skip to main content


Title: A viscoelastic model for seismic attenuation using fractal mechanical networks
SUMMARY Seismic attenuation (quantified by the quality factor Q) has a significant impact on the seismic waveforms, especially in the fluid-saturated rocks. This dissipative process can be phenomenologically represented by viscoelastic models. Previous seismological studies show that the Q value of Earth media exhibits a nearly frequency-independent behaviour (often referred to as constant-Q in literature) in the seismic frequency range. Such attenuation can be described by the mathematical Kjartansson constant-Q model, which lacks of a physical representation in the viscoelastic sense. Inspired by the fractal nature of the pore fluid distribution in patchy-saturated rocks, here we propose two fractal mechanical network (FMN) models, that is, a fractal tree model and a quasi-fractal ladder model, to phenomenologically represent the frequency-independent Q behaviour. As with the classic viscoelastic models, the FMN models are composed of mechanical elements (spring and dashpots) arranged in different hierarchical patterns. A particular parametrization of each model can produce the same complex modulus as in the Kjartansson model, which leads to the constant-Q. Applying the theory to several typical rock samples, we find that the seismic attenuation signature of these rocks can be accurately represented by either one of the FMN models. Besides, we demonstrate that the ladder model in particular exhibits the realistic multiscale fractal structure of the saturated rocks. Therefore, the FMN models as a proxy could provide a new way to estimate the microscopic rock structure property from macroscopic seismic attenuation observation.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1919650
NSF-PAR ID:
10338647
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Geophysical Journal International
Volume:
224
Issue:
3
ISSN:
0956-540X
Page Range / eLocation ID:
1658 to 1669
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    Subduction zone accretionary prisms are commonly modeled as elastic structures where permanent deformation is accommodated by faulting and folding of otherwise elastic materials, yet accretionary prisms may exhibit other deformation styles over relatively short time scales. In this study, we use 6.5‐year (2014–2021) Sentinel‐1 interferometric synthetic aperture radar (InSAR) time‐series of post‐seismic deformation in the Makran accretionary prism of southeast Pakistan to characterize non‐linear viscoelastic deformation within an active accretionary prism on short timescales (months to years). We constructed a series of 3‐D finite‐element models of the Makran subduction zone, including an accretionary prism, and constrained the elastic thickness of the upper wedge and the flow‐law parameters (power‐law exponent, activation enthalpy, and pre‐exponential constant) of the lower wedge through forward model fits to the InSAR time‐series. Our results show that the prism is elastically thin (8–12 km) and the non‐linear viscoelastic relaxation of the deep portions of the prism alone can sufficiently explain the post‐seismic surface deformation. Our best fitting flow‐law parameters (n = 3.76 ± 0.39,Q = 82.2 ± 37.73 kJ mol−1, andA = 10−3.36±4.69) are consistent with triggering of low temperature dislocation creep within fluid‐saturated siliciclastic rocks. We believe that the fluids necessary for this weakening originate from sedimentary underplating and/or the presence the hydrocarbons. The presence of power‐law rheology within the lower wedge impacts the estimated plate coupling and the stress state in the subduction system, with respect to the conventional elastic wedge model, and hence should to be considered in future earthquake cycle models.

     
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    SUMMARY Seismic attenuation is measured from a swarm of 50 earthquakes in Kīlauea volcano in 2018, associated with caldera collapse. The traverse extends at nearly constant azimuth to the saddle between Mauna Loa and Mauna Kea, continuing to Maui beneath the distal flanks of three dormant volcanos. From Maui the traverse then extends seaward to the Aloha Cabled Observatory (ACO) on the seafloor north of O‘ahu. The effective attenuation is measured with respect to an ${\omega ^{ - 2}}$ earthquake source model. Frequency dependent ${Q_P}$ and ${Q_S}$ are derived. The initial path is shallow and uphill, the path to Maui propagates at mid-crustal depths, and the path to ACO extends through oceanic crust. The observations of ${Q_P} \le {Q_S}$ over each traverse are modelled as bulk attenuation ${Q_K}$. Several attenuation processes are observed, including ${Q_\mu }$, ${Q_K}$, $Q\sim f$, constant Q and scattering. The observation of bulk attenuation is ascribed to contrasting physical properties between basalt and water saturated vesicles. The ratio of Q values between shallow and mid-crustal propagation is used to derive an activation energy E* for the undetermined shear attenuation mechanism. A Debye relaxation peak is fit to the ${Q_S}( f )$ and ${Q_K}( f )$ observed for the mid-crustal pathway. A prior high-frequency attenuation study near Wake Island compares well with this Hawaiian Q data set, which in general shows lower values of Q than observed for Wake. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    The operation of fracture, diffusion, and intracrystalline‐plastic micromechanisms during semibrittle deformation of rock is directly relevant to understanding mechanical behavior across the brittle‐plastic transition in the crust. An outstanding question is whether (1) the micromechanisms of semibrittle flow can be considered to operate independently, as represented in typical crustal strength profiles across the brittle to plastic transition, or (2) the micromechanisms are coupled such that the transition is represented by a distinct rheology with dependency on effective pressure, temperature, and strain rate. We employ triaxial stress‐cycling experiments to investigate elastic‐plastic and viscoelastic behaviors during semibrittle flow in two distinctly different monomineralic, polycrystalline, synthetic salt‐rocks. During semibrittle flow at high differential stress, granular, low‐porosity, work‐hardened salt‐rocks deform predominantly by grain‐boundary sliding and wing‐crack opening accompanied by minor intragranular dislocation glide. In contrast, fully annealed, near‐zero porosity salt‐rocks flow at lower differential stress by intragranular dislocation glide accompanied by grain‐boundary sliding and opening. Grain‐boundary sliding is frictional during semibrittle flow at higher strain rates, but the associated dispersal of water from fluid inclusions along boundaries can activate fluid‐assisted diffusional sliding at lower strain rates. Changes in elastic properties with semibrittle flow largely reflect activation of sliding along closed grain boundaries. Observed microstructures, pronounced hysteresis and anelasticity during cyclic stressing after semibrittle flow, and stress relaxation behaviors indicate coupled operation of micromechanisms leading to a distinct rheology (hypothesis 2 above).

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Fractured rock permeability can increase by crack extension that creates additional flow pathways or by increases in crack openings that increase crack transmissivity. Understanding the partitioning between these two mechanisms during rock deformation is critical for conceptual models of fluid flow and transport in crystalline rocks and sedimentary layers with low matrix permeability and for the hydromechanics of crustal rocks. Using ice as a model for rock, new systematic experiments reveal that when subject to uniaxial loading at a constant strain rate, crack density remains nearly constant after the onset of percolation even while permeability increases, indicating that after the onset of percolation the increase in permeability is primarily due to the opening of existing cracks rather than the extension of cracks. These observations have implications for conceptual models of fractured rock permeability that often focus on the evolution of permeability with changing fracture density rather than changing fracture transmissivity and for attempts to link fractured rock permeability to seismic properties that often dominantly consider changes in crack density rather than crack apertures.

     
    more » « less
  5. SUMMARY

    The spatio-temporal properties of seismicity give us incisive insight into the stress state evolution and fault structures of the crust. Empirical models based on self-exciting point processes continue to provide an important tool for analysing seismicity, given the epistemic uncertainty associated with physical models. In particular, the epidemic-type aftershock sequence (ETAS) model acts as a reference model for studying seismicity catalogues. The traditional ETAS model uses simple parametric definitions for the background rate of triggering-independent seismicity. This reduces the effectiveness of the basic ETAS model in modelling the temporally complex seismicity patterns seen in seismic swarms that are dominated by aseismic tectonic processes such as fluid injection rather than aftershock triggering. In order to robustly capture time-varying seismicity rates, we introduce a deep Gaussian process (GP) formulation for the background rate as an extension to ETAS. GPs are a robust non-parametric model for function spaces with covariance structure. By conditioning the length-scale structure of a GP with another GP, we have a deep-GP: a probabilistic, hierarchical model that automatically tunes its structure to match data constraints. We show how the deep-GP-ETAS model can be efficiently sampled by making use of a Metropolis-within-Gibbs scheme, taking advantage of the branching process formulation of ETAS and a stochastic partial differential equation (SPDE) approximation for Matérn GPs. We illustrate our method using synthetic examples, and show that the deep-GP-ETAS model successfully captures multiscale temporal behaviour in the background forcing rate of seismicity. We then apply the results to two real-data catalogues: the Ridgecrest, CA 2019 July 5 Mw 7.1 event catalogue, showing that deep-GP-ETAS can successfully characterize a classical aftershock sequence; and the 2016–2019 Cahuilla, CA earthquake swarm, which shows two distinct phases of aseismic forcing concordant with a fluid injection-driven initial sequence, arrest of the fluid along a physical barrier and release following the largest Mw 4.4 event of the sequence.

     
    more » « less