skip to main content


Title: Solid-State Electrochemical Synthesis of Silicon Clathrates Using a Sodium-Sulfur Battery Inspired Approach

Clathrates of Tetrel elements (Si, Ge, Sn) have attracted interest for their potential use in batteries and other applications. Sodium-filled silicon clathrates are conventionally synthesized through thermal decomposition of the Zintl precursor Na4Si4, but phase selectivity of the product is often difficult to achieve. Herein, we report the selective formation of the type I clathrate Na8Si46using electrochemical oxidation at 450 °C and 550 °C. A two-electrode cell design inspired by high-temperature sodium-sulfur batteries is employed, using Na4Si4as working electrode, Naβ″-alumina solid electrolyte, and counter electrode consisting of molten Na or Sn. Galvanostatic intermittent titration is implemented to observe the oxidation characteristics and reveals a relatively constant cell potential under quasi-equilibrium conditions, indicating a two-phase reaction between Na4Si4and Na8Si46. We further demonstrate that the product selection and morphology can be altered by tuning the reaction temperature and Na vapor pressure. Room temperature lithiation of the synthesized Na8Si46is evaluated for the first time, showing similar electrochemical characteristics to those in the type II clathrate Na24Si136. The results show that solid-state electrochemical oxidation of Zintl phases at high temperatures can lead to opportunities for more controlled crystal growth and a deeper understanding of the formation processes of intermetallic clathrates.

 
more » « less
Award ID(s):
2004579 2004514 1710017 1709813
NSF-PAR ID:
10303793
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
The Electrochemical Society
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of The Electrochemical Society
Volume:
168
Issue:
2
ISSN:
0013-4651
Page Range / eLocation ID:
Article No. 020516
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Type II germanium clathrates have recently been investigated for potential applications as anodes in batteries due to their cage-like structures that can accommodate electrochemical insertion of guest ions. To synthesize type II Ge clathrates (Ge136), several experimental routes use thermal or electrochemical desodiation of the Zintl phase compound Na4Ge4. However, the mechanism by which Na atoms are removed from the precursor to form clathrates is not well understood. Herein, we use first-principles density functional theory and nudged elastic band calculations to understand the reaction mechanism and formation energies of the products typically observed in the synthesis, namely, NaδGe136 (0 < δ < 24) type II clathrates and hexagonal phase Na1–xGe3+z. Specifically, we confirm the energetic feasibility of Na vacancy formation in Na4Ge4 and find that the barrier for Na vacancy migration is only 0.37 eV. This relatively low energy barrier is consistent with the ease with which Na4Ge4 can be desodiated to form the products. We also discuss the energetics, sodium migration pathways, and potential electrochemical performance of Ge136 as anode material for Na-ion batteries. Overall, this study highlights how first-principles calculations can be used to understand the synthesis mechanism and desodiation processes in clathrate materials and will help guide researchers in the design and evaluation of new open framework compounds as viable materials for energy storage applications. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    All‐solid‐state sodium‐ion batteries are highly promising for next generation grid energy storage with improved safety. Among the known sodium superionic conductors, the Na3PnS4family and the recently discovered Na11Sn2PnS12(Pn = P, Sb) have garnered major interest due to their extremely high ionic conductivities. In this work, comprehensive investigation of the Na3PnS4‐Na4TtS4(Pn = P/As/Sb, Tt = Si/Ge/Sn) phase space of superionic conductors using density functional theory calculations, as well as AIMD simulations on the promising new Na11Sn2PnS12(Pn=P/As/Sb) structures are presented. Crucial design rules on the effect of cation mixing are extracted on relative phase stability, electrochemical stability, moisture stability, and ionic conductivity. In particular, it is shown that while larger cations can substantially improve the ionic conductivity and moisture stability in these structures, there is an inherent trade‐off in terms of electrochemical stability. Na11Sn2AsS12is also identified as a hitherto unexplored stable sodium superionic conductor with higher Na+conductivity and better moisture stability than the Na11Sn2PS12and Na11Sn2SbS12phases already reported experimentally.

     
    more » « less
  3. null (Ed.)
    The unconventional clathrates, Cs 8 Zn 18 Sb 28 and Cs 8 Cd 18 Sb 28 , were synthesized and reinvestigated. These clathrates exhibit unique and extensive superstructural ordering of the clathrate-I structure that was not initially reported. Cs 8 Cd 18 Sb 28 orders in the Ia 3̄ d space group (no. 230) with 8 times larger volume of the unit cell in which most framework atoms segregate into distinct Cd and Sb sites. The structure of Cs 8 Zn 18 Sb 28 is much more complicated, with an 18-fold increase of unit cell volume accompanied by significant reduction of symmetry down to P 2 (no. 3) monoclinic space group. This structure was revealed by a combination of synchrotron X-ray diffraction and electron microscopy techniques. A full solid solution, Cs 8 Zn 18−x Cd x Sb 28 , was also synthesized and characterized. These compounds follow Vegard's law in regard to their primitive unit cell sizes and melting points. Variable temperature in situ synchrotron powder X-ray diffraction was used to study the formation and melting of Cs 8 Zn 18 Sb 28 . Due to the heavy elements comprising clathrate framework and the complex structural ordering, the synthesized clathrates exhibit ultralow thermal conductivities, all under 0.8 W m −1 K −1 at room temperature. Cs 8 Zn 9 Cd 9 Sb 28 and Cs 8 Zn 4.5 Cd 13.5 Sb 28 both have total thermal conductivities of 0.49 W m −1 K −1 at room temperature, among the lowest reported for any clathrate. Cs 8 Zn 18 Sb 28 has typical p-type semiconducting charge transport properties, while the remaining clathrates show unusual n–p transitions or sharp increases of thermopower at low temperatures. Estimations of the bandgaps as activation energy for resistivity dependences show an anomalous widening and then shrinking of the bandgap with increasing Cd-content. 
    more » « less
  4. At low guest atom concentrations, Si clathrates can be viewed as semiconductors, with the guest atoms acting as dopants, potentially creating alternatives to diamond Si with exciting optoelectronic and spin properties. Studying Si clathrates with different guest atoms would not only provide insights into the electronic structure of the Si clathrates but also give insights into the unique properties that each guest can bring to the Si clathrate structure. However, the synthesis of Si clathrates with guests other than Na is challenging. In this study, we have developed an alternative approach, using thermal diffusion into type II Si clathrate with an extremely low Na concentration, to create Si clathrate with Li guests. Using time-of-flight secondary-ion mass spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, and Raman scattering, thermal diffusion of Li into the nearly empty Si clathrate framework is detected and characterized as a function of the diffusion temperature and time. Interestingly, the Si clathrate exhibits reduced structural stability in the presence of Li, converting to polycrystalline or disordered phases for anneals at temperatures where the starting Na guest Si clathrate is quite stable. The Li atoms inserted into the Si clathrate lattice contribute free carriers, which can be detected in Raman scattering through their effect on the strength of Si−Si bonds in the framework. These carriers can also be observed in electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR). EPR shows, however, that Li guests are not simple analogues of Na guests. In particular, our results suggest that Li atoms, with their smaller size, tend to doubly occupy cages, forming “molecular-like” pairs with other Li or Na atoms. Results of this work provide a deeper insight into Li guest atoms in Si clathrate. These findings are also relevant to understanding how Li moves through and interacts with Si clathrate anodes in Li-ion batteries. Additionally, techniques presented in this work demonstrate a new method for filling the Si clathrate cages, enabling studies of a broad range of other guests in Si clathrates. 
    more » « less
  5. The objective of this investigation was to utilize the first-principles molecular dynamics computational approach to investigate the lithiation characteristics of empty silicon clathrates (Si 46 ) for applications as potential anode materials in lithium-ion batteries. The energy of formation, volume expansion, and theoretical capacity were computed for empty silicon clathrates as a function of Li. The theoretical results were compared against experimental data of long-term cyclic tests performed on half-cells using electrodes fabricated from Si 46 prepared using a Hofmann-type elimination–oxidation reaction. The comparison revealed that the theoretically predicted capacity (of 791.6 mAh/g) agreed with experimental data (809 mAh/g) that occurred after insertion of 48 Li atoms. The calculations showed that overlithiation beyond 66 Li atoms can cause large volume expansion with a volume strain as high as 120%, which may correlate to experimental observations of decreasing capacities from the maximum at 1030 mAh/g to 553 mA h/g during long-term cycling tests. The finding suggests that overlithiation beyond 66 Li atoms may have caused damage to the cage structure and led to lower reversible capacities. 
    more » « less