skip to main content


Title: Reply to the ‘Comment on “Tensional homeostasis at different length scales” by J. Humphrey and C. Cyron, Soft Matter , 2022, 18 , DOI: 10.1039/D1SM01151K’
Drs Humphrey and Cyron wrote a commentary regarding our review article entitled “Tensional homeostasis at different length scales” that was published in Soft Matter , 2020, 16 , 6946–6963. These authors brought up some valid concerns to which we would like to respond. Their first concern is related to our remark regarding equations that we used to describe homeostasis in blood vessels, where we stated that those equations were limited only to linearly elastic materials. We were wrong, and we agree with the authors that these equations hold for all cylindrical vessels regardless of their material properties. Their second concern is related to tensional homeostasis at the subcellular level. Drs Humphrey and Cyron disagree with our substantiated claim that tensional homeostasis breaks down at the level of focal adhesions (FAs) of a living cell. In our reply, we provided several pieces of evidence that demonstrate that tensional homeostasis depends upon FA size, FA maturity and FA force dynamics and thus, tensional homeostasis cannot hold in all FAs across a cell. In summary, we are grateful for the opportunity to reply to the commentary of Drs Humphrey and Cyron. Moreover, we are excited that this topic has become an important focus in the biomechanics and mechanobiology communities, and we feel strongly that critical feedback is necessary to move this field forward.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1910401
NSF-PAR ID:
10318581
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Soft Matter
Volume:
18
Issue:
3
ISSN:
1744-683X
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Plant fatty acids (FAs) and lipids are essential in storing energy and act as structural components for cell membranes and signaling molecules for plant growth and stress responses. Acyl Carrier Proteins (ACPs) are small acidic proteins that covalently bind the fatty acyl intermediates during the elongation of FAs. The Arabidopsis thaliana ACP family has eight members. Through reverse genetic, molecular, and biochemical approaches, we have discovered that ACP1 localizes to the chloroplast and limits the magnitude of pattern-triggered immunity (PTI) against the bacterial pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pathovar tomato (Pto). The mutant acp1 plants have reduced levels of linolenic acid (18:3), which is the primary precursor for the biosynthesis of the phytohormone jasmonic acid (JA), and a corresponding decrease in the abundance of JA. Consistent with the known antagonistic relationship between JA and salicylic acid (SA), acp1 mutant plants also accumulate higher level of SA and display the corresponding shifts in JA- and SA-regulated transcriptional outputs. Moreover, the methyl JA and linolenic acid treatments cause an apparently enhanced decrease of resistance against Pto in acp1 mutants than that in wild-type plants. The ability of ACP1 to prevent this hormone imbalance likely underlies its negative impact on PTI in plant defense. Thus, ACP1 links FA metabolism to stress hormone homeostasis to be negatively involved in PTI in Arabidopsis plant defense. 
    more » « less
  2. In epithelia, breakdown of tensional homeostasis is closely associated with E-cadherin dysfunction and disruption of tissue function and integrity. In this study, we investigated the effect of E-cadherin mutations affecting distinct protein domains on tensional homeostasis of gastric cancer cells. We used micropattern traction microscopy to measure temporal fluctuations of cellular traction forces in AGS cells transfected with the wild-type E-cadherin or with variants affecting the extracellular, the juxtamembrane, and the intracellular domains of the protein. We focused on the dynamic aspect of tensional homeostasis, namely the ability of cells to maintain a consistent level of tension, with low temporal variability around a set point. Cells were cultured on hydrogels micropatterned with different extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins to test whether the ECM adhesion impacts cell behavior. A combination of Fibronectin and Vitronectin was used as a substrate that promotes the adhesive ability of E-cadherin dysfunctional cells, whereas Collagen VI was used to test an unfavorable ECM condition. Our results showed that mutations affecting distinct E-cadherin domains influenced differently cell tensional homeostasis, and pinpointed the juxtamembrane and intracellular regions of E-cadherin as the key players in this process. Furthermore, Fibronectin and Vitronectin might modulate cancer cell behavior towards tensional homeostasis. 
    more » « less
  3. Tensional homeostasis is a phenomenon of fundamental importance in mechanobiology. It refers to the ability of organs, tissues, and cells to respond to external disturbances by maintaining a homeostatic (set point) level of mechanical stress (tension). It is well documented that breakdown in tensional homeostasis is the hallmark of progression of diseases, including cancer and atherosclerosis. In this review, we surveyed quantitative studies of tensional homeostasis with the goal of providing characterization of this phenomenon across a broad range of length scales, from the organ level to the subcellular level. We considered both static and dynamics approaches that have been used in studies of this phenomenon. Results that we found in the literature and that we obtained from our own investigations suggest that tensional homeostasis is an emergent phenomenon driven by collective rheostatic mechanisms associated with focal adhesions, and by a collective action of cells in multicellular forms, whose impact on tensional homeostasis is cell type-dependent and cell microenvironment-dependent. Additionally, the finding that cadherins, adhesion molecules that are important for formation of cell–cell junctions, promote tensional homeostasis even in single cells, demonstrates their relevance as a signaling moiety. 
    more » « less
  4. The ability of cells to maintain a constant level of cytoskeletal tension in response to external and internal disturbances is referred to as tensional homeostasis. It is essential for the normal physiological function of cells and tissues, and for protection against disease progression, including atherosclerosis and cancer. In previous studies, we defined tensional homeostasis as the ability of cells to maintain a consistent level of cytoskeletal tension with low temporal fluctuations. In those studies, we measured temporal fluctuations of cell-substrate traction forces in clusters of endothelial cells and of fibroblasts. We observed those temporal fluctuations to decrease with increasing cluster size in endothelial cells, but not in fibroblasts. We quantified temporal fluctuation, and thus homeostasis, through the coefficient of variation (CV) of the traction field; the lower the value of CV, the closer the cell is to the state of tensional homeostasis. This metric depends on correlation between individual traction forces. In this study, we analyzed the contribution of correlation between traction forces on traction field CV in clusters of endothelial cells and fibroblasts using experimental data that we had obtained previously. Results of our analysis showed that positive correlation between traction forces was detrimental to homeostasis, and that it was cell type-dependent. 
    more » « less
  5. The contributions of skeletal cells to the processes of B cell development in the bone marrow (BM) have not been completely described. The von-Hippel Lindau protein (VHL) plays a key role in cellular responses to hypoxia. Previous work showed that Dmp1 -Cre; Vhl conditional knockout mice ( Vhl cKO), which deletes Vhl in subsets of mesenchymal stem cells, late osteoblasts and osteocytes, display dysregulated bone growth and reduction in B cells. Here, we investigated the mechanisms underlying the B cell defects using flow cytometry and high-resolution imaging. In the Vhl cKO BM, B cell progenitors were increased in frequency and number, whereas Hardy Fractions B-F were decreased. Vhl cKO Fractions B-C cells showed increased apoptosis and quiescence. Reciprocal BM chimeras confirmed a B cell-extrinsic source of the Vhl cKO B cell defects. In support of this, Vhl cKO BM supernatant contained reduced CXCL12 and elevated EPO levels. Intravital and ex vivo imaging revealed Vhl cKO BM blood vessels with increased diameter, volume, and a diminished blood-BM barrier. Staining of Vhl cKO B cells with an intracellular hypoxic marker indicated the natural existence of distinct B cell microenvironments that differ in local oxygen tensions and that the B cell developmental defects in Vhl cKO BM are not initiated by hypoxia. Our studies identify novel mechanisms linking altered bone homeostasis with drastic BM microenvironmental changes that dysregulate B cell development. 
    more » « less