skip to main content


Title: The effects of soft and rough substrates on suction-based adhesion
ABSTRACT The northern clingfish (Gobiesox maeandricus) has a suction-based adhesive disc that can stick to incredibly rough surfaces, a challenge for stiff commercial suction cups. Both clingfish discs and bioinspired suction cups have stiff cores but flexible edges that can deform to overcome surface irregularities. Compliant surfaces are common in nature and technical settings, but performance data for fish and commercial cups are gathered from stiff surfaces. We quantified the interaction between substrate compliance, surface roughness and suction performance for the northern clingfish, commercial suction cups and three biomimetic suction cups with disc rims of varying compliance. We found that all cups stick better on stiffer substrates and worse on more compliant ones, as indicated by peak stress values. On compliant substrates, surface roughness had little effect on adhesion, even for commercial cups that normally fail on hard, rough surfaces. We propose that suction performance on compliant substrates can be explained in part by effective elastic modulus, the combined elastic modulus from a cup–substrate interaction. Of all the tested cups, the biomimetic cups performed the best on compliant surfaces, highlighting their potential to be used in medical and marine geotechnical fields. Lastly, we discuss the overmolding technique used to generate the bioinspired cups and how it is an important tool for studying biology.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1759637 1701665
NSF-PAR ID:
10353979
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Experimental Biology
Volume:
225
Issue:
9
ISSN:
0022-0949
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    It has been nearly 20 years since Autumn and colleagues established the central role of van der Waals intermolecular forces in how geckos stick. Much has been discovered about the structure and function of fibrillar adhesives in geckos and other taxa, and substantial success has been achieved in translating natural models into bioinspired synthetic adhesives. Nevertheless, synthetics still cannot match the multidimensional performance observed in the natural gecko system that is simultaneously robust to dirt and water, resilient over thousands of cycles, and purportedly competent on surfaces that are rough at drastically different length scales. Apparent insensitivity of adhesion to variability in roughness is particularly interesting from both a theoretical and applied perspective. Progress on understanding the extent to which and the basis of how the gecko adhesive system is robust to variation in roughness is impeded by the complexity of quantifying roughness of natural surfaces and a dearth of data on free-ranging gecko substrate use. Here we review the main challenges in characterizing rough surfaces as they relate to collecting relevant estimates of variation in gecko adhesive performance across different substrates in their natural habitats. In response to these challenges, we propose a practical protocol (borrowing from thermal biophysical ecological methods) that will enable researchers to design detailed studies of structure–function relationships of the gecko fibrillar system. Employing such an approach will help provide specific hypotheses about how adhesive pad structure translates into a capacity for robust gecko adhesion across large variation in substrate roughness. Preliminary data we present on this approach suggest its promise in advancing the study of how geckos deal with roughness variation. We argue and outline how such data can help advance development of design parameters to improve bioinspired adhesives based on the gecko fibrillar system.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract Flexible electronics often employ composite inks consisting of conductive flakes embedded in a polymer matrix to transmit electrical signal. Recently, localized necking was identified as a cause of a substantial increase in normalized resistance with applied strain thereby adversely impacting electrical performance. The current study explores two possible contributing factors for the formation of such localization—ink surface roughness and local variations in silver flake volume fraction. Uniaxial tension experiments of a DuPont 5025 type ink are used to inform a constitutive model implemented using finite element method on different substrates. Surface roughness was modeled by sinusoidal variation in ink height, whose amplitude and wavelength are informed by experimental laser profilometry scan data. Local flake fraction variations obtained from experimental measurements before applying any strain, were modeled as local variations in the elastic modulus according to an inverse rule of mixtures between the silver flake and acrylic binder material properties. The study identified that the ink height roughness is the most impactful contributor to the subsequent strain localization. The substrate elastic properties impact the number and magnitude of localization bands, with the stiffer substrate delocalizing strain and averting catastrophic crack formation seen with a more compliant substrate. The model incorporating surface roughness closely matches experimental measurements of local strain across different substrates. The study can inform designers of the adverse impact of ink surface roughness on localization and subsequent detrimental increase of the resistance. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Animal movement is often largely determined by abiotic conditions of the environment, including substrate properties. While a large body of work has improved our understanding of how different substrate properties can impact locomotor performance and behaviour, few of these studies have investigated this relationship during transitions within a single locomotor event.

    In nature, terrestrial animals frequently encounter substrate transitions, or changes in substrate level, incline, texture and/or compliance during a single bout of movement, which can be sudden for high‐speed animals. These animals often adjust their posture and kinematics during transitions, and in some cases lose forward velocity.

    We examined the occurrence and effect of non‐elastic compliance transitions inRhoptropus afer, a cursorial day gecko known for its ability to sprint rapidly for several metres at a time. We recorded substrate use during provoked escapes in the field and conducted locomotor trials on a trackway that mimicked natural structural habitat conditions with transitions from a rigid surface into sand and from sand back to a rigid surface.

    During escapes,R. aferused substrates of different compliance (i.e. rock, gravel and sand) and transitioned to and from the more compliant surfaces with even frequency, which matched substrate and compliance availability estimates. In laboratory experiments, sprint speed was not significantly affected by acute changes in compliance, which was likely facilitated by an increased body angle and duty factor upon entering the sand, and potentially a high yield strength of the sand relative to applied forces.

    We speculate that this species' ability to maintain speed during compliance transitions underlies their apparent indiscriminate substrate use during escapes, and that this behaviour may offer a selective advantage for evading larger terrestrial predators. Using field data to inform and contextualize laboratory experiments thus yields important insights as to how animals accommodate acute changes in substrate conditions encountered during critical locomotor events.

    A freePlain Language Summarycan be found within the Supporting Information of this article.

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    The roughness and wettability of surfaces exploited by free-ranging geckos can be highly variable and attachment to these substrates is context dependent (e.g., presence or absence of surface water). Although previous studies focus on the effect of these variables on attachment independently, geckos encounter a variety of conditions in their natural environment simultaneously. Here, we measured maximum shear load of geckos in air and when their toes were submerged underwater on substrates that varied in both surface roughness and wettability. Gecko attachment was greater in water than in air on smooth and rough hydrophobic substrates, and attachment to rough hydrophilic substrates did not differ when tested in air or water. Attachment varied considerably with surface roughness and characterization revealed that routine measurements of root mean square height can misrepresent the complexity of roughness, especially when measured with single instruments. We used surface roughness power spectra to characterize substrate surface roughness and examined the relationship between gecko attachment performance across the power spectra. This comparison suggests that roughness wavelengths less than 70 nm predominantly dictate gecko attachment. This study highlights the complexity of attachment in natural conditions and the need for comprehensive surface characterization when studying biological adhesive system performance.

     
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    In riverine ecosystems, downstream drag caused by fast‐flowing water poses a significant challenge to rheophilic organisms. In neotropical rivers, many members of a diverse radiation of suckermouth catfishes (Loricarioidei) resist drag in part by using modified lips that form an oral suction cup composed of thick flesh. Histological composition and morphology of this cup are interspecifically highly variable. Through an examination of 23 loricarioid species, we determined that the tissue most responsible for lip fleshiness is collagen. We hypothesized that lip collagen content is interspecifically correlated with substrate and flow so that fishes living on rocky substrates in high‐flow environments have the largest, most collagenous lips. By mapping the amount and distribution of lip collagen onto a phylogeny and conducting ANOVA tests, we found support for this hypothesis. Moreover, these traits evolved multiple times in correlation with substrate and flow, suggesting they are an effective means for improving suction‐based attachment. We hypothesize that collagen functions to reinforce oral suction cups, reducing the likelihood of slipping, buckling, and failure under high‐flow, high‐drag conditions. Macroevolutionary patterns among loricarioid catfishes suggest that for maximum performance, biomimetic suction cups should vary in material density according to drag and substrate requirements.

     
    more » « less