skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


Title: A Study on the Accuracy of OCR Engines for Source Code Transcription from Programming Screencasts
Programming screencasts can be a rich source of documentation for developers. However, despite the availability of such videos, the information available in them, and especially the source code being displayed is not easy to find, search, or reuse by programmers. Recent work has identified this challenge and proposed solutions that identify and extract source code from video tutorials in order to make it readily available to developers or other tools. A crucial component in these approaches is the Optical Character Recognition (OCR) engine used to transcribe the source code shown on screen. Previous work has simply chosen one OCR engine, without consideration for its accuracy or that of other engines on source code recognition. In this paper, we present an empirical study on the accuracy of six OCR engines for the extraction of source code from screencasts and code images. Our results show that the transcription accuracy varies greatly from one OCR engine to another and that the most widely chosen OCR engine in previous studies is by far not the best choice. We also show how other factors, such as font type and size can impact the results of some of the engines. We conclude by offering guidelines for programming screencast creators on which fonts to use to enable a better OCR recognition of their source code, as well as advice on OCR choice for researchers aiming to analyze source code in screencasts.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1846142
PAR ID:
10220037
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Proceedings of the 17th International Conference on Mining Software Repositories
Page Range / eLocation ID:
65 to 75
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; (, Proceedings of the 28th International Conference on Program Comprehension)
    null (Ed.)
    Mobile applications demand is on the rise, leading to more programmers learning to develop or having to maintain this kind of programs. Developers often refer to online resources to find inspiration or answers to questions they have about mobile programming topics and screencasts are a popular resource. However, given the multitude of screencasts available, it can be difficult to quickly comprehend which of the many videos is relevant to one's needs. We propose a novel approach, called UIScreens, which detects, extracts, and presents the most representative user interface (UI) screens embedded in mobile development screencasts. This could help developers quickly comprehend what an app displayed in a video is about, therefore saving time searching for useful videos. UIScreens has been evaluated in two empirical studies on iOS and Android programming screencasts. The first study investigates the accuracy of our UI extraction and shows that our approach is able to detect and extract UI screens with an accuracy of 94%. The second is a user study with mobile app developers, who evaluated both the accuracy and the usefulness of UIScreens. They agreed that UIScreens is accurate and extracts representative UI screens from videos. They considered that the extracted UI screens are useful for understanding what a video is about and if it is relevant to a search. Our approach has been implemented as a free online tool. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; (, Proceedings of the ACM/IEEE 42nd International Conference on Software Engineering: Companion Proceedings)
    null (Ed.)
    The need for mobile applications and mobile programming is increasing due to the continuous rise in the pervasiveness of mobile devices. Developers often refer to video programming tutorials to learn more about mobile programming topics. To find the right video to watch, developers typically skim over several videos, looking at their title, description, and video content in order to determine if they are relevant to their information needs. Unfortunately, the title and description do not always provide an accurate overview, and skimming over videos is time-consuming and can lead to missing important information. We propose a novel approach that locates and extracts the GUI screens showcased in a video tutorial, then selects and displays the most representative ones to provide a GUI-focused overview of the video. We believe this overview can be used by developers as an additional source of information for determining if a video contains the information they need. To evaluate our approach, we performed an empirical study on iOS and Android programming screencasts which investigates the accuracy of our automated GUI extraction. The results reveal that our approach can detect and extract GUI screens with an accuracy of 94%. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; et al (, Applications in Plant Sciences)
    Abstract PremiseAmong the slowest steps in the digitization of natural history collections is converting imaged labels into digital text. We present here a working solution to overcome this long‐recognized efficiency bottleneck that leverages synergies between community science efforts and machine learning approaches. MethodsWe present two new semi‐automated services. The first detects and classifies typewritten, handwritten, or mixed labels from herbarium sheets. The second uses a workflow tuned for specimen labels to label text using optical character recognition (OCR). The label finder and classifier was built via humans‐in‐the‐loop processes that utilize the community science Notes from Nature platform to develop training and validation data sets to feed into a machine learning pipeline. ResultsOur results showcase a >93% success rate for finding and classifying main labels. The OCR pipeline optimizes pre‐processing, multiple OCR engines, and post‐processing steps, including an alignment approach borrowed from molecular systematics. This pipeline yields >4‐fold reductions in errors compared to off‐the‐shelf open‐source solutions. The OCR workflow also allows human validation using a custom Notes from Nature tool. DiscussionOur work showcases a usable set of tools for herbarium digitization including a custom‐built web application that is freely accessible. Further work to better integrate these services into existing toolkits can support broad community use. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; ; (, Forum for Information Retrieval Evaluation. (FIRE 2022))
    he advancement of web programming techniques, such as Ajax and jQuery, and datastores, such as Apache Solr and Elasticsearch, have made it much easier to deploy small to medium scale web- based search engines. However, developing a sustainable search engine that supports scholarly big data services is still challenging often because of limited human resources and financial support. Such scenarios are typical in academic settings or small businesses. Here, we showcase how four key design decisions were made by trading-off competing factors such as performance, cost, and effi- ciency, when developing the Next Generation CiteSeerX (NGX), the successor of CiteSeerX, which was a pioneering digital library search engine that has been serving academic communities for more than two decades. This work extends our previous work in Wu et al. (2021) and discusses design considerations of infrastruc- ture, web applications, indexing, and document filtering. These design considerations can be generalized to other web-based search engines with a similar scale that are deployed in small business or academic settings with limited resources. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; et al (, Proceedings of the Fourteenth Symposium on Usable Privacy and Security)
    Despite the best efforts of the security community, security vulnerabilities in software are still prevalent, with new vulnerabilities reported daily and older ones stubbornly repeating themselves. One potential source of these vulnerabilities is shortcomings in the used language and library APIs. Developers tend to trust APIs, but can misunderstand or misuse them, introducing vulnerabilities. We call the causes of such misuse blindspots. In this paper, we study API blindspots from the developers' perspective to: (1) determine the extent to which developers can detect API blindspots in code and (2) examine the extent to which developer characteristics (i.e., perception of code correctness, familiarity with code, confidence, professional experience, cognitive function, and personality) affect this capability. We conducted a study with 109 developers from four countries solving programming puzzles that involve Java APIs known to contain blindspots. We find that (1) The presence of blindspots correlated negatively with the developers' accuracy in answering implicit security questions and the developers' ability to identify potential security concerns in the code. This effect was more pronounced for I/O-related APIs and for puzzles with higher cyclomatic complexity. (2) Higher cognitive functioning and more programming experience did not predict better ability to detect API blindspots. (3) Developers exhibiting greater openness as a personality trait were more likely to detect API blindspots. This study has the potential to advance API security in (1) design, implementation, and testing of new APIs; (2) addressing blindspots in legacy APIs; (3) development of novel methods for developer recruitment and training based on cognitive and personality assessments; and (4) improvement of software development processes (e.g., establishment of security and functionality teams). 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email