relief efforts. To maximize utilities of these apps, it is imperative to have robust human behavior models in social networks with detailed expressions of individual decision-making processes and of the interactions among people. In this paper, we introduce a hierarchical human behavior model by associating extended Decision Field Theory (e-DFT) with the opinion formation and innovation diffusion models. Particularly, its expressiveness and validity are addressed in three ways. First, we estimate individual’s choice patterns in social networks by deriving people’s asymptotic choice probabilities within e-DFT. Second, by analyzing opinion formation models and innovation diffusion models in different types of social networks, the effects of neighbor’s opinions on people and their interactions are demonstrated. Finally, an agent-based simulation is used to trace agents’ dynamic behaviors in different scenarios. The simulated results reveal that the proposed models can be used to establish better disaster management strategies in natural disasters.more » « less
-
Debris removal is a critical activity in the aftermath of natural disasters such as earthquakes and tsunamis to enable community and lifeline network recovery. This activity is hampered by logistical bottlenecks including the non-availability of equipment and inadequate capacity of temporary debris management sites (TDMS). This paper enables analysis of debris removal and lifeline repair operations quantifying recovery times for informed decision-making about equipment allocation and TDMS selection before the disaster. The developed framework was applied to the case study of a Cascadia Subduction Zone event for the coastal town of Astoria in Oregon. The proposed framework enables decision-makers with an objective means of evaluating decision alternatives both before and after disasters to analyze and improve their community’s capability of handling disaster debris. Furthermore, this framework will serve as a platform upon which interdependencies between transportation network and debris removal operations will be analyzed in the future.more » « less
-
Unstructured construction sites including incomplete structures and unsecured resources (e.g., materials, equipment, and temporary facilities) are among the most vulnerable environments to windstorms such as hurricanes. Wind-induced cascading damages cause substantial losses, disruption, and considerable schedule delays in construction projects. Moreover, this would negatively affect neighboring buildings and interdependent infrastructures (e.g., electric power transmission or transportation systems), which triggers serious economic losses in our community. Nonetheless, prior works on disaster management mainly focused on post-disaster assessment and reconstruction process of built environments, and thus predicting potential risks associated with expected disasters for proactive preparedness remain largely unknown. This paper presents a new Imaging-to-Simulation framework that can uncover potential risks of wind-induced cascading damages to construction projects and their negative impacts on neighboring communities. The outcomes are expected to benefit our society as it will enhance current windstorm preparedness and mitigation plans, which ultimately promote public safety, property loss reduction, insurance cost reduction, and raise awareness of ‘Culture of Preparedness’ for disasters.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- The DOI is not currently available.
