skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Assessment of Models for Extracting Thermal Conductivity From Frequency Domain Thermoreflectance Experiments
Abstract The Fourier heat conduction and the hyperbolic heat conduction equations were solved numerically to simulate a frequency-domain thermoreflectance (FDTR) experimental setup. Numerical solutions enable use of realistic boundary conditions, such as convective cooling from the various surfaces of the substrate and transducer. The equations were solved in time domain and the phase lag between the temperature at the center of the transducer and the modulated pump laser signal were computed for a modulation frequency range of 200 kHz to 200 MHz. It was found that the numerical predictions fit the experimentally measured phase lag better than analytical frequency-domain solutions of the Fourier heat equation based on Hankel transforms. The effects of boundary conditions were investigated and it was found that if the substrate (computational domain) is sufficiently large, the far-field boundary conditions have no effect on the computed phase lag. The interface conductance between the transducer and the substrate was also treated as a parameter, and was found to have some effect on the predicted thermal conductivity, but only in certain regimes. The hyperbolic heat conduction equation yielded identical results as the Fourier heat conduction equation for the particular case studied. The thermal conductivity value (best fit) for the silicon substrate considered in this study was found to be 108 W/m/K, which is slightly different from previously reported values for the same experimental data.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2003747
PAR ID:
10355581
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Proceedings of the ASME Summer Heat Transfer Conference, SHTC2020
Page Range / eLocation ID:
HT2020-8920
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract The Fourier and the hyperbolic heat conduction equations were solved numerically to simulate a frequency-domain thermoreflectance (FDTR) experiment. Numerical solutions enable isolation of pump and probe laser spot size effects and use of realistic boundary conditions. The equations were solved in time domain and the phase lag between the temperature of the transducer (averaged over the probe laser spot) and the modulated pump laser signal was computed for a modulation frequency range of 200 kHz–200 MHz. Numerical calculations showed that extracted values of the thermal conductivity are sensitive to both the pump and probe laser spot sizes, while analytical solutions (based on Hankel transform) cannot isolate the two effects. However, for the same effective (combined) spot size, the two solutions are found to be in excellent agreement. If the substrate (computational domain) is sufficiently large, the far-field boundary conditions were found to have no effect on the computed phase lag. The interface conductance between the transducer and the substrate was found to have some effect on the extracted thermal conductivity. The hyperbolic heat conduction equation yielded almost the same results as the Fourier heat conduction equation for the particular case studied. The numerically extracted thermal conductivity value (best fit) for the silicon substrate considered in this study was found to be about 82–108 W/m/K, depending on the pump and probe laser spot sizes used. 
    more » « less
  2. The anisotropic Fourier Heat Conduction Equation (FHCE) and the multidimensional phonon Boltzmann Transport Equation (BTE) were solved numerically in cylindrical coordinates and in time domain to simulate a Time Domain Thermo-Reflectance (TDTR) experimental silicon/aluminum substrate/transducer setup. The out-of-phase response of the probe laser was predicted at various beam offset distances for a pump laser pulse frequency of 80 MHz and modulation frequency of 10 MHz and compared against experimental measurements for a silicon substrate. The isotropic FHCE was also solved for comparison. Results show that the isotropic FHCE with bulk thermal conductivity of 145 W/m/K significantly underpredicts the out-of-phase temperature difference, particularly at smaller beam offsets. With an isotropic thermal conductivity of 105 W/m/K, the computed results match experimental data at smaller beam offsets well, but overpredicts the experimental data at larger beam offsets. An almost-perfect match is obtained by using an anisotropic thermal conductivity wherein the radial (in-plane) thermal conductivity is set to 85 W/m/K and the axial (through-plane) conductivity is set to 130 W/m/K. The multidimensional frequency and polarization dependent phonon BTE is next solved. The BTE results for the out-of-phase temperature difference match experimental observations well at small and intermediate beam offsets, but overpredicts the experimental data at larger beam offsets. FHCE results are fitted to the BTE predictions, and the extracted (best fit) thermal conductivity is found to be 110 W/m/K. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract The Boltzmann Transport equation (BTE) was solved numerically in cylindrical coordinates and in time domain to simulate a Frequency Domain Thermo-Reflectance (FDTR) experiment. First, a parallel phonon BTE solver that accounts for all phonon modes, frequencies, and polarizations was developed and tested. The solver employs the finite-volume method (FVM) for discretization of physical space, and the finite-angle method (FAM) for discretization of angular space. The solution was advanced in time using explicit time marching. The simulations were carried out in time domain and band-based parallelization of the BTE solver was implemented. The phase lag between the temperature averaged over the probed region of the transducer and the modulated laser pump signal was extracted for a pump laser modulation frequency ranging from 20–200 MHz. It was found that with the relaxation time scales used in the present study, the computed phase lag is underpredicted when compared to experimental data, especially at smaller modulation frequencies. The challenges in solving the BTE for such applications are highlighted. 
    more » « less
  4. null (Ed.)
    In this paper, the authors propose a new dimension reduction method for level-set-based topology optimization of conforming thermal structures on free-form surfaces. Both the Hamilton-Jacobi equation and the Laplace equation, which are the two governing PDEs for boundary evolution and thermal conduction, are transformed from the 3D manifold to the 2D rectangular domain using conformal parameterization. The new method can significantly simplify the computation of topology optimization on a manifold without loss of accuracy. This is achieved due to the fact that the covariant derivatives on the manifold can be represented by the Euclidean gradient operators multiplied by a scalar with the conformal mapping. The original governing equations defined on the 3D manifold can now be properly modified and solved on a 2D domain. The objective function, constraint, and velocity field are also equivalently computed with the FEA on the 2D parameter domain with the properly modified form. In this sense, we are solving a 3D topology optimization problem equivalently on the 2D parameter domain. This reduction in dimension can greatly reduce the computing cost and complexity of the algorithm. The proposed concept is proved through two examples of heat conduction on manifolds. 
    more » « less
  5. This paper is on an Eulerian-Eulerian (EE) approach that utilizes Godunov’s scheme to deal with a running shock that interacts with a cloud of particles. The EE approach treats both carrier phase (fluid phase) and dispersed phase (particle phase) in the Eulerian frame. In this work, the fluid equations are the Euler equations for the compressible gas while the particle equations are based on a recently developed model to solve for the number density, velocity, temperature, particle sub-grid scale stresses, and particle sub-grid scale heat fluxes. The carrier and dispersed phases exchange momentum and heat, which are modeled through incorporating source terms in their equations. Carrier and dispersed phase equation form a hyperbolic set of differential equations, which are numerically solved with Godunov’s scheme. The numerical solutions are obtained in this work for a two-dimensional normal running shock interacting with a rectangular cloud of particles. The results generated by the EE approach were compared against the results that were generated by a well-stablished Eulerian-Lagragian (EL) approach that treats the carrier phase in an Eulerian frame, while does the dispersed phase in a Lagrangian framework where individuals particles are traced and solved. For the considered configuration, the EE approach reproduced the EL results with a very good accuracy. 
    more » « less