skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Doubly Balanced Connected Graph Partitioning
We introduce and study the doubly balanced connected graph partitioning problem: Let G =( V , E ) be a connected graph with a weight (supply/demand) function p : V → {−1, +1} satisfying p ( V )=∑ j &isin V p ( j ) = 0. The objective is to partition G into ( V 1 , V 2 ) such that G [ V 1 ] and G [ V 2 ] are connected, ∣ p ( V 1 )∣,∣ p ( V 2 )∣≤ c p , and max{ ∣ V 1 / V 2 ∣,∣ V 2 / V 1 ∣} ≤ c s , for some constants c p and c s . When G is 2-connected, we show that a solution with c p =1 and c s =2 always exists and can be found in randomized polynomial time. Moreover, when G is 3-connected, we show that there is always a “perfect” solution (a partition with p ( V 1 )= p ( V 2 )=0 and ∣ V 1 ∣=∣ V 2 ∣, if ∣ V ∣≡ 0 (mod 4)), and it can be found in randomized polynomial time. Our techniques can be extended, with similar results, to the case in which the weights are arbitrary (not necessarily ±1), and to the case that p ( V )≠ 0 and the excess supply/demand should be split evenly. They also apply to the problem of partitioning a graph with two types of nodes into two large connected subgraphs that preserve approximately the proportion of the two types.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1703925 1763970
PAR ID:
10225708
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
ACM Transactions on Algorithms
Volume:
16
Issue:
2
ISSN:
1549-6325
Page Range / eLocation ID:
1 to 24
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. null (Ed.)
    Motivated by applications in gerrymandering detection, we study a reconfiguration problem on connected partitions of a connected graph G. A partition of V(G) is connected if every part induces a connected subgraph. In many applications, it is desirable to obtain parts of roughly the same size, possibly with some slack s. A Balanced Connected k-Partition with slack s, denoted (k, s)-BCP, is a partition of V(G) into k nonempty subsets, of sizes n1,…,nk with |ni−n/k|≤s , each of which induces a connected subgraph (when s=0 , the k parts are perfectly balanced, and we call it k-BCP for short). A recombination is an operation that takes a (k, s)-BCP of a graph G and produces another by merging two adjacent subgraphs and repartitioning them. Given two k-BCPs, A and B, of G and a slack s≥0 , we wish to determine whether there exists a sequence of recombinations that transform A into B via (k, s)-BCPs. We obtain four results related to this problem: (1) When s is unbounded, the transformation is always possible using at most 6(k−1) recombinations. (2) If G is Hamiltonian, the transformation is possible using O(kn) recombinations for any s≥n/k , and (3) we provide negative instances for s≤n/(3k) . (4) We show that the problem is PSPACE-complete when k∈O(nε) and s∈O(n1−ε) , for any constant 0<ε≤1 , even for restricted settings such as when G is an edge-maximal planar graph or when k≥3 and G is planar. 
    more » « less
  2. We prove a new generalization of the higher-order Cheeger inequality for partitioning with buffers. Consider a graph G=(V,E). The buffered expansion of a set S⊆V with a buffer B⊆V∖S is the edge expansion of S after removing all the edges from set S to its buffer B. An ε-buffered k-partitioning is a partitioning of a graph into disjoint components Pi and buffers Bi, in which the size of buffer Bi for Pi is small relative to the size of Pi: |Bi|≤ε|Pi|. The buffered expansion of a buffered partition is the maximum of buffered expansions of the k sets Pi with buffers Bi. Let hk,εG be the buffered expansion of the optimal ε-buffered k-partitioning, then for every δ>0, hk,εG≤Oδ(1)⋅(logkε)⋅λ⌊(1+δ)k⌋, where λ⌊(1+δ)k⌋ is the ⌊(1+δ)k⌋-th smallest eigenvalue of the normalized Laplacian of G. Our inequality is constructive and avoids the ``square-root loss'' that is present in the standard Cheeger inequalities (even for k=2). We also provide a complementary lower bound, and a novel generalization to the setting with arbitrary vertex weights and edge costs. Moreover our result implies and generalizes the standard higher-order Cheeger inequalities and another recent Cheeger-type inequality by Kwok, Lau, and Lee (2017) involving robust vertex expansion. 
    more » « less
  3. We prove a new generalization of the higher-order Cheeger inequality for partitioning with buffers. Consider a graph G = (V, E). The buffered expansion of a set S ⊆ V with a buffer B ⊆ V∖S is the edge expansion of S after removing all the edges from set S to its buffer B. An ε-buffered k-partitioning is a partitioning of a graph into disjoint components P_i and buffers B_i, in which the size of buffer B_i for P_i is small relative to the size of P_i: |B_i| ≤ ε|P_i|. The buffered expansion of a buffered partition is the maximum of buffered expansions of the k sets P_i with buffers B_i. Let h^{k,ε}_G be the buffered expansion of the optimal ε-buffered k-partitioning, then for every δ>0, h^{k,ε}_G ≤ O(1)⋅(log k) ⋅λ_{⌊(1+δ)k⌋} / ε, where λ_{⌊(1+δ)k⌋} is the ⌊(1+δ)k⌋-th smallest eigenvalue of the normalized Laplacian of G. Our inequality is constructive and avoids the ``square-root loss'' that is present in the standard Cheeger inequalities (even for k=2). We also provide a complementary lower bound, and a novel generalization to the setting with arbitrary vertex weights and edge costs. Moreover our result implies and generalizes the standard higher-order Cheeger inequalities and another recent Cheeger-type inequality by Kwok, Lau, and Lee (2017) involving robust vertex expansion. 
    more » « less
  4. We consider the following communication problem: Alice and Bob each have some valuation functions $$v_1(\cdot)$$ and $$v_2(\cdot)$$ over subsets of $$m$$ items, and their goal is to partition the items into $$S, \bar{S}$$ in a way that maximizes the welfare, $$v_1(S) + v_2(\bar{S})$$. We study both the allocation problem, which asks for a welfare-maximizing partition and the decision problem, which asks whether or not there exists a partition guaranteeing certain welfare, for binary XOS valuations. For interactive protocols with $poly(m)$ communication, a tight 3/4-approximation is known for both [Fei06,DS06]. For interactive protocols, the allocation problem is provably harder than the decision problem: any solution to the allocation problem implies a solution to the decision problem with one additional round and $$\log m$$ additional bits of communication via a trivial reduction. Surprisingly, the allocation problem is provably easier for simultaneous protocols. Specifically, we show: 1) There exists a simultaneous, randomized protocol with polynomial communication that selects a partition whose expected welfare is at least $3/4$ of the optimum. This matches the guarantee of the best interactive, randomized protocol with polynomial communication. 2) For all $$\varepsilon > 0$$, any simultaneous, randomized protocol that decides whether the welfare of the optimal partition is $$\geq 1$$ or $$\leq 3/4 - 1/108+\varepsilon$$ correctly with probability $> 1/2 + 1/ poly(m)$ requires exponential communication. This provides a separation between the attainable approximation guarantees via interactive ($3/4$) versus simultaneous ($$\leq 3/4-1/108$$) protocols with polynomial communication. In other words, this trivial reduction from decision to allocation problems provably requires the extra round of communication. We further discuss the implications of our results for the design of truthful combinatorial auctions in general, and extensions to general XOS valuations. In particular, our protocol for the allocation problem implies a new style of truthful mechanisms. 
    more » « less
  5. Ene, Alina; Chattopadhyay, Eshan (Ed.)
    We study the classic Max-Cut problem under multiple cardinality constraints, which we refer to as the Constrained Max-Cut problem. Given a graph G = (V, E), a partition of the vertices into c disjoint parts V₁, …, V_c, and cardinality parameters k₁, …, k_c, the goal is to select a set S ⊆ V such that |S ∩ V_i| = k_i for each i ∈ [c], maximizing the total weight of edges crossing S (i.e., edges with exactly one endpoint in S).\r\nBy designing an approximate kernel for Constrained Max-Cut and building on the correlation rounding technique of Raghavendra and Tan (2012), we present a (0.858 - ε)-approximation algorithm for the problem when c = O(1). The algorithm runs in time O(min{k/ε, n}^poly(c/ε) + poly(n)), where k = ∑_{i∈[c]} k_i and n = |V|. This improves upon the (1/2 + ε₀)-approximation of Feige and Langberg (2001) for Max-Cut_k (the special case when c = 1, k₁ = k), and generalizes the (0.858 - ε)-approximation of Raghavendra and Tan (2012), which only applies when min{k,n-k} = Ω(n) and does not handle multiple constraints.\r\nWe also establish that, for general values of c, it is NP-hard to determine whether a feasible solution exists that cuts all edges. Finally, we present a 1/2-approximation algorithm for Max-Cut under an arbitrary matroid constraint. 
    more » « less