skip to main content

Title: Optimal Nursing Home Service Scheduling Under covid-19 Related Probabilistic Staff Shortage: A Two-stage Stochastic Programming Approach
Maintaining an appropriate staffing level is essential to providing a healthy workplace environment at nursing homes and ensuring quality care among residents. With the widespread Covid-19 pandemic, staff absenteeism frequently occurs due to mandatory quarantine and providing care to their inflicted family members. Even though some of the staff show up for work, they may have to perform additional pandemic-related protection duties. In combination, these changes lead to an uncertain reduction in the quantity of care each staff member able to provide in a future shift. To alleviate the staff shortage concern and maintain the necessary care quantity, we study the optimal shift scheduling problem for a skilled nursing facility under probabilistic staff shortage in the presence of pandemic-related service provision disruptions. We apply a two-stage stochastic programming approach to our study. Our objective is to assign staff (i.e., certified nursing aids) to shifts to minimize the total staffing cost associated with contract staff workload, the adjusted workload for the changing resident demand, and extra workload due to required sanitization. Thus, the uncertainties considered arise from probabilistic staff shortage in addition to resident service need fluctuation. We model the former source of uncertainty with a geometric random variable for each more » staffer. In a proof-of-the-concept study, we consider realistic COVID-19 pandemic response measures recommended by the Indiana state government. We extract payment parameter estimates from the COVID-19 Nursing Home Dataset publicly available by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). We conclude with our numerical experiments that when a skilled nursing facility is at low risk of the pandemic, the absenteeism rate and staff workload increase slightly, thus maintaining the current staffing level can still handle the service disruptions. On the other hand, under high-risk circumstances, with the sharp increase of the absence rate and workload, a care facility likely needs to hire additional full-time staff as soon as possible. Our research offers insights into staff shift scheduling in the face of uncertain staff shortages and service disruption due to pandemics and prolonged disasters. « less
; ; ; ;
Ghate, A; Krishnaiyer, K.; Paynabar, K.
Award ID(s):
Publication Date:
Journal Name:
2021 Industrial and Systems Engineering Research Conference
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. In this paper, we study a nursing home staff schedule optimization problem under resident demand uncertainty. We formulate a two-stage stochastic binary program accordingly, with objective to minimize the total labor cost (linearly related to work time) incurred by both regular registered nurses (RRNs) and part-time nurses (PTNs). As a significant constraint, we balance RRNs’ total amount of work time with residents’ total service need for every considered shift. Besides, we restrict feasible shift schedules based on common scheduling practice. We conduct a series of computational experiments to validate the proposed model. We discuss our optimal solutions under different compositions of residents in terms of their disabilities. In addition, we compare the total labor costs and an RRN scheduling flexibility index with the given optimal solution under different combinations of RRNs and PTNs. Our analysis offers an operational approach to set the minimum number of nurses on flexible shift schedules to cover uncertain the service needs while maintaining a minimum labor cost.
  2. Background According to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, nurses will be the largest labor pool in the United States by 2022, and more than 1.1 million nursing positions have to be filled by then in order to avoid a nursing shortage. In addition, the incidence rate of musculoskeletal disorders in nurses is above average in comparison with other occupations. Robot-assisted health care has the potential to alleviate the nursing shortage by automating mundane and routine nursing tasks. Furthermore, robots in health care environments may assist with safe patient mobility and handling and may thereby reduce the likelihood of musculoskeletal disorders. Objective This pilot study investigates the perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness (acceptability) of a customized service robot as determined by nursing students (as proxies for nursing staff in health care environments). This service robot, referred to as the Adaptive Robotic Nurse Assistant (ARNA), was developed to enhance the productivity of nurses through cooperation during physical tasks (eg, patient walking, item fetching, object delivery) as well as nonphysical tasks (eg, patient observation and feedback). This pilot study evaluated the acceptability of ARNA to provide ambulatory assistance to patients. Methods We conducted a trial with 24 participants to collectmore »data and address the following research question: Is the use of ARNA as an ambulatory assistive device for patients acceptable to nurses? The experiments were conducted in a simulated hospital environment. Nursing students (as proxies for nursing staff) were grouped in dyads, with one participant serving as a nurse and the other acting as a patient. Two questionnaires were developed and administrated to the participants based on the Technology Acceptance Model with respect to the two subscales of perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use metrics. In order to evaluate the internal consistency/reliability of the questionnaires, we calculated Cronbach alpha coefficients. Furthermore, statistical analyses were conducted to evaluate the relation of each variable in the questionnaires with the overall perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use metrics. Results Both Cronbach alpha values were acceptably high (.93 and .82 for perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use questionnaires, respectively), indicating high internal consistency of the questionnaires. The correlation between the variables and the overall perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use metrics was moderate. The average perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use metrics among the participants were 4.13 and 5.42, respectively, out of possible score of 7, indicating a higher-than-average acceptability of this service robot. Conclusions The results served to identify factors that could affect nurses’ acceptance of ARNA and aspects needing improvement (eg, flexibility, ease of operation, and autonomy level).« less
  3. This paper proposes and analyzes a stochastic Susceptible-Exposed-Infected-Removed (SEIR) spreading model on networks. Imagine a nursing home housing 28 seniors and 7 staff workers, in which one of the staff has tested positive for COVID-19. Unfortunately, the results of this test are 3 days late and the infected person had not been quarantining while waiting for their test results. What is now the individual risk to the different people living in this nursing home? If the home has access to two rapid COVID-19 viral tests, who should they be given to and why? In order to answer questions like this, we need to study stochastic models rather than deterministic ones. Unlike the vast majority of works that analyze various deterministic models, stochastic models are required when analyzing the risk of COVID-19 to individual people rather than tracking aggregate numbers in a given region. More specifically, this paper compares the results provided by analyzing stochastic and deterministic models and investigating when it is suitable to use the different models. In particular, we show why it is not suitable to use deterministic models when analyzing the spread in small communities and how these questions can be better addressed using stochastic ones. Finally,more »we show the added complications that arise due to the relatively long incubation period of COVID-19, and how it can be addressed. A simulated case study of the spread of COVID-19 in a 35-person nursing home is used to help illustrate our results.« less
  4. Fernández-Alcántara, Manuel (Ed.)
    Background Nurse identification of patient deterioration is critical, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic, as patients can deteriorate quickly. While the literature has shown that nurses rely on intuition to make decisions, there is limited information on what sources of data experienced nurses utilize to inform their intuition. The objectives of this study were to identify sources of data that inform nurse decision-making related to recognition of deteriorating patients, and explore how COVID-19 has impacted nurse decision-making. Methods In this qualitative study, experienced nurses voluntarily participated in focused interviews. During focused interviews, expert nurses were asked to share descriptions of memorable patient encounters, and questions were posed to facilitate reflections on thoughts and actions that hindered or helped their decision-making. They were also asked to consider the impact of COVID-19 on nursing and decision-making. Interviews were transcribed verbatim, study team members reviewed transcripts and coded responses, and organized key findings into themes. Results Several themes related to decision-making were identified by the research team, including: identifying patient care needs, workload management, and reflecting on missed care opportunities to inform learning. Participants (n = 10) also indicated that COVID-19 presented a number of unique barriers to nurse decision-making. Conclusions Findings from thismore »study indicate that experienced nurses utilize several sources of information to inform their intuition. It is apparent that the demands on nurses in response to pandemics are heightened. Decision-making themes drawn from participants’ experiences can to assist nurse educators for training nursing students on decision-making for deteriorating patients and how to manage the potential barriers (e.g., resource constraints, lack of family) associated with caring for patients during these challenging times prior to encountering these issues in the clinical environment. Nurse practice can utilize these findings to increase awareness among experienced nurses on recognizing how pandemic situations can impact to their decision-making capability.« less
  5. In May 2020, the New York City (NYC) Mayor’s Office of Climate Resiliency (MOCR) began convening bi-weekly discussions, called the Rapid Research and Assessment (RRA) Series, between City staff and external experts in science, policy, design, engineering, communications, and planning. The goal was to rapidly develop authoritative, actionable information to help integrate resiliency into the City’s COVID response efforts. The situation in NYC is not uncommon. Extreme events often require government officials, practitioners, and citizens to call upon multiple forms of scientific and technical assistance from rapid data collection to expert elicitation, each spanning more or less involved engagement. We compare the RRA to similar rapid assessment efforts and reflect on the nature of the RRA and similar efforts to exchange and co-produce knowledge. The RRA took up topics on social cohesion, risk communication, resilient and healthy buildings, and engagement, in many cases strengthening confidence in what was already known but also refining the existing knowledge in ways that can be helpful as the pandemic unfolds. Researchers also learned from each other ways to be supportive of the City of New York and MOCR in the future. The RRA network will continue to deepen, continue to co-produce actionable climate knowledge,more »and continue to value organizational sensemaking as a usable climate service, particularly in highly uncertain times. Given the complex, rare, and, in many cases, unfamiliar context of COVID-19, we argue that organizational sensemaking is a usable climate service.« less