An official website of the United States government
Nutrient pollution remains one of the greatest threats to water quality and imposes numerous public health and ecological concerns. Phosphate, the most common form of phosphorus, is one of the key nutrients necessary for plant growth. However, phosphate concentration in water should be carefully monitored for environmental protection requirements. Hence, an easy-to-use, field-deployable, and reliable device is needed to measure phosphate concentrations in the field. In this study, an inexpensive dip strip is developed for the detection of low concentrations of phosphate in water and seawater. In this device, ascorbic acid/antimony reagent was dried on blotting paper, which served as the detection zone, and was followed by a wet chemistry protocol using the molybdenum method. Ammonium molybdate and sulfuric acid were separately stored in liquid form to significantly improve the lifetime of the device and enhance the reproducibility of its performance. The device was tested with deionized water and Sargasso Sea seawater. The limits of detection and quantification for the optimized device using a desktop scanner were 0.134 ppm and 0.472 ppm for phosphate in water and 0.438 ppm and 1.961 ppm in seawater, respectively. The use of the portable infrared lightbox previously developed at our lab improved the limits of detection and quantification by a factor of three and were 0.156 ppm and 0.769 ppm for the Sargasso Sea seawater. The device’s shelf life, storage conditions, and limit of detection are superior to what was previously reported for the paper-based phosphate detection devices.
more »
« less
A Paper-Based Device for Ultrasensitive, Colorimetric Phosphate Detection in Seawater
High concentrations of certain nutrients, including phosphate, are known to lead to undesired algal growth and low dissolved oxygen levels, creating deadly conditions for organisms in marine ecosystems. The rapid and robust detection of these nutrients using a colorimetric, paper-based system that can be applied on-site is of high interest to individuals monitoring marine environments and others affected by marine ecosystem health. Several techniques for detecting phosphate have been reported previously, yet these techniques often suffer from high detection limits, reagent instability, and the need of the user to handle toxic reagents. In order to develop improved phosphate detection methods, the commonly used molybdenum blue reagents were incorporated into a paper-based, colorimetric detection system. This system benefited from improved stabilization of the molybdenum blue reagent as well as minimal user contact with toxic reagents. The colorimetric readout from the paper-based devices was analyzed and quantified using RGB analyses (via ImageJ), and resulted in the detection of phosphate at detection limits between 1.3 and 2.8 ppm in various aqueous media, including real seawater.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1655221
- PAR ID:
- 10158788
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Sensors
- Volume:
- 20
- Issue:
- 10
- ISSN:
- 1424-8220
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 2766
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
null (Ed.)In this paper, we report the development of a portable and inexpensive infrared lightbox for improving the detection limits of paper-based phosphate devices. Commercial paper-based devices utilize the molybdenum blue protocol to detect phosphate in the environment. Although these devices are easy to use and have a long shelf life, their main deficiency is their low sensitivity based on the qualitative results obtained via a color chart. To improve the results, we constructed a compact infrared lightbox that communicates wirelessly with a smartphone. The system measures the absorbance of radiation for the molybdenum blue reaction in the infrared region of the spectrum. It consists of a lightbox illuminated by four infrared light-emitting diodes, an infrared digital camera, a Raspberry Pi microcontroller, a mini-router, and an iPhone to control the microcontroller. An iPhone application was also developed to analyze images captured by the infrared camera in order to quantify phosphate concentrations. Additionally, the app connects to an online data center to present a highly scalable worldwide system for tracking and analyzing field measurements. In this study, the detection limits for two popular commercial devices were improved by a factor of 4 for the Quantofix devices (from 1.3 ppm using visible light to 300 ppb using infrared illumination) and a factor of 6 for the Indigo units (from 9.2 ppm to 1.4 ppm) with repeatability of less than or equal to 1.2% relative standard deviation (RSD). The system also provides more granular concentration information compared to the discrete color chart used by commercial devices and it can be easily adapted for use in other applications.more » « less
-
High-resolution, autonomous monitoring of phosphate and silicate in the marine environment is essential to understand their complex dynamics and implications for the functioning of marine ecosystems. In the absence of dependable reagent-less sensors for these nutrients, leveraging established colorimetric techniques using miniaturized analyzers, such as programmable Flow Injection (pFI), offers the best immediate solution to meet oceanographic accuracy and precision standards. In this work, we further optimize the phosphomolybdate and silicomolybdate assays recently adapted for use with pFI, laying the groundwork for the technique’s use for long-term, autonomous operations. For both assays, we show that only a narrow range of acidities and molybdate concentrations can maximize sensitivity while minimizing salt effects. In addition, we demonstrate the stability of our optimized colorimetric reagent formulations, ensuring that analytical sensitivity remains within 10% of initial levels for at least 35 days of continuous use. We then applied our optimized protocols to produce oceanographically consistent phosphate and silicate profiles at the Hawaii Ocean Time Series (HOTS) and Southern Ocean Time Series (SOTS), respectively, which compared favorably against a reference method and historical data. Using certified reference materials for nutrients in seawater, we show that our pFI protocols, optimized for long-term operations, achieve a shipboard precision better than 6% and a relative combined uncertainty (k=1) of 4.5% for phosphate (0.45 - 2.95 µmol L-1) and 6.2% for silicate (2.2 to 103 µmol L-1). To demonstrate pFI’s potential as a versatile tool for autonomous monitoring, we report a five-day hourly phosphate time series at a coastal shore station in central California (n=121 analyses), examine phosphate uptake by seaweed at five-minute intervals at a seaweed aquaculture facility (n=103), and discuss a unique, high-resolution surface silicate transect spanning multiple frontal zones in the Australian sector of the Southern Ocean (n=249). These data, obtained using a commercially available pFI analyzer, confirm that pFI is a viable technology for autonomous monitoring of phosphate and silicate, paving the way for more ambitious, long-term deployments in a variety of settings.more » « less
-
The silicate (Si) molybdenum blue method was modified by combining oxalate and ascorbic acid into a single reagent and was used for determining Si in sea water samples. The first step of this automated assay protocol was designed to perform either a calibration by a single Si standard prepared in deionized (DI) water, or to dilute samples in the range of 0–160 μM Si to fit into 0–20 μM Si calibration range using a 20 cm flow cell. By designing the assay protocol to function in batch mode, the influence of salinity on calibration was eliminated, thus making the method suitable for analysis of samples collected in the open ocean, coastal areas, or rivers. Reproducibility and accuracy of this method were evaluated by analysis of certified sea water reference materials. Phosphate (P) does not interfere significantly if the Si:P ratio is 4:1 or larger. The limit of detection was 514 nM Si, r.s.d. 2.1 %, sampling frequency 40 s/h, reagent consumption 700 μL/sample, and using deionized water as the carrier solution.more » « less
-
Monitoring chemical levels is crucial for safeguarding both the environment and public health. Elevated levels of ammonia, for instance, can harm both humans and aquatic ecosystems, often indicating contamination from agriculture, industry, or sewage. Developing portable, high-resolution, and affordable methods for in situ monitoring of ammonia is thus imperative. Plasmonic sensors offer a promising solution, detecting ammonia by correlating changes in their optical response to the target analyte’s concentration. While they are highly sensitive and can be fabricated in a variety of portable and user-friendly formats, some still require reagents or expensive optical equipment, which hinder their widespread adoption. Here, we present a self-assembled nanoplasmonic colorimetric sensor capable of directly detecting ammonia concentrations in aqueous matrices. The proposed sensor exploits the plasmonic resonance of the nanostructures to transduce changes in the chemical environment into alterations in color, offering a label-free method for real-time analysis. The sensor is fabricated using a self-assembling technique compatible with low-cost mass production based on aluminum and aluminum oxide, ensuring affordability and avoiding the use of other toxic chemicals. We developed a model to predict ammonia concentrations based on visible color change of the sensor, achieving a detection limit of 8.5 ppm. Furthermore, to address the need for on-site detection, we integrated smartphone technology for real-time color change analysis, eliminating the need for expensive, bulky optical instruments. Indeed, our approach offers a cost-effective, portable, and user-friendly solution for ammonia detection in water without the need for chemical reagents or spectrometers, making it ideal for field applications. Interestingly, this platform extends its applicability beyond ammonia detection, enabling the monitoring of various chemicals using a smartphone, without the need for any additional costly equipment.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.3390/s20102766
