skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


Title: LinDA: linear models for differential abundance analysis of microbiome compositional data
Abstract Differential abundance analysis is at the core of statistical analysis of microbiome data. The compositional nature of microbiome sequencing data makes false positive control challenging. Here, we show that the compositional effects can be addressed by a simple, yet highly flexible and scalable, approach. The proposed method, LinDA, only requires fitting linear regression models on the centered log-ratio transformed data, and correcting the bias due to compositional effects. We show that LinDA enjoys asymptotic FDR control and can be extended to mixed-effect models for correlated microbiome data. Using simulations and real examples, we demonstrate the effectiveness of LinDA.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2113360 2113359 1811747
PAR ID:
10324490
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Genome Biology
Volume:
23
Issue:
1
ISSN:
1474-760X
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; (, Briefings in Bioinformatics)
    Abstract Differential abundance analysis (DAA) is one central statistical task in microbiome data analysis. A robust and powerful DAA tool can help identify highly confident microbial candidates for further biological validation. Current microbiome studies frequently generate correlated samples from different microbiome sampling schemes such as spatial and temporal sampling. In the past decade, a number of DAA tools for correlated microbiome data (DAA-c) have been proposed. Disturbingly, different DAA-c tools could sometimes produce quite discordant results. To recommend the best practice to the field, we performed the first comprehensive evaluation of existing DAA-c tools using real data-based simulations. Overall, the linear model-based methods LinDA, MaAsLin2 and LDM are more robust than methods based on generalized linear models. The LinDA method is the only method that maintains reasonable performance in the presence of strong compositional effects. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ; (, Genes)
    It is well known that the microbiome data are ridden with outliers and have heavy distribution tails, but the impact of outliers and heavy-tailedness has yet to be examined systematically. This paper investigates the impact of outliers and heavy-tailedness on differential abundance analysis (DAA) using the linear models for the differential abundance analysis (LinDA) method and proposes effective strategies to mitigate their influence. The presence of outliers and heavy-tailedness can significantly decrease the power of LinDA. We investigate various techniques to address outliers and heavy-tailedness, including generalizing LinDA into a more flexible framework that allows for the use of robust regression and winsorizing the data before applying LinDA. Our extensive numerical experiments and real-data analyses demonstrate that robust Huber regression has overall the best performance in addressing outliers and heavy-tailedness. 
    more » « less
  3. ; (, Microbiome)
    Abstract Background Differential abundance analysis (DAA) is one central statistical task in microbiome data analysis. A robust and powerful DAA tool can help identify highly confident microbial candidates for further biological validation. Numerous DAA tools have been proposed in the past decade addressing the special characteristics of microbiome data such as zero inflation and compositional effects. Disturbingly, different DAA tools could sometimes produce quite discordant results, opening to the possibility of cherry-picking the tool in favor of one’s own hypothesis. To recommend the best DAA tool or practice to the field, a comprehensive evaluation, which covers as many biologically relevant scenarios as possible, is critically needed. Results We performed by far the most comprehensive evaluation of existing DAA tools using real data-based simulations. We found that DAA methods explicitly addressing compositional effects such as ANCOM-BC, Aldex2, metagenomeSeq (fitFeatureModel), and DACOMP did have improved performance in false-positive control. But they are still not optimal: type 1 error inflation or low statistical power has been observed in many settings. The recent LDM method generally had the best power, but its false-positive control in the presence of strong compositional effects was not satisfactory. Overall, none of the evaluated methods is simultaneously robust, powerful, and flexible, which makes the selection of the best DAA tool difficult. To meet the analysis needs, we designed an optimized procedure, ZicoSeq, drawing on the strength of the existing DAA methods. We show that ZicoSeq generally controlled for false positives across settings, and the power was among the highest. Application of DAA methods to a large collection of real datasets revealed a similar pattern observed in simulation studies. Conclusions Based on the benchmarking study, we conclude that none of the existing DAA methods evaluated can be applied blindly to any real microbiome dataset. The applicability of an existing DAA method depends on specific settings, which are usually unknown a priori. To circumvent the difficulty of selecting the best DAA tool in practice, we design ZicoSeq, which addresses the major challenges in DAA and remedies the drawbacks of existing DAA methods. ZicoSeq can be applied to microbiome datasets from diverse settings and is a useful DAA tool for robust microbiome biomarker discovery. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; (, Biometrics)
    Abstract A critical task in microbiome data analysis is to explore the association between a scalar response of interest and a large number of microbial taxa that are summarized as compositional data at different taxonomic levels. Motivated by fine‐mapping of the microbiome, we propose a two‐step compositional knockoff filter to provide the effective finite‐sample false discovery rate (FDR) control in high‐dimensional linear log‐contrast regression analysis of microbiome compositional data. In the first step, we propose a new compositional screening procedure to remove insignificant microbial taxa while retaining the essential sum‐to‐zero constraint. In the second step, we extend the knockoff filter to identify the significant microbial taxa in the sparse regression model for compositional data. Thereby, a subset of the microbes is selected from the high‐dimensional microbial taxa as related to the response under a prespecified FDR threshold. We study the theoretical properties of the proposed two‐step procedure, including both sure screening and effective false discovery control. We demonstrate these properties in numerical simulation studies to compare our methods to some existing ones and show power gain of the new method while controlling the nominal FDR. The potential usefulness of the proposed method is also illustrated with application to an inflammatory bowel disease data set to identify microbial taxa that influence host gene expressions. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (, mSystems)
    ABSTRACT The central aims of many host or environmental microbiome studies are to elucidate factors associated with microbial community compositions and to relate microbial features to outcomes. However, these aims are often complicated by difficulties stemming from high-dimensionality, non-normality, sparsity, and the compositional nature of microbiome data sets. A key tool in microbiome analysis is beta diversity, defined by the distances between microbial samples. Many different distance metrics have been proposed, all with varying discriminatory power on data with differing characteristics. Here, we propose a compositional beta diversity metric rooted in a centered log-ratio transformation and matrix completion called robust Aitchison PCA. We demonstrate the benefits of compositional transformations upstream of beta diversity calculations through simulations. Additionally, we demonstrate improved effect size, classification accuracy, and robustness to sequencing depth over the current methods on several decreased sample subsets of real microbiome data sets. Finally, we highlight the ability of this new beta diversity metric to retain the feature loadings linked to sample ordinations revealing salient intercommunity niche feature importance. IMPORTANCE By accounting for the sparse compositional nature of microbiome data sets, robust Aitchison PCA can yield high discriminatory power and salient feature ranking between microbial niches. The software to perform this analysis is available under an open-source license and can be obtained at https://github.com/biocore/DEICODE ; additionally, a QIIME 2 plugin is provided to perform this analysis at https://library.qiime2.org/plugins/q2-deicode . 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email