Vertical eddy diffusivity (VED) in the planetary boundary layer (PBL) has a significant impact on forecasts of tropical cyclone (TC) structure and intensity. VED uncertainties in PBL parameterizations can be partly attributed to the model’s inability to represent roll vortices (RV). In this study, RV effects on turbulent fluxes derived from a large eddy simulation (LES) by Li et al. (Geophys. Res. Lett., 2021, 48, e2020GL090703) are added to the VED parameterization of the PBL scheme within the operational Hurricane Weather Research and Forecasting (HWRF) model. RV contribution to VED is parameterized through a coefficient and varies with the RV intensity and velocity scale. A modification over land has also been implemented. This modified VED parameterization is compared with the original wind-speed-dependent VED scheme in HWRF. Retrospective HWRF forecasts of Hurricanes Florence (2018) and Laura (2020) are analyzed to evaluate the impacts of the modified VED scheme on landfalling hurricane forecasts. Results show that the modified PBL scheme with the RV effect leads to an improvement in 10-m maximum wind speed forecasts of 14%–31%, with a neutral to positive improvement for track forecasts. Improved wind structure and precipitation forecasts against observations are also noted with the modified PBL scheme. Further diagnoses indicate that the revised PBL scheme enhances moist entropy in the boundary layer over land, leading to improved TC intensity prediction compared to the original scheme.
A Review and Evaluation of Planetary Boundary Layer Parameterizations in Hurricane Weather Research and Forecasting Model Using Idealized Simulations and Observations
This paper reviews the evolution of planetary boundary layer (PBL) parameterization schemes that have been used in the operational version of the Hurricane Weather Research and Forecasting (HWRF) model since 2011. Idealized simulations are then used to evaluate the effects of different PBL schemes on hurricane structure and intensity. The original Global Forecast System (GFS) PBL scheme in the 2011 version of HWRF produces the weakest storm, while a modified GFS scheme using a wind-speed dependent parameterization of vertical eddy diffusivity (Km) produces the strongest storm. The subsequent version of the hybrid eddy diffusivity and mass flux scheme (EDMF) used in HWRF also produces a strong storm, similar to the version using the wind-speed dependent Km. Both the intensity change rate and maximum intensity of the simulated storms vary with different PBL schemes, mainly due to differences in the parameterization of Km. The smaller the Km in the PBL scheme, the faster a storm tends to intensify. Differences in hurricane PBL height, convergence, inflow angle, warm-core structure, distribution of deep convection, and agradient force in these simulations are also examined. Compared to dropsonde and Doppler radar composites, improvements in the kinematic structure are found in simulations using the wind-speed dependent Km and modified EDMF schemes relative to those with earlier versions of the PBL schemes in HWRF. However, the upper boundary layer in all simulations is much cooler and drier than that in dropsonde observations. This model deficiency needs to be considered and corrected in future model physics upgrades.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10219517
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Atmosphere
- Volume:
- 11
- Issue:
- 10
- ISSN:
- 2073-4433
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 1091
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
more » « less
-
Sensitivity of large eddy simulations of tropical cyclone to sub-grid scale mixing parameterization.The surface wind structure and vertical turbulent transport processes in the eyewall of hurricane Isabel (2003) are investigated using six large-eddy simulations (LESs) with different horizontal grid spacing and three-dimensional (3D) sub-grid scale (SGS) turbulent mixing models and a convection permitting simulation that uses a coarser grid spacing and one-dimensional vertical turbulent mixing scheme. The mean radius-height distribution of storm tangential wind and radial flow, vertical velocity structure, and turbulent kinetic energy and momentum fluxes in the boundary layer generated by LESs are consistent with those derived from historical dropsonde composites, Doppler radar, and aircraft measurements. Unlike the convection permitting simulation that produces storm wind fields lacking small-scale disturbances, all LESs are able to produce sub-kilometer and kilometer scale eddy circulations in the eyewall. The inter-LES differences generally reduce with the decrease of model grid spacing. At 100-m horizontal grid spacing, the vertical momentum fluxes induced by the model-resolved eddies and the associated eddy exchange coefficients in the eyewall simulated by the LESs with different 3D SGS mixing schemes are fairly consistent. Although with uncertainties, the decomposition in terms of eddy scales suggests that sub-kilometer eddies are mainly responsible for the vertical turbulent transport within the boundary layer (~1 km depth following the conventional definition) whereas eddies greater than 1 km become the dominant contributors to the vertical momentum transport above the boundary layer in the eyewall. The strong dependence of vertical turbulent transport on eddy scales suggests that the vertical turbulent mixing parameterization in mesoscale simulations of tropical cyclones is ultimately a scale-sensitive problem.more » « less
-
Rotation in hurricane flows can highly affect the dynamics and structure of hurricane boundary layers (HBLs). Recent studies (Momen et al. 2021) showed that there is a significant distinction between turbulence characteristics in hurricane and regular atmospheric boundary layers due to the strong rotational effects of hurricane flows. Despite these unique features of HBLs, the current planetary boundary layer (PBL) and turbulence schemes in numerical weather prediction (NWP) models are neither specifically designed nor comprehensively tested for major hurricane flows. In this talk, we will address this knowledge gap by characterizing the role of horizontal and vertical eddy diffusion under different PBL schemes in simulated hurricane intensity, size, and track. To this end, the results of multiple simulated hurricane cases will be presented using the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model. The impacts of changing the grid resolution, horizontal turbulence, PBL scheme, vertical eddy diffusivity, and PBL height on hurricane dynamics and accuracy will be characterized. The results indicate that the current turbulence and PBL schemes in WRF are overly diffusive for simulating major hurricanes (Romdhani et al. 2022; Li et al. 2023) primarily since they do not account for turbulence suppression effects in rotating hurricane flows. We will also show new suites of simulations in which the default horizontal and vertical diffusion in WRF are modulated to determine the impacts of eddy diffusion changes on hurricane dynamics. The results indicate that reducing the default vertical diffusion depth and magnitude led to ~38% and ~24% improvements, on average, in hurricane intensity forecasts compared to the default models in the considered cases (Matak and Momen 2023). Moreover, by decreasing the default horizontal mixing length, we managed to decrease the intensity errors on average between ~8-23% in the WRF’s default models for both low and high resolutions. Figure A displays an example of the simulations in which our new adjustment of the vertical diffusion (reduced diffusion, blue line) agrees better with the observed data (black line) compared to the default WRF results (gray line). The figure also depicts wind speed contours that how this change in vertical diffusion can remarkably influence the structure, size, and intensity of hurricane simulations. The results of this study provide notable insights into the role of turbulent fluxes in simulated hurricanes that can be useful to advance the turbulence and PBL parameterizations of NWP models for accurate tropical cyclone forecasts. References: Li M, Zhang JA, Matak L, Momen M (2023) The impacts of adjusting momentum roughness length on strong and weak hurricanes forecasts: a comprehensive analysis of weather simulations and observations. Mon Weather Rev. https://doi.org/10.1175/MWR-D-22-0191.1 Matak L, Momen M (2023) The role of vertical diffusion parameterizations in the dynamics and accuracy of simulated intensifying hurricanes . Boundary Layer Meteorology. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10546-023-00818-w Momen M, Parlange MB, Giometto MG (2021) Scrambling and reorientation of classical boundary layer turbulence in hurricane winds. Geophys Res Lett 48:.https://doi.org/10.1029/2020GL091695 Romdhani O, Zhang JA, Momen M (2022) Characterizing the impacts of turbulence closures on real hurricane forecasts: A comprehensive joint assessment of grid resolution, horizontal turbulence models, and horizontal mixing length. J Adv Model Earth Syst. https://doi.org/10.1029/2021MS002796more » « less
-
Tropical cyclones are one of the deadliest natural disasters in the world that cause significant damage to the environment and infrastructure. The Hurricane Boundary Layer (HBL) plays a major role in hurricane dynamics and its intensification. Most of the existing vertical diffusion parameterizations in the current numerical weather prediction models rely on the Planetary Boundary Layer (PBL) schemes. Previous studies (Momen et al. 2021; Romdhani et al. 2022) showed that there is a significant distinction between turbulence characteristics in HBLs and regular atmospheric boundary layers (ABLs) due to the strong rotational effects of hurricane flows. Nevertheless, such differences are not considered in the current PBL schemes, and they are primarily designed and tested for regular ABLs. In this talk, we aim to bridge this knowledge gap by conducting real hurricane simulations using the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model. We investigate the role of the PBL height and eddy momentum exchange coefficients in five intensifying hurricanes by probing the parameter space of the problem. Our simulations have shown that the most widely used WRF PBL schemes do not capture the hurricane intensification properly and underestimate their intensity. We will demonstrate how limiting the amount of the vertical transport of momentum greatly benefits the skill of forecasting in major hurricane simulations. We will also present how changing the height of the PBL significantly impacts the accuracy of the forecasts. By reducing the PBL height, simulated hurricanes become stronger and larger – representing the actual rapid intensification process much more accurately. Not only changes are seen in the predicted wind intensities, but also remarkable impacts are observed in storm size, the radius of maximum wind speed, hurricane track, and minimum sea level pressure. The results of this study provide insights into the role of vertical diffusion parameterizations in hurricane dynamics. Our findings can be used to improve the accuracy of real hurricane forecasts in numerical weather prediction models.more » « less
-
Recent studies have shown that climate change and global warming considerably increase the risks of hurricane winds, floods, and storm surges in coastal communities. Turbulent processes in Hurricane Boundary Layers (HBLs) play a major role in hurricane dynamics and intensification. Most of the existing turbulence parameterizations in the current numerical weather prediction (NWP) models rely on the Planetary Boundary Layer (PBL) schemes. Previous studies (Zhang 2010; Momen et al. 2021) showed that there is a significant distinction between turbulence characteristics in HBLs and regular atmospheric boundary layers (ABLs) due to the strong rotational effects of hurricane flows. Nevertheless, such differences are not considered in the current schemes of NWPs, and they are primarily designed and tested for regular ABLs. In this talk, we aim to bridge this knowledge gap by conducting new hurricane simulations using the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model as well as large-eddy simulations. We investigate the role of the PBL parameterizations and momentum roughness length in multiple hurricanes by probing the parameter space of the problem. Our simulations have shown that the most widely used WRF PBL schemes do not capture the hurricane intensification properly and underestimate their intensity. We will present that decreasing the roughness length close to the values of observational estimates and theoretical hurricane intensity models in high wind regimes (≳ 45 m s-1) led to significant improvements in the intensity forecasts of strong hurricanes. Furthermore, by decreasing the existing vertical diffusion values, on average more than 20% improvements in hurricane intensity forecasts were obtained compared to the default runs. Our results provide new insights into the role of turbulence parameterizations in hurricane dynamics and can be employed to improve the accuracy of real hurricane forecasts. The implications of these results and improvements for coastal resiliency and fluid-structure interactions will also be discussed.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.3390/atmos11101091
