skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Reducing surface roughness of Nb3Sn through chemical polishing treatments
Niobium-3 tin (Nb3Sn) is a promising alternative material for SRF cavities, with theoretical limits for critical temperatures and superheating fields reaching twice that of conventional Nb cavities. However, currently achievable accelerating gradients in Nb3Sn cavities are much lower than their theoretical limit. One limitation to the maximum accelerating gradient is surface magnetic field enhancement caused by the surface roughness of Nb3Sn. However, there are currently no standard techniques used to reduce Nb3Sn surface roughness. Since Nb3Sn is only 2-3 microns thick, it is difficult to selectively polish Nb3Sn without removing the entire layer. Here, we investigate reducing the surface roughness of Nb3Sn through applying chemical polishing treatments, including modified versions of standard techniques such as Buffered Chemical Polishing (BCP) and Electropolishing (EP). Through data acquired from Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) scans, SEM scans, and SEM-EDS analysis, we show the effects of these chemical treatments in reducing surface roughness and consider the changes in the chemical composition of Nb3Sn that may occur through the etching process. We find that BCP with a 1:1:8 solution is ineffective while EP halves the surface roughness of Nb3Sn.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1719875
PAR ID:
10147646
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Conference on RF Superconductivity
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract This research investigates the feasibility of electroless nickel deposition on additively manufactured stainless steel samples. The prevalent additive manufacturing techniques for metal components generate a surface with rough characteristics, which can result in a higher likelihood of fatigue and the initiation of cracks or fractures in the printed part. As a result, using as-manufactured components in the final product is impractical, which requires post-processing to create a smoother surface. This study assesses chempolishing (CP) and Electropolish (EP) techniques for post-processing additively manufactured stainless steel components. CP is a purely chemical process that involves continuous anodization of the sample, resulting in oxidation-reduction. CP has a significant advantage in creating a uniform and smooth surface, irrespective of the size or geometry of the component. Conversely, EP is an electrochemical process that necessitates an electric current to facilitate polishing. EP produces an exceptionally smooth surface that reduces surface roughness to a sub-micrometer level. We observed that EP and CP techniques reduced the surface roughness’s arithmetical mean height (Ra) by up to 4 μm and 10 μm, respectively. In this study, we investigate the application of electroless nickel deposition on additively manufactured (AM) components using different surface finishing techniques, including electro-polishing (EP), chemo-polishing (CP), and as-built components. Electroless nickel plating aims to enhance the surface hardness and resistance of manufactured components to withstand harsh environmental conditions. The electroless nickel plating process is less complicated than electroplating and does not require using an electric current through the chemical bath solution for nickel deposition. For this study, we used low-phosphorus (2–5% P), medium-phosphorus (6–9% P), and high-phosphorus (10–13% P) nickel solutions. We used the L9 Taguchi design of experiments (TDOE) to optimize these Ni deposition experiments, which consider solution content, surface finish, geometry plane, and bath temperature. The pre- and post-processed surfaces of the AM parts were analyzed using the KEYENCE Digital Microscope VHX-7000 and Phenom XL Desktop SEM. We apply a machine learning-based instance segmentation technique to improve the identification of nickel deposition and surface topology of microscopic images. Our experiments show that electroless nickel deposition produces uniform Ni coating on the additively manufactured components at up to 20 μm per hour. Mechanical properties of as-built and Ni-coated AM samples were evaluated using a standard 10 N scratch test. It was found that the nickel-coated AM samples were up to two times more scratch-resistant than the as-built samples. Based on our findings, we conclude that electroless nickel plating is a robust and viable option for surface hardening and finishing AM components for various applications and operating conditions. 
    more » « less
  2. Electroless coating brings the advantage of providing films on the complex geometry of additively manufactured components. However, there is a knowledge gap about the impact of AM part surface and postprocessing parameters on the quality of electroless coating. This study explores the application of three solution-based surface finishing techniques on the microstructure and surface hardness of additively manufactured stainless steel components coated with electroless nickel films. Given that AM techniques for metal parts often yield surfaces with inherently rough textures and differences in properties along the different planes, we investigated their relationship with nickel coating. To mitigate the impact of surface irregularities on electroless nickel coating quality, this research evaluated the effectiveness of chemical polishing (CP) and Electropolishing (EP) as post-processing treatments for AM stainless steel. Characterization of the treated samples was conducted using the analytical Digital Microscope, Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM), and scratch tester. Additionally, the study incorporated an instant segmentation machine learning algorithm to overcome image analysis challenges. The findings indicate that EP and CP significantly improve surface smoothness, decreasing the arithmetical mean height (Ra) by as much as 4 µm and 10 µm, respectively. Furthermore, the nickel-coated AM samples demonstrated an enhancement in scratch resistance, exhibiting up to a two-fold increase in surface hardness compared to their as-built counterparts. Taguchi design of the experiment was applied to investigate the effect of process parameters. This study provides insights for developing improved surface quality and acquiring new properties via the coating process to make AM parts suitable for challenging environments and novel applications. 
    more » « less
  3. This paper presents a study of the grinding of three different grades of silicon carbide (SiC) under the same conditions. Surface topography is analyzed using coherent scanning interferometry and scanning electron microscopy. The study provides a baseline understanding of the process mechanics and targets effective selection of process parameters for grinding SiC optics with near optical level surface roughness, thus reducing the need for post-polishing. Samples are raster and spiral ground on conventional precision machines with metal and copper-resin bonded wheels under rough, medium, and finish grinding conditions. Material microstructure and grinding conditions affect attainable surface roughness. Local surface roughness of less than 3 nm RMS was attained in both chemical vapor deposition (CVD) and chemical vapor composite (CVC) SiC. The tool footprint is suitable for sub-aperture machining of a large freeform optics possibly without the need for surface finish correction by post-polishing. Subsurface damage will be assessed in Part 2 of this paper series. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract Polishing of additively manufactured products is a multi-stage process, and a different combination of polishing pad and process parameters is employed at each stage. Pad change decisions and endpoint determination currently rely on practitioners’ experience and subjective visual inspection of surface quality. An automated and objective decision process is more desired for delivering consistency and reducing variability. Toward that objective, a model-guided decision-making scheme is developed in this article for the polishing process of a titanium alloy workpiece. The model used is a series of Gaussian process models, each established for a polishing stage at which surface data are gathered. The series of Gaussian process models appear capable of capturing surface changes and variation over the polishing process, resulting in a decision protocol informed by the correlation characteristics over the sample surface. It is found that low correlations reveal the existence of extreme roughness that may be deemed surface defects. Making judicious use of the change pattern in surface correlation provides insights enabling timely actions. Physical polishing of titanium alloy samples and a simulation of this process are used together to demonstrate the merit of the proposed method. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract Workbench-size particle accelerators, enabled by Nb3Sn-based superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities, hold the potential of driving scientific discovery by offering a widely accessible and affordable source of high-energy electrons and x-rays. Thin-film Nb3Sn RF superconductors with high quality factors, high operation temperatures, and high-field potentials are critical for these devices. However, surface roughness, non-stoichiometry, and impurities in Nb3Sn deposited by conventional Sn-vapor diffusion prevent them from reaching their theoretical capabilities. Here we demonstrate a seed-free electrochemical synthesis that pushes the limit of chemical and physical properties in Nb3Sn. Utilization of electrochemical Sn pre-deposits reduces the roughness of converted Nb3Sn by five times compared to typical vapor-diffused Nb3Sn. Quantitative mappings using chemical and atomic probes confirm improved stoichiometry and minimized impurity concentrations in electrochemically synthesized Nb3Sn. We have successfully applied this Nb3Sn to the large-scale 1.3 GHz SRF cavity and demonstrated ultra-low BCS surface resistances at multiple operation temperatures, notably lower than vapor-diffused cavities. Our smooth, homogeneous, high-purity Nb3Sn provides the route toward high efficiency and high fields for SRF applications under helium-free cryogenic operations. 
    more » « less