skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Some concrete steps for journal editorial boards: A commentary on Kidd and Garcia (2022)
As members of the editorial team at Language Acquisition, we read Kidd and Garcia’s target article with enthusiasm. In our commentary, we outline some specific ideas for how journals can help to alleviate the issues raised by Kidd and Garcia, some of which are in progress or in place at Language Acquisition, and some of which we hope to undertake alongside other journals in the field. We focus on concrete steps, acknowledging that systemic changes, too, will be required to ensure that our science reflects the diversity of languages learned.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1844194
PAR ID:
10355559
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
First Language
ISSN:
0142-7237
Page Range / eLocation ID:
014272372210960
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Registered reports are a new publication workflow where the decision to publish is made prior to data collection and analysis and thus cannot be dependent on the outcome of the study. An increasing number of journals have adopted this new mechanism, but previous research suggests that submission rates are still relatively low. We conducted a census of journals publishing registered reports (N = 278) using independent coders to collect information from submission guidelines, with the goal of documenting journals’ early adoption of registered reports. Our results show that the majority of journals adopting registered reports are in psychology, and it typically takes about a year to publish the first registered report after adopting. Still, many journals have not published their first registered report. There is high variability in impact of journals adopting registered reports. Many journals do not include concrete information about policies that address concerns about registered reports (e.g., exploratory analysis); however, those that do typically allow these practices with some restrictions. Additionally, other open science practices are commonly encouraged or required as part of the registered report process, especially open data and materials. Overall, many journals did not include many of the fields coded by the research team, which could be a barrier to submission for some authors. Though the majority of journals allow authors to be anonymous during the review process, a sizable portion do not, which could also be a barrier to submission. We conclude with future directions and implications for authors of registered reports, journals that have already adopted registered reports, and journals that may consider adopting registered reports in the future. 
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    Acquisition of natural language has been shown to fundamentally impact both one’s ability to use the first language and the ability to learn subsequent languages later in life. Sign languages offer a unique perspective on this issue because Deaf signers receive access to signed input at varying ages. The majority acquires sign language in (early) childhood, but some learn sign language later—a situation that is drastically different from that of spoken language acquisition. To investigate the effect of age of sign language acquisition and its potential interplay with age in signers, we examined grammatical acceptability ratings and reaction time measures in a group of Deaf signers (age range = 28–58 years) with early (0–3 years) or later (4–7 years) acquisition of sign language in childhood. Behavioral responses to grammatical word order variations (subject–object–verb [SOV] vs. object–subject–verb [OSV]) were examined in sentences that included (1) simple sentences, (2) topicalized sentences, and (3) sentences involving manual classifier constructions, uniquely characteristic of sign languages. Overall, older participants responded more slowly. Age of acquisition had subtle effects on acceptability ratings, whereby the direction of the effect depended on the specific linguistic structure. 
    more » « less
  3. Grounded language acquisition is concerned with learning the meaning of language as it applies to the physical world. As robots become more capable and ubiquitous, there is an increasing need for non-specialists to interact with and control them, and natural language is an intuitive, flexible, and customizable mechanism for such communication. At the same time, physically embodied agents offer a way to learn to understand natural language in the context of the world to which it refers. This paper gives an overview of the research area, selected recent advances, and some future directions and challenges that remain. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract As the use of artificial intelligence (AI) has grown exponentially across a wide variety of science applications, it has become clear that it is critical to share data and code to facilitate reproducibility and innovation. AMS recently adopted the requirement that all papers include an availability statement. However, there is no requirement to ensure that the data and code are actually freely accessible during and after publication. Studies show that without this requirement, data is openly available in about a third to a half of journal articles. In this work, we surveyed two AMS journals, Artificial Intelligence for the Earth Systems (AIES) and Monthly Weather Review (MWR), and two non-AMS journals. These journals varied in primary topic foci, publisher, and requirement of an availability statement. We examined the extent to which data and code are stated to be available in all four journals, if readers could easily access the data and code, and what common justifications were provided for articles without open data or code. Our analysis found that roughly 75% of all articles that produced data and had an availability statement made at least some of their data openly available. Code was made openly available less frequently in three out of the four journals examined. Access was inhibited to data or code in approximately 15% of availability statement that contained at least one link. Finally, the most common justifications for not making data or code openly available referenced dataset size and restrictions of availability from non-co-author entities. 
    more » « less
  5. Learning to understand grounded language, which connects natural language to percepts, is a critical research area. Prior work in grounded language acquisition has focused primarily on textual inputs. In this work, we demonstrate the feasibility of performing grounded language acquisition on paired visual percepts and raw speech inputs. This will allow interactions in which language about novel tasks and environments is learned from end-users, reducing dependence on textual inputs and potentially mitigating the effects of demographic bias found in widely available speech recognition systems. We leverage recent work in self-supervised speech representation models and show that learned representations of speech can make language grounding systems more inclusive towards specific groups while maintaining or even increasing general performance. 
    more » « less