skip to main content


Title: Benchmark seasonal prediction skill estimates based on regional indices
Abstract. Basic statistical metrics such as autocorrelations and across-region lagcorrelations of sea ice variations provide benchmarks for the assessments offorecast skill achieved by other methods such as more sophisticatedstatistical formulations, numerical models, and heuristic approaches. In thisstudy we use observational data to evaluate the contribution of the trend tothe skill of persistence-based statistical forecasts of monthly and seasonalice extent on the pan-Arctic and regional scales. We focus on the BeaufortSea for which the Barnett Severity Index provides a metric of historicalvariations in ice conditions over the summer shipping season. The varianceabout the trend line differs little among various methods of detrending(piecewise linear, quadratic, cubic, exponential). Application of thepiecewise linear trend calculation indicates an acceleration of the winterand summer trends during the 1990s. Persistence-based statistical forecastsof the Barnett Severity Index as well as September pan-Arctic ice extent showsignificant statistical skill out to several seasons when the data includethe trend. However, this apparent skill largely vanishes when the data aredetrended. In only a few regions does September ice extent correlatesignificantly with antecedent ice anomalies in the same region more than 2months earlier. The springtime “predictability barrier” in regionalforecasts based on persistence of ice extent anomalies is not reduced by theinclusion of several decades of pre-satellite data. No region showssignificant correlation with the detrended September pan-Arctic ice extent atlead times greater than a month or two; the concurrent correlations arestrongest with the East Siberian Sea. The Beaufort Sea's ice extent as farback as July explains about 20 % of the variance of the Barnett SeverityIndex, which is primarily a September metric. The Chukchi Sea is the onlyother region showing a significant association with the Barnett SeverityIndex, although only at a lead time of a month or two.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1749081
NSF-PAR ID:
10127274
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
The Cryosphere
Volume:
13
Issue:
4
ISSN:
1994-0424
Page Range / eLocation ID:
1073 to 1088
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Seasonal predictability of the minimum sea ice extent (SIE) in the Laptev Sea is investigated using winter coastal divergence as a predictor. From February to May, the new ice forming in wind-driven coastal polynyas grows to a thickness approximately equal to the climatological thickness loss due to summer thermodynamic processes. Estimating the area of sea ice that is preconditioned to melt enables seasonal predictability of the minimum SIE. Wintertime ice motion is quantified by seeding passive tracers along the coastlines and advecting them with the Lagrangian Ice Tracking System (LITS) forced with sea ice drifts from the Polar Pathfinder dataset for years 1992–2016. LITS-derived landfast ice estimates are comparable to those of the Russian Arctic and Antarctic Research Institute ice charts. Time series of the minimum SIE and coastal divergence show trends of −24.2% and +31.3% per decade, respectively. Statistically significant correlation ( r = −0.63) between anomalies of coastal divergence and the following September SIE occurs for coastal divergence integrated from February to the beginning of May. Using the coastal divergence anomaly to predict the minimum SIE departure from the trend improves the explained variance by 21% compared to hindcasts based on persistence of the linear trend. Coastal divergence anomalies correlate with the winter mean Arctic Oscillation index ( r = 0.69). LITS-derived areas of coastal divergence tend to underestimate the total area covered by thin ice in the CryoSat-2/SMOS (Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity) thickness dataset, as suggested by a thermodynamic sea ice growth model.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    The Bering Strait oceanic heat transport influences seasonal sea ice retreat and advance in the Chukchi Sea. Monitored since 1990, it depends on water temperature and factors controlling the volume transport, assumed to be local winds in the strait and an oceanic pressure difference between the Pacific and Arctic oceans (the “pressure head”). Recent work suggests that variability in the pressure head, especially during summer, relates to the strength of the zonal wind in the East Siberian Sea that raises or drops sea surface height in this area via Ekman transport. We confirm that westward winds in the East Siberian Sea relate to a broader central Arctic pattern of high sea level pressure and note that anticyclonic winds over the central Arctic Ocean also favor low September sea ice extent for the Arctic as a whole by promoting ice convergence and positive temperature anomalies. Month‐to‐month persistence in the volume transport and atmospheric circulation patterns is low, but the period 1980–2017 had a significant summertime (June–August) trend toward higher sea level pressure over the central Arctic Ocean, favoring increased transports. Some recent large heat transports are associated with high water temperatures, consistent with persistence of open water in the Chukchi Sea into winter and early ice retreat in spring. The highest heat transport recorded, October 2016, resulted from high water temperatures and ideal wind conditions yielding a record‐high volume transport. November and December 2005, the only months with southward volume (and thus heat) transports, were associated with southward winds in the strait.

     
    more » « less
  3. null (Ed.)
    Each Arctic summer since 2008, the Sea Ice Outlook (SIO) has invited researchers and the engaged public to contribute predictions regarding the September extent of Arctic sea ice. Then, each September, we see the accuracy or inaccuracy of those predictions. More than 1,000 individual predictions, based on many different methods, were contributed from 2008 to 2020. Earlier papers analyzed the ensemble skill of the first few hundred SIO contributions through 2013 ( Stroeve et al. 2014) and through 2015 ( Hamilton & Stroeve 2016). Here, I bring those analyses up to date with data through 2020. The main conclusions from earlier papers have proven to be robust, but unexpected new insights emerged as well. The long term downward trend in ice extent is reasonably well described as linear (R2 = 0.79) or quadratic (R2 = 0.81). Very large changes from the previous year’s extent in 2012 and 2013 resulted in the largest prediction errors. Both errors reflect one 2012 cyclone. For reasons not yet understood, SIO predictions especially those from dynamic modeling predict the previous year’s extent rather than the current year. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Observations show predictive skill of the minimum sea ice extent (Min SIE) from late winter anomalous offshore ice drift along the Eurasian coastline, leading to local ice thickness anomalies at the onset of the melt season—a signal then amplified by the ice–albedo feedback. We assess whether the observed seasonal predictability of September sea ice extent (Sept SIE) from Fram Strait Ice Area Export (FSIAE; a proxy for Eurasian coastal divergence) is present in global climate model (GCM) large ensembles, namely the CESM2-LE, GISS-E2.1-G, FLOR-LE, CNRM-CM6-1, and CanESM5. All models show distinct periods where winter FSIAE anomalies are negatively correlated with the May sea ice thickness (May SIT) anomalies along the Eurasian coastline, and the following Sept Arctic SIE, as in observations. Counterintuitively, several models show occasional periods where winter FSIAE anomalies are positively correlated with the following Sept SIE anomalies when the mean ice thickness is large, or late in the simulation when the sea ice is thin, and/or when internal variability increases. More important, periods with weak correlation between winter FSIAE and the following Sept SIE dominate, suggesting that summer melt processes generally dominate over late-winter preconditioning and May SIT anomalies. In general, we find that the coupling between the winter FSIAE and ice thickness anomalies along the Eurasian coastline at the onset of the melt season is a ubiquitous feature of GCMs and that the relationship with the following Sept SIE is dependent on the mean Arctic sea ice thickness.

     
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    Abstract Compared to the Arctic, seasonal predictions of Antarctic sea ice have received relatively little attention. In this work, we utilize three coupled dynamical prediction systems developed at the Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory to assess the seasonal prediction skill and predictability of Antarctic sea ice. These systems, based on the FLOR, SPEAR_LO, and SPEAR_MED dynamical models, differ in their coupled model components, initialization techniques, atmospheric resolution, and model biases. Using suites of retrospective initialized seasonal predictions spanning 1992–2018, we investigate the role of these factors in determining Antarctic sea ice prediction skill and examine the mechanisms of regional sea ice predictability. We find that each system is capable of skillfully predicting regional Antarctic sea ice extent (SIE) with skill that exceeds a persistence forecast. Winter SIE is skillfully predicted 11 months in advance in the Weddell, Amundsen and Bellingshausen, Indian, and West Pacific sectors, whereas winter skill is notably lower in the Ross sector. Zonally advected upper ocean heat content anomalies are found to provide the crucial source of prediction skill for the winter sea ice edge position. The recently-developed SPEAR systems are more skillful than FLOR for summer sea ice predictions, owing to improvements in sea ice concentration and sea ice thickness initialization. Summer Weddell SIE is skillfully predicted up to 9 months in advance in SPEAR_MED, due to the persistence and drift of initialized sea ice thickness anomalies from the previous winter. Overall, these results suggest a promising potential for providing operational Antarctic sea ice predictions on seasonal timescales. 
    more » « less