skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: A Case History of Highwater Shore Erosion and Bank Stabilization via Tree Roots
Extreme highwater pool elevations in Pactola Reservoir, South Dakota in 2015 and 2019 resulted in massive shoreline erosion along the southern banks. This shoreline erosion occurred despite the geologic material being highly fractured rock with fracture dip angles approximately parallel to that of the subject hillside. The shale and siltstone in the upper 30 meters of the geology had weathered into silt and clay, leaving a matrix of 70% to 90% rock and 10% to 30% fine-grained soil. When highwater occurred, the silty portion of the shore materials eroded, while the remaining small amounts of highly plastic clay were insufficient to bind the weak and thinly bedded rock together, and rock slipped along the 15 to 30-degree fracture dip angle into the water. The shore erosion was arrested by a line of pine trees, and the erosion patterns show the effectiveness of tree roots to resist erosion in highly fractured rock. The erosion case history is presented with descriptions of several individual root systems that were effective in shore stabilization, as well as descriptions of several individual tree root systems that were ineffective in shore stabilization and the trees perished in the highwater evens and toppled.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1929143
PAR ID:
10309956
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Date Published:
Journal Name:
10th International Conference on Soil Erosion and Scour
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. The northern part of the Hikurangi margin (HM) regularly experiences shallow slow-slip events (SSEs), possibly extending into the thrust faults of the sedimentary prism. For example, offshore Gisborne SSEs occur every 1-2 years and can last several weeks, during which 5-30 cm of slip may be accommodated. Understanding what controls the timing of such events will help the comprehension of HM deformation and earthquake mechanics in general. One hypothesis for a slow slip mechanism is that the low permeability of the HM prism rocks and the large fluid volumes dragged deep into the subduction zone cause over-pressures along the megathrust and prism splay faults. Overpressure induces SSEs that locally increase permeability. After an SSE, swelling clays and ductile deformation reduce permeability within months, resetting the conditions for developing overpressure. We tested such a hypothesis by measuring the hydraulic permeability of fractured sedimentary rocks making up the core of the accretionary prism. Tests were performed using a newly developed X-ray transparent pressure vessel mounted inside a micro-computed tomography scanner (mCT) that allowed in-situ observation of fracture evolution as a function of confining pressure, time, and exposure to water. The tested rocks were probably subducted to ~7.5 km and are calcareous-glauconitic fine-grained sandstones with a silty matrix from the Late Cretaceous-to-Paleocene Tinui Group containing ~15% vol% of clay minerals. After exposure to high confining pressure and water, the samples regained pre-fracture permeability in tens of days. mCT imagery suggests that fracture clogging, possibly due to clay expansion, controls healing. We propose that slow slip events in the northern HM open fault fractures and allow drainage at the beginning of the slip cycle, followed by fracture clogging due to swelling clays and ductile deformation, with the duration of the cycle regulated by the interplay of these processes. 
    more » « less
  2. Beaches and inlets throughout the U.S. have been stabilized for purposes of navigation, erosion mitigation, and economic resilience, commonly leading to changes in shoreline dynamics and downdrift erosion/accretion patterns. The developed beach of Plum Island, Massachusetts is highly dynamic, experiencing regular complex erosion / accretion patterns along much of the shoreline. We analyzed > 100 years of high-water line positions derived from satellite imagery, t-sheets, historical maps, and aerial photography. Unlike most beaches, the river-proximal sections of Plum Island are not uniformly retreating. Rather, the beach undergoes short-term erosion, followed by periods of accretion and return to a long-term mean stable shoreline position. These cycles occur over different time frames and in different segments of the beach, creating an ephemeral erosion ‘hotspot’ lasting as briefly as one year. The highly dynamic and spatially diverse nature of erosion along Plum Island provides insight into the complex nature of coupled inlet-beach dynamics over multiple timescales. 
    more » « less
  3. null (Ed.)
    Coastal storms are an important driver of geomorphic change along Great Lakes shorelines. While there is abundant anecdotal evidence for storm impacts in the region, only a handful of studies over the last few decades have quantified them and addressed system morphodynamics. Annual to seasonal lake-level fluctuations and declining winter-ice covers also influence coastal response to storms, yet relationships between hydrodynamics and geomorphology are poorly constrained. Given this, the Great Lakes region lags behind marine coasts in terms of predictive modeling of future coastal change, which is a necessary tool for proactive coastal management. To help close this gap, we conducted a year-long study at a sandy beach-dune system along the western shore of Lake Michigan, evaluating storm impacts under conditions of extremely high water level and absent shorefast ice. Drone-derived beach and dune topography data were used to link geomorphic changes to specific environmental conditions. High water levels throughout the year of study facilitated erosion during relatively minor wave events, enhancing the vulnerability of the system to a large storm in January 2020. This event occurred with no shorefast ice present and anomalously high winter water levels, resulting in widespread erosion and overwash. This resulted in 20% of the total accretion and 66% of the erosion documented at the site over the entire year. Our study highlights the importance of both antecedent and present conditions in determining Great Lakes shoreline vulnerability to storm impacts. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract The subsurface processes that mediate the connection between evapotranspiration and groundwater within forested hillslopes are poorly defined. Here, we investigate the origin of diel signals in unsaturated soil water, groundwater, and stream stage on three forested hillslopes in the H.J. Andrews Experimental Forest in western Oregon, USA, during the summer of 2017, and assess how the diurnal signal in evapotranspiration (ET) is transferred through the hillslope and into these stores. There was no evidence of diel fluctuations in upslope groundwater wells, suggesting that tree water uptake in upslope areas does not directly contribute to the diel signal observed in near‐stream groundwater and streamflow. The water table in upslope areas resided within largely consolidated bedrock, which was overlain by highly fractured unsaturated bedrock. These subsurface characteristics inhibited formation of diel signals in groundwater and impeded the transfer of diel signals in soil moisture to groundwater because (1) the bedrock where the water table resides limited root penetration and (2) the low unsaturated hydraulic conductivity of the highly fractured rock weakened the hydraulic connection between groundwater and soil/rock moisture. Transpiration‐driven diel fluctuations in groundwater were limited to near‐stream areas but were not ubiquitous in space and time. The depth to the groundwater table and the geologic structure at that depth likely dictated rooting depth and thus controlled where and when the transpiration‐driven diel fluctuations were apparent in riparian groundwater. This study outlines the role of hillslope hydrogeology and its influence on the translation of evapotranspiration and soil moisture fluctuations to groundwater and stream fluctuations. 
    more » « less
  5. Two- and three-dimensional rock-penetrating-radar data were acquired on the wall of a pillar in an underground limestone mine. The objective was to test the ability of radar to image fractures and karst voids and to characterize their geometry, aperture, and fluid content, with the goal of mitigating mining hazards. Strong radar reflections in the field data correlate with fractures and a cave exposed on the pillar walls. Large pillar wall topography was included in the steep-dip Kirchhoff migration algorithm because standard elevation corrections are inaccurate. The depth-migrated 250 MHz radar images illuminate fractures, karst voids, and the far wall of the pillar up to approximately 25 m depth into the rock, with a spatial resolution of <0.5 m. Higher frequency radar improved the image resolution and aided in the interpretation, but at the cost of shallower depth of penetration and extra acquisition effort. Due to the strong contrast in physical properties between the rock and the fracture fluid, fractures with apertures as thin as a 50th of a radar wavelength were imaged. Water-filled fractures with mm-scale aperture and air-filled fractures with cm-scale apertures produce strong reflections at 250 MHz. A strong variation in the reflection amplitude along each fracture is interpreted to represent the variable fracture aperture and the nonplanar fracture structure. Fracture apertures were quantitatively measured, but distinguishing water from air-filled fractures was not possible due to the complex radar wavelet and fracture geometry. Two conjugate fracture sets were imaged. One of these fracture sets dominates the rock mass stability and water inrush challenges throughout the mine. All of the detected voids and a large cave are at the intersection of two fractures, indicating preferential water flow and dissolution along conjugate fracture intersections. Detecting, locating, and characterizing fractures and voids prior to excavation can enable miners to mitigate potential collapse and flood hazards before they occur. 
    more » « less