skip to main content


Title: Simulation of Ductile Fracture Propagation in Structural Steel Subjected to Ultra-Low Cycle Fatigue
While considerable progress has been made in simulating the overall seismic response of steel structures using nonlinear response history (dynamic) analysis, techniques to simulate fracture propagation under large scale inelastic cyclic loading are not as well developed. This is despite the fact that fracture is often a critical limit state that can precipitate structural failure and collapse. To address this, a new ductile damage-based cohesive zone model is presented. The proposed model is an extension of the established continuum-based local or micromechanical ductile fracture models for evaluating ultra-low cycle fatigue in structural steels. This model is implemented in the finite element program WARP3D, and evaluated against tests of notched bars that fail by ductile crack propagation. The preliminary results indicate that the model is an effective tool for predicting ductile fracture initiation and propagation in structural steels subjected to monotonic and cyclic large scale inelastic loading. Implications of this for characterizing the post-fracture response of structural steel components are discussed, along with limitations of the research.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1635043
NSF-PAR ID:
10079310
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Eleventh U.S. National Conference on Earthquake Engineering
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. While considerable progress has been made in simulating the overall seismic response of steel structures using nonlinear response history (dynamic) analysis, techniques to simulate fracture propagation under large scale inelastic cyclic loading are not as well developed. This is despite the fact that fracture is often a critical limit state that can precipitate structural failure and collapse. To address this, a new ductile damage-based cohesive zone model is presented. The proposed model is an extension of the established continuum-based local or micromechanical ductile fracture models for evaluating ultra-low cycle fatigue in structural steels. This model is implemented in the finite element program WARP3D, and evaluated against tests of notched bars that fail by ductile crack propagation. The preliminary results indicate that the model is an effective tool for predicting ductile fracture initiation and propagation in structural steels subjected to monotonic and cyclic large scale inelastic loading. Implications of this for characterizing the post-fracture response of structural steel components are discussed, along with limitations of the research. 
    more » « less
  2. While considerable progress has been made in simulating the overall seismic response of steel structures using nonlinear response history (dynamic) analysis, techniques to simulate fracture propagation under large scale inelastic cyclic loading are not as well developed. This is despite the fact that fracture is often a critical limit state that can precipitate structural failure and collapse. To address this, a new ductile damage-based cohesive zone model is presented. The proposed model is an extension of the established continuum-based local or micromechanical ductile fracture models for evaluating ultra-low cycle fatigue in structural steels. This model is implemented in the finite element program WARP3D, and evaluated against tests of notched bars that fail by ductile crack propagation. The preliminary results indicate that the model is an effective tool for predicting ductile fracture initiation and propagation in structural steels subjected to monotonic and cyclic large scale inelastic loading. Implications of this for characterizing the post-fracture response of structural steel components are discussed, along with limitations of the research. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Micromechanics‐based continuum damage criteria have previously been developed to simulate the initiation of ductile fracture in structural steels under conditions with large‐scale plasticity where conventional fracture mechanics indices are invalid. Such models have been combined with methods to simulate ductile crack growth for monotonic loading. In this study, a micromechanics‐based adaptive cohesive zone model for simulating ductile crack propagation under monotonic loading is extended to handle cyclic loading. The proposed model adaptively modifies the cohesive traction–separation relationship for crack opening and closure, as the loading reverses between tension and compression. The approach is implemented into the finite element analysis platform WARP3D, and results of simulations that use the model are compared with data from coupon‐scale tests. The results demonstrate that the proposed model can accurately simulate the effect of crack propagation on specimen response, as well as other key aspects of observed behavior, including crack face closure and crack tunneling.

     
    more » « less
  4. Since their first use in Japan about thirty years ago, Buckling Restrained Braces (BRBs) have been widely implemented in steel-framed buildings throughout the world. To date, most of the development and validation of BRB ductility has relied extensively on testing of full-scale braces under cyclic loading since no fracture evaluation method based on underlying micromechanics is currently available. Therefore, research is currently being undertaken to develop, validate and apply detailed finite element models to computationally simulate ductile fracture initiation and propagation in BRBs. As a part of this research, this paper presents an evaluation methodology of ductile fracture initiation using an Ultra-Low Cyclic Fatigue criterion, referred to as the Stress Weighted Damage Model (SWDM), along with detailed finite element analysis of BRBs. 
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    Advanced high strength dual-phase steels are one of the most widely sought-after structural materials for automotive applications. These high strength steels, however, are prone to fracture under bending-dominated manufacturing processes. Experimental observations suggest that the bendability of these steels is sensitive to the presence of subsurface non-metallic inclusions and the inclusions exhibit a rather discrete size effect on the bendability of these steels. Following this, we have carried out a series of microstructure-based finite element calculations of ductile fracture in an advanced high strength dual-phase steel under bending. In the calculations, both the dual-phase microstructure and inclusion are discretely modeled. To gain additional insight, we have also analyzed the effect of an inclusion on the bendability of a single-phase material. In line with the experimental observations, strong inclusion size effect on the bendability of the dual-phase steel naturally emerge in the calculations. Furthermore, supervised machine learning is used to quantify the effects of the multivariable input space associated with the dual-phase microstructure and inclusion on the bendability of the steel. The results of the supervised machine learning are then used to identify the contributions of individual features and isolate critical features that control the bendability of dual-phase steels. 
    more » « less