skip to main content

Title: Diversity-enabled sweet spots in layered architectures and speed–accuracy trade-offs in sensorimotor control

Nervous systems sense, communicate, compute, and actuate movement using distributed components with severe trade-offs in speed, accuracy, sparsity, noise, and saturation. Nevertheless, brains achieve remarkably fast, accurate, and robust control performance due to a highly effective layered control architecture. Here, we introduce a driving task to study how a mountain biker mitigates the immediate disturbance of trail bumps and responds to changes in trail direction. We manipulated the time delays and accuracy of the control input from the wheel as a surrogate for manipulating the characteristics of neurons in the control loop. The observed speed–accuracy trade-offs motivated a theoretical framework consisting of two layers of control loops—a fast, but inaccurate, reflexive layer that corrects for bumps and a slow, but accurate, planning layer that computes the trajectory to follow—each with components having diverse speeds and accuracies within each physical level, such as nerve bundles containing axons with a wide range of sizes. Our model explains why the errors from two control loops are additive and shows how the errors in each control loop can be decomposed into the errors caused by the limited speeds and accuracies of the components. These results demonstrate that an appropriate diversity in the properties of more » neurons across layers helps to create “diversity-enabled sweet spots,” so that both fast and accurate control is achieved using slow or inaccurate components.

« less
Authors:
; ; ;
Award ID(s):
1735004
Publication Date:
NSF-PAR ID:
10232235
Journal Name:
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Volume:
118
Issue:
22
Page Range or eLocation-ID:
Article No. e1916367118
ISSN:
0027-8424
Publisher:
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Nervous systems sense, communicate, compute, and actuate movement, using distributed hardware with tradeoffs in speed and accuracy. The resulting sensorimotor control is nevertheless remarkably fast and accurate due to highly effective layered architectures. However, such architectures have received little attention in neuroscience due to the lack of theory that connects the system and hardware level speed-accuracy tradeoffs. In this paper, we present a theoretical framework that connects the speed-accuracy tradeoffs of sensorimotor control and neurophysiology. We characterize how the component SATs in spiking neuron communication and their sensory and muscle endpoints constrain the system SATs in both stochastic and deterministicmore »models. The results show that appropriate speed -accuracy diversity at the neurons/muscles levels allow nervous systems to improve the speed and accuracy in control performance despite using slow or inaccurate hardware. Then, we characterize the fundamental limits of layered control systems and show that appropriate diversity in planning and reaction layers leads to both fast and accurate system despite being composed of slow or inaccurate layers. We term these phenomena “Diversity Sweet Spots.” The theory presented here is illustrated in a companion paper, which introduces simple demos and a new inexpensive and easy-to-use experimental platform.« less
  2. This paper describes several surprisingly rich but simple demos and a new experimental platform for human sensorimotor control research and also controls education. The platform safely simulates a canonical sensorimotor task of riding a mountain bike down a steep, twisting, bumpy trail using a standard display and inexpensive off-the-shelf gaming steering wheel with a force feedback motor. We use the platform to verify our theory, presented in a companion paper. The theory tells how component hardware speed-accuracy tradeoffs (SATs) in control loops impose corresponding SATs at the system level and how effective architectures mitigate the deleterious impact of hardware SATsmore »through layering and “diversity sweet spots” (DSSs). Specifically, we measure the impacts on system performance of delays, quantization, and uncertainties in sensorimotor control loops, both within the subject's nervous system and added externally via software in the platform. This provides a remarkably rich test of the theory, which is consistent with all preliminary data. Moreover, as the theory predicted, subjects effectively multiplex specific higher layer planning/tracking of the trail using vision with lower layer rejection of unseen bump disturbances using reflexes. In contrast, humans multitask badly on tasks that do not naturally distribute across layers (e.g. texting and driving). The platform is cheap to build and easy to program for both research and education purposes, yet verifies our theory, which is aimed at closing a crucial gap between neurophysiology and sensorimotor control. The platform can be downloaded at https://github.com/Doyle-Lab/WheelCon.« less
  3. The activity of motor cortex is necessary for accurate stepping on a complex terrain. How this activity is generated remains unclear. The goal of this study was to clarify the contribution of signals from the ventrolateral thalamus (VL) to formation of locomotion-related activity of motor cortex during vision-independent and vision-dependent locomotion. In two cats, we recorded the activity of neurons in layer V of motor cortex as cats walked on a flat surface and a horizontal ladder. We reversibly inactivated ~10% of the VL unilaterally with the glutamatergic transmission antagonist 6-cyano-7-nitroquinoxaline-2,3-dione (CNQX) and analyzed how this affected the activity ofmore »motor cortex neurons. We examined neuronal subpopulations with somatosensory receptive fields on different segments of the forelimb and pyramidal tract projecting neurons (PTNs). We found that the VL contribution to the locomotion-related activity of motor cortex is very powerful and has both excitatory and inhibitory components. The magnitudes of both the excitatory and inhibitory contributions fluctuate over the step cycle and depend on locomotion task. On a flat surface, the VL contributes more excitation to the shoulder- and elbow-related neurons than the wrist/paw-related cells. The VL excites the shoulder-related group the most during the transition from stance to swing phase, while most intensively exciting the elbow-related group during the transition from swing to stance. The VL contributes more excitation for the fast- than slow-conducting PTNs. Upon transition to vision-dependent locomotion on the ladder, the VL contribution increases more for the wrist/paw-related neurons and slow-conducting PTNs. NEW & NOTEWORTHY How the activity of motor cortex is generated and the roles that different inputs to motor cortex play in formation of response properties of motor cortex neurons during movements remain unclear. This is the first study to characterize the contribution of the input from the ventrolateral thalamus (VL), the main subcortical input to motor cortex, to the activity of motor cortex neurons during vision-independent and vision-dependent locomotion.« less
  4. Abstract. A fast-response (10 Hz) chemiluminescence detector forozone (O3) was used to determine O3 fluxes using the eddy covariancetechnique at the Penlee Point Atmospheric Observatory (PPAO) on the southcoast of the UK during April and May 2018. The median O3 flux was −0.132 mg m−2 h−1 (0.018 ppbv m s−1),corresponding to a deposition velocity of 0.037 cm s−1(interquartile range 0.017–0.065 cm s−1) – similar to thehigher values previously reported for open-ocean flux measurements but notas high as some other coastal results. We demonstrate that a typical singleflux observation was above the 2σ limit of detection but hadconsiderable uncertainty. The median 2σ uncertainty of depositionvelocity was 0.031 cm s−1 for each 20 min period, whichreducesmore »with the square root of the sample size. Eddy covariance footprintanalysis of the site indicates that the flux footprint was predominantlyover water (> 96 %), varying with atmospheric stability and, toa lesser extent, with the tide. At very low wind speeds when the atmospherewas typically unstable, the observed ozone deposition velocity was elevated,most likely because the footprint contracted to include a greater landcontribution in these conditions. At moderate to high wind speeds whenatmospheric stability was near-neutral, the ozone deposition velocityincreased with wind speed and showed a linear dependence with frictionvelocity. This observed dependence on friction velocity (and therefore alsowind speed) is consistent with the predictions from the one-layer model ofFairall et al. (2007), which parameterisesthe oceanic deposition of ozone from the fundamental conservation equation,accounting for both ocean turbulence and near-surface chemical destruction,while assuming that chemical O3 destruction by iodide is distributed overdepth. In contrast to our observations, the deposition velocity predicted bythe recently developed two-layer model of Luhar et al. (2018) (whichconsiders iodide reactivity in both layers but with molecular diffusivitydominating over turbulent diffusivity in the first layer) shows no majordependence of deposition velocity on wind speed and underestimates themeasured deposition velocities. These results call for further investigationinto the mechanisms and control of oceanic O3 deposition.« less
  5. The methodology and standardization layer provided by the Performance Application Programming Interface (PAPI) has played a vital role in application profiling for almost two decades. It has enabled sophisticated performance analysis tool designers and performance-conscious scientists to gain insights into their applications by simply instrumenting their code using a handful of PAPI functions that “just work” across different hardware components. In the past, PAPI development had focused primarily on hardware-specific performance metrics. However, the rapidly increasing complexity of software infrastructure poses new measurement and analysis challenges for the developers of large-scale applications. In particular, acquiring information regarding the behavior ofmore »libraries and runtimes—used by scientific applications—requires low-level binary instrumentation, or APIs specific to each library and runtime. No uniform API for monitoring events that originate from inside the software stack has emerged. In this article, we present our efforts to extend PAPI’s role so that it becomes the de facto standard for exposing performance-critical events, which we refer to as software-defined events (SDEs), from different software layers. Upgrading PAPI with SDEs enables monitoring of both types of performance events—hardware- and software-related events—in a uniform way, through the same consistent PAPI. The goal of this article is threefold. First, we motivate the need for SDEs and describe our design decisions regarding the functionality we offer through PAPI’s new SDE interface. Second, we illustrate how SDEs can be utilized by different software packages, specifically, by showcasing their use in the numerical linear algebra library MAGMA-Sparse, the tensor algebra library TAMM that is part of the NWChem suite, and the compiler-based performance analysis tool Byfl. Third, we provide a performance analysis of the overhead that results from monitoring SDEs and discuss the trade-offs between overhead and functionality.« less