skip to main content


Title: Enhancing Ocean Biogeochemical Models With Phytoplankton Variable Composition
Chlorophyll (Chl) is widely taken as a proxy for phytoplankton biomass, despite well-known variations in Chl:C:biomass ratios as an acclimative response to changing environmental conditions. For the sake of simplicity and computational efficiency, many large scale biogeochemical models ignore this flexibility, compromising their ability to capture phytoplankton dynamics. Here we evaluate modelling approaches of differing complexity for phytoplankton growth response: fixed stoichiometry, fixed stoichiometry with photoacclimation, classical variable-composition with photoacclimation, and Instantaneous Acclimation with optimal resource allocation. Model performance is evaluated against biogeochemical observations from time-series sites BATS and ALOHA, where phytoplankton composition varies substantially. We analyse the sensitivity of each model variant to the affinity parameters for light and nutrient, respectively. Models with fixed stoichiometry are more sensitive to parameter perturbations, but the inclusion of photoacclimation in the fixed-stoichiometry model generally captures Chl observations better than other variants when individually tuned for each site and when using similar parameter sets for both sites. Compared to the fixed stoichiometry model including photoacclimation, models with variable C:N ratio perform better in cross-validation experiments using model-specific parameter sets tuned for the other site; i.e., they are more portable. Compared to typical variable composition approaches, instantaneous acclimation, which requires fewer state variables, generally yields better performance but somewhat lower portability than the fully dynamic variant. Further assessments using objective optimisation and more contrasting stations are suggested.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1756517
PAR ID:
10342384
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Frontiers in Marine Science
Volume:
8
ISSN:
2296-7745
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Realistic model representation of ocean phytoplankton is important for simulating nutrient cycles and the biological carbon pump, which affects atmospheric carbon dioxide (pCO2) concentrations and, thus, climate. Until recently, most models assumed constant ratios (or stoichiometry) of phosphorous (P), nitrogen (N), silicon (Si), and carbon (C) in phytoplankton, despite observations indicating systematic variations. Here, we investigate the effects of variable stoichiometry on simulated nutrient distributions, plankton community compositions, and the C cycle in the preindustrial (PI) and glacial oceans. Using a biogeochemical model, a linearly increasing P:N relation to increasing PO4 is implemented for ordinary phytoplankton (PO), and a nonlinearly decreasing Si:N relation to increasing Fe is applied to diatoms (PDiat). C:N remains fixed. Variable P:N affects modeled community composition through enhanced PO4 availability, which increases N-fixers in the oligotrophic ocean, consistent with previous research. This increases the NO3 fertilization of PO, the NO3 inventory, and the total plankton biomass. The accuracy of modeled surface nutrients is relatively unchanged. Conversely, variable Si:N shifts south the Southern Ocean’s meridional surface silicate gradient, which aligns better with observations, but depresses PDiat growth globally. In Last Glacial Maximum simulations, PO respond to more oligotrophic conditions by increasing their C:P. This strengthens the biologically mediated C storage such that dissolved organic (inorganic) C inventories increase by 34-40 (38-50) Pg C and 0.7-1.2 Pg yr-1 more particulate C is exported into the interior ocean. Thus, an additional 13-14 ppm of pCO2 difference from PI levels results, improving model agreement with glacial observations. 
    more » « less
  2. Primary production and photoacclimation models are two important classes of physiological models that find applications in remote sensing of pools and fluxes of carbon associated with phytoplankton in the ocean. They are also key components of ecosystem models designed to study biogeochemical cycles in the ocean. So far, these two classes of models have evolved in parallel, somewhat independently of each other. Here we examine how they are coupled to each other through the intermediary of the photosynthesis–irradiance parameters. We extend the photoacclimation model to accommodate the spectral effects of light penetration in the ocean and the spectral sensitivity of the initial slope of the photosynthesis–irradiance curve, making the photoacclimation model fully compatible with spectrally resolved models of photosynthesis in the ocean. The photoacclimation model contains a parameterθ<#comment/>m, which is the maximum chlorophyll-to-carbon ratio that phytoplankton can attain when available light tends to zero. We explore how size-class-dependent values ofθ<#comment/>mcould be inferred from field data on chlorophyll and carbon content in phytoplankton, and show that the results are generally consistent with lower bounds estimated from satellite-based primary production calculations. This was accomplished using empirical models linking phytoplankton carbon and chlorophyll concentration, and the range of values obtained in culture measurements. We study the equivalence between different classes of primary production models at the functional level, and show that the availability of a chlorophyll-to-carbon ratio facilitates the translation between these classes. We discuss the importance of the better assignment of parameters in primary production models as an important avenue to reduce model uncertainties and to improve the usefulness of satellite-based primary production calculations in climate research.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Phytoplankton stoichiometry modulates the interaction between carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus cycles. Environmentally driven variations in phytoplankton C:N:P can alter biogeochemical cycling compared to expectations under fixed ratios. In fact, the assumption of fixed C:N:P has been linked to Earth System Model (ESM) biases and potential misrepresentation of responses to future change. Here we integrate key elements of the Adaptive Trait Optimization Model (ATOM) for phytoplankton stoichiometry with the Carbon, Ocean Biogeochemistry and Lower Trophics (COBALT) ocean biogeochemical model. Within a series of global ocean‐ice‐ecosystem retrospective simulations, ATOM‐COBALT reproduced observations of phytoplankton N:P, and compared to static ratios, exhibited reduced phytoplankton P‐limitation, enhanced N‐fixation, and increased low‐latitude export, improving consistency with observations and highlighting the biogeochemical implications of dynamic N:P. We applied ATOM‐COBALT to explore the impacts of different physiological mechanisms hypothesized to underlie N:P variation, finding that two mechanisms together drove the observed patterns: proportionality of P‐rich ribosomes in phytoplankton cells to growth rates and reductions in P‐storage during scarcity. A third mechanism which linked temperature with phytoplankton biomass allocations to non‐ribosomal proteins, led only to relatively modest impacts because this mechanism decreased the temperature dependence of phytoplankton growth rates, compensating for changes in N:P. We find that there are quantitative response differences that associate distinctive biogeochemical footprints with each mechanism, which are most apparent in highly productive low‐latitude regions. These results suggest that variable phytoplankton N:P makes phytoplankton productivity and export resilient to environmental changes, and support further research on the physiological and environmental drivers of phytoplankton stoichiometry and biogeochemical role.

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    The elemental ratios of carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus (C:N:P) within organic matter play a key role in coupling biogeochemical cycles in the global ocean. At the cellular level, these ratios are controlled by physiological responses to the environment. But linking these cellular‐level processes to global biogeochemical cycles remains challenging. We present a novel model framework that combines knowledge of phytoplankton cellular functioning with global scale hydrographic data, to assess the role of variable carbon‐to‐phosphorus ratios (RC:P) on the distribution of export production. We implement a trait‐based mechanistic model of phytoplankton growth into a global biogeochemical inverse model to predict global patterns of phytoplankton physiology and stoichiometry that are consistent with both biological growth mechanisms and hydrographic carbon and nutrient observations. We compare this model to empirical parameterizations relatingRC:Pto temperature or phosphate concentration. We find that the way the model represents variable stoichiometry affects the magnitude and spatial pattern of carbon export, with globally integrated fluxes varying by up to 10% (1.3 Pg C yr−1) across models. Despite these differences, all models exhibit strong consistency with observed dissolved inorganic carbon and phosphate concentrations (R2 > 0.9), underscoring the challenge of selecting the most accurate model structure. We also find that the choice of parameterization impacts the capacity of changingRC:Pto buffer predicted export declines. Our novel framework offers a pathway by which additional biological information might be used to reduce the structural uncertainty in model representations of phytoplankton stoichiometry, potentially improving our capacity to project future changes.

     
    more » « less
  5. The underwater light field of lakes, estuaries, and oceans may vary greatly in spectral composition. Phytoplankton in these environments must contain pigments that absorb the available colors of light. If spectral quality changes, acclimation to the new spectral environment would confer an ecological advantage in terms of photosynthesis and growth. Here, we explored the capacity of eight marine cryptophytes to adjust pigmentation in response to changes in spectral irradiance and related effects on light absorption, photosynthetically useable radiation (PUR), and growth rate. The pigment composition of all species changed in some way in response to shifts in spectral irradiance, but not all pigment changes could be considered advantageous in the context of chromatic acclimation. For most species, absorption by chl‐aand chl‐c2resulted in highest absorption in the blue region, highestPURvalues for blue‐light grown cells, and highest growth rates in blue light. The exception wasChroomonas mesostigmatica(CCMP1168), which contains a high percentage of Cryptophyte‐Phycocyanin (Cr‐PC) 645, absorbs strongly in the orange‐to‐red region of the spectrum, and grew fastest under red light. The position and magnitude of the maximum and secondary absorption peak of Cr‐PC569, the phycobiliprotein pigment ofHemiselmis cryptochromatica, varied with spectral irradiance. The underlying cause remains unknown, but may represent a mechanism by which cryptophytes optimize photon capture.

     
    more » « less