skip to main content


Title: Data-Driven Models Reveal Mutant Cell Behaviors Important for Myxobacterial Aggregation
ABSTRACT Single mutations frequently alter several aspects of cell behavior but rarely reveal whether a particular statistically significant change is biologically significant. To determine which behavioral changes are most important for multicellular self-organization, we devised a new methodology using Myxococcus xanthus as a model system. During development, myxobacteria coordinate their movement to aggregate into spore-filled fruiting bodies. We investigate how aggregation is restored in two mutants, csgA and pilC , that cannot aggregate unless mixed with wild-type (WT) cells. To this end, we use cell tracking to follow the movement of fluorescently labeled cells in combination with data-driven agent-based modeling. The results indicate that just like WT cells, both mutants bias their movement toward aggregates and reduce motility inside aggregates. However, several aspects of mutant behavior remain uncorrected by WT, demonstrating that perfect recreation of WT behavior is unnecessary. In fact, synergies between errant behaviors can make aggregation robust. IMPORTANCE Self-organization into spatial patterns is evident in many multicellular phenomena. Even for the best-studied systems, our ability to dissect the mechanisms driving coordinated cell movement is limited. While genetic approaches can identify mutations perturbing multicellular patterns, the diverse nature of the signaling cues coupled to significant heterogeneity of individual cell behavior impedes our ability to mechanistically connect genes with phenotype. Small differences in the behaviors of mutant strains could be irrelevant or could sometimes lead to large differences in the emergent patterns. Here, we investigate rescue of multicellular aggregation in two mutant strains of Myxococcus xanthus mixed with wild-type cells. The results demonstrate how careful quantification of cell behavior coupled to data-driven modeling can identify specific motility features responsible for cell aggregation and thereby reveal important synergies and compensatory mechanisms. Notably, mutant cells do not need to precisely recreate wild-type behaviors to achieve complete aggregation.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1903275 2019745 1856742
NSF-PAR ID:
10175165
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
mSystems
Volume:
5
Issue:
4
ISSN:
2379-5077
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Tullman-Ercek, Danielle (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT A wide range of biological systems, from microbial swarms to bird flocks, display emergent behaviors driven by coordinated movement of individuals. To this end, individual organisms interact by recognizing their kin and adjusting their motility based on others around them. However, even in the best-studied systems, the mechanistic basis of the interplay between kin recognition and motility coordination is not understood. Here, using a combination of experiments and mathematical modeling, we uncover the mechanism of an emergent social behavior in Myxococcus xanthus . By overexpressing the cell surface adhesins TraA and TraB, which are involved in kin recognition, large numbers of cells adhere to one another and form organized macroscopic circular aggregates that spin clockwise or counterclockwise. Mechanistically, TraAB adhesion results in sustained cell-cell contacts that trigger cells to suppress cell reversals, and circular aggregates form as the result of cells’ ability to follow their own cellular slime trails. Furthermore, our in silico simulations demonstrate a remarkable ability to predict self-organization patterns when phenotypically distinct strains are mixed. For example, defying naive expectations, both models and experiments found that strains engineered to overexpress different and incompatible TraAB adhesins nevertheless form mixed circular aggregates. Therefore, this work provides key mechanistic insights into M. xanthus social interactions and demonstrates how local cell contacts induce emergent collective behaviors by millions of cells. IMPORTANCE In many species, large populations exhibit emergent behaviors whereby all related individuals move in unison. For example, fish in schools can all dart in one direction simultaneously to avoid a predator. Currently, it is impossible to explain how such animals recognize kin through brain cognition and elicit such behaviors at a molecular level. However, microbes also recognize kin and exhibit emergent collective behaviors that are experimentally tractable. Here, using a model social bacterium, we engineer dispersed individuals to organize into synchronized collectives that create emergent patterns. With experimental and mathematical approaches, we explain how this occurs at both molecular and population levels. The results demonstrate how the combination of local physical interactions triggers intracellular signaling, which in turn leads to emergent behaviors on a population scale. 
    more » « less
  2. RodrĂ­guez-Verdugo, Alejandra (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT

    The soil bacteriumMyxococcus xanthusis a model organism with a set of diverse behaviors. These behaviors include the starvation-induced multicellular development program, in which cells move collectively to assemble multicellular aggregates. After initial aggregates have formed, some will disperse, with smaller aggregates having a higher chance of dispersal. Initial aggregation is driven by two changes in cell behavior: cells slow down inside of aggregates and bias their motion by reversing direction less frequently when moving toward aggregates. However, the cell behaviors that drive dispersal are unknown. Here, we use fluorescent microscopy to quantify changes in cell behavior after initial aggregates have formed. We observe that after initial aggregate formation, cells adjust the bias in reversal timings by initiating reversals more rapidly when approaching unstable aggregates. Using agent-based modeling, we then show dispersal is predominantly generated by this change in bias, which is strong enough to overcome slowdown inside aggregates. Notably, the change in reversal bias is correlated with the nearest aggregate size, connecting cellular activity to previously observed correlations between aggregate size and fate. To determine if this connection is consistent across strains, we analyze a secondM. xanthusstrain with reduced levels of dispersal. We find that far fewer cells near smaller aggregates modified their bias. This implies that aggregate dispersal is under genetic control, providing a foundation for further investigations into the role it plays in the life cycle ofM. xanthus.

    IMPORTANCE

    Understanding the processes behind bacterial biofilm formation, maintenance, and dispersal is essential for addressing their effects on health and ecology. Within these multicellular communities, various cues can trigger differentiation into distinct cell types, allowing cells to adapt to their specific local environment. The soil bacteriumMyxococcus xanthusforms biofilms in response to starvation, marked by cells aggregating into mounds. Some aggregates persist as spore-filled fruiting bodies, while others disperse after initial formation for unknown reasons. Here, we use a combination of cell tracking analysis and computational simulations to identify behaviors at the cellular level that contribute to aggregate dispersal. Our results suggest that cells in aggregates actively determine whether to disperse or persist and undergo a transition to sporulation based on a self-produced cue related to the aggregate size. Identifying these cues is an important step in understanding and potentially manipulating bacterial cell-fate decisions.

     
    more » « less
  3. O'Toole, George (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT Myxococcus xanthus is a bacterium that lives on surfaces as a predatory biofilm called a swarm. As a growing swarm feeds on prey and expands, it displays dynamic multicellular patterns such as traveling waves called ripples and branching protrusions called flares. The rate at which a swarm expands across a surface, and the emergence of the coexisting patterns, are all controlled through coordinated cell movement. M. xanthus cells move using two motility systems known as adventurous (A) and social (S). Both are involved in swarm expansion and pattern formation. In this study, we describe a set of M. xanthus swarming genotype-to-phenotype associations that include both genetic and environmental perturbations. We identified new features of the swarming phenotype, recorded and measured swarm expansion using time-lapse microscopy, and compared the impact of mutations on different surfaces. These observations and analyses have increased our ability to discriminate between swarming phenotypes and provided context that allows us to identify some phenotypes as improbable outliers within the M. xanthus swarming phenome. IMPORTANCE Myxococcus xanthus grows on surfaces as a predatory biofilm called a swarm. In nature, a feeding swarm expands by moving over and consuming prey bacteria. In the laboratory, a swarm is created by spotting cell suspension onto nutrient agar in lieu of prey. The suspended cells quickly settle on the surface as the liquid is absorbed into the agar, and the new swarm then expands radially. An assay that measures the expansion rate of a swarm of mutant cells is the first, and sometimes only, measurement used to decide whether a particular mutation impacts swarm motility. We have broadened the scope of this assay by increasing the accuracy of measurements and introducing prey, resulting in new identifiable and quantifiable features that can be used to improve genotype-to-phenotype associations. 
    more » « less
  4. Introduction

    MrpC, a member of the CRP/Fnr transcription factor superfamily, is necessary to induce and control the multicellular developmental program of the bacterium,Myxococcus xanthus. During development, certain cells in the population first swarm into haystack-shaped aggregates and then differentiate into environmentally resistant spores to form mature fruiting bodies (a specialized biofilm).mrpCtranscriptional regulation is controlled by negative autoregulation (NAR).

    Methods

    Wild type and mutantmrpCpromoter regions were fused to a fluorescent reporter to examine effects onmrpCexpression in the population and in single cellsin situ. Phenotypic consequences of the mutantmrpCpromoter were assayed by deep convolution neural network analysis of developmental movies, sporulation efficiency assays, and anti-MrpC immunoblot. In situ analysis of single cell MrpC levels in distinct populations were assayed with an MrpC-mNeonGreen reporter.

    Results

    Disruption of MrpC binding sites within themrpCpromoter region led to increased and broadened distribution ofmrpCexpression levels between individual cells in the population. Expression ofmrpCfrom the mutant promoter led to a striking phenotype in which cells lose synchronized transition from aggregation to sporulation. Instead, some cells abruptly exit aggregation centers and remain locked in a cohesive swarming state we termed developmental swarms, while the remaining cells transition to spores inside residual fruiting bodies.In situexamination of a fluorescent reporter for MrpC levels in developmental subpopulations demonstrated cells locked in the developmental swarms contained MrpC levels that do not reach the levels observed in fruiting bodies.

    Discussion

    Increased cell-to-cell variation inmrpCexpression upon disruption of MrpC binding sites within its promoter is consistent with NAR motifs functioning to reducing noise. Noise reduction may be key to synchronized transition of cells in the aggregation state to the sporulation state. We hypothesize a novel subpopulation of cells trapped as developmental swarms arise from intermediate levels of MrpC that are sufficient to promote aggregation but insufficient to trigger sporulation. Failure to transition to higher levels of MrpC necessary to induce sporulation may indicate cells in developmental swarms lack an additional positive feedback signal required to boost MrpC levels.

     
    more » « less
  5. ABSTRACT His-Asp phosphorelay (also known as two-component signal transduction) proteins are the predominant mechanism used in most bacteria to control behavior in response to changing environmental conditions. In addition to systems consisting of a simple two-component system utilizing an isolated histidine kinase/response regulator pair, some bacteria are enriched in histidine kinases that serve as signal integration proteins; these kinases are usually characterized by noncanonical domain architecture, and the responses that they regulate may be difficult to identify. The environmental bacterium Myxococcus xanthus is highly enriched in these noncanonical histidine kinases. M. xanthus is renowned for a starvation-induced multicellular developmental program in which some cells are induced to aggregate into fruiting bodies and then differentiate into environmentally resistant spores. Here, we characterize the M. xanthus orphan hybrid histidine kinase SinK (Mxan_4465), which consists of a histidine kinase transmitter followed by two receiver domains (REC 1 and REC 2 ). Nonphosphorylatable sinK mutants were analyzed under two distinct developmental conditions and using a new high-resolution developmental assay. These assays revealed that SinK autophosphorylation and REC 1 impact the onset of aggregation and/or the mobility of aggregates, while REC 2 impacts sporulation efficiency. SinK activity is controlled by a genus-specific hypothetical protein (SinM; Mxan_4466). We propose that SinK serves to fine-tune fruiting body morphology in response to environmental conditions. IMPORTANCE Biofilms are multicellular communities of microorganisms that play important roles in host disease or environmental biofouling. Design of preventative strategies to block biofilms depends on understanding the molecular mechanisms used by microorganisms to build them. The production of biofilms in bacteria often involves two-component signal transduction systems in which one protein component (a kinase) detects an environmental signal and, through phosphotransfer, activates a second protein component (a response regulator) to change the transcription of genes necessary to produce a biofilm. We show that an atypical kinase, SinK, modulates several distinct stages of specialized biofilm produced by the environmental bacterium Myxococcus xanthus . SinK likely integrates multiple signals to fine-tune biofilm formation in response to distinct environmental conditions. 
    more » « less