skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Towards Establishing Consistent Proposal Binning Methods for Unimodal and Multimodal Interaction Elicitation Studies
More than two hundred papers on elicitation studies have been published in the last ten years. These works are mainly focused on generating user-defined gesture sets and discovering natural feeling multimodal interaction techniques with virtual objects. Few papers have discussed binning the elicited interaction proposals after data collection. Binning is a process of grouping the entire set of user-generated interaction proposals based on similarity criteria. The binned set of proposals is then analyzed to produce a consensus set, which results in the user-defined interaction set. This paper presents a formula to use when deciding how to bin interaction proposals, thus helping to establish a more consistent binning procedure. This work can provide human-computer interaction (HCI) researchers with the guidance they need for interaction elicitation data processing, which is largely missing from current elicitation study literature. Using this approach will improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the binning process, increase the reliability of us er-defined interaction sets, and most importantly, improve the replicability of elicitation studies.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1948254
PAR ID:
10357472
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Editor(s):
The Open University of Japan, Chiba
Date Published:
Journal Name:
HCII: International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction
ISSN:
2442-8671
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Elicitation studies have become a popular method of participatory design. While traditionally used to examine unimodal gesture interactions, elicitation has started being used with other novel interaction modalities. Unfortunately, there has been no work that examines the impact of referent display on elicited interaction proposals. To address that concern this work provides a detailed comparison between two elicitation studies that were similar in design apart from the way that participants were prompted for interaction proposals (i.e., the referents). Based on this comparison the impact of referent display on speech and gesture interaction proposals are each discussed. The interaction proposals between these elicitation studies were not identical. Gesture proposals were the least impacted by referent display, showing high proposal similarity between the two works. Speech proposals were highly biased by text referents with proposals directly mirroring text-based referents an average of 69.36% of the time. In short, the way that referents are presented during elicitation studies can impact the resulting interaction proposals; however, the level of impact found is dependent on the modality of input elicited. 
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    Gesture elicitation studies are a popular means of gaining valuable insights into how users interact with novel input devices. One of the problems elicitation faces is that of legacy bias, when elicited interactions are biased by prior technologies use. In response, methodologies have been introduced to reduce legacy bias. This is the first study that formally examines the production method of reducing legacy bias (i.e., repeated proposals for a single referent). This is done through a between-subject study that had 27 participants per group (control and production) with 17 referents placed in a virtual environment using a head-mounted display. This study found that over a range of referents, legacy bias was not significantly reduced over production trials. Instead, production reduced participant consensus on proposals. However, in the set of referents that elicited the most legacy biased proposals, production was an effective means of reducing legacy bias, with an overall reduction of 11.93% for the chance of eliciting a legacy bias proposal. 
    more » « less
  3. Cussens, James; Zhang, Kun (Ed.)
    Metric elicitation is a recent framework for eliciting classification performance metrics that best reflect implicit user preferences based on the task and context. However, available elicitation strategies have been limited to linear (or quasi-linear) functions of predictive rates, which can be practically restrictive for many applications including fairness. This paper develops a strategy for eliciting more flexible multiclass metrics defined by quadratic functions of rates, designed to reflect human preferences better. We show its application in eliciting quadratic violation-based group-fair metrics. Our strategy requires only relative preference feedback, is robust to noise, and achieves near-optimal query complexity. We further extend this strategy to eliciting polynomial metrics – thus broadening the use cases for metric elicitation. 
    more » « less
  4. null (Ed.)
    Across a wide variety of domains, artificial agents that can adapt and personalize to users have potential to improve and transform how social services are provided. Because of the need for personalized interaction data to drive this process, long-term (or longitudinal) interactions between users and agents, which unfold over a series of distinct interaction sessions, have attracted substantial research interest. In recognition of the expanded scope and structure of a long-term interaction, researchers are also adjusting the personalization models and algorithms used, orienting toward “continual learning” methods, which do not assume a stationary modeling target and explicitly account for the temporal context of training data. In parallel, researchers have also studied the effect of “multitask personalization,” an approach in which an agent interacts with users over multiple different tasks contexts throughout the course of a long-term interaction and learns personalized models of a user that are transferrable across these tasks. In this paper, we unite these two paradigms under the framework of “Lifelong Personalization,” analyzing the effect of multitask personalization applied to dynamic, non-stationary targets. We extend the multi-task personalization approach to the more complex and realistic scenario of modeling dynamic learners over time, focusing in particular on interactive scenarios in which the modeling agent plays an active role in teaching the student whose knowledge the agent is simultaneously attempting to model. Inspired by the way in which agents use active learning to select new training data based on domain context, we augment a Gaussian Process-based multitask personalization model with a mechanism to actively and continually manage its own training data, allowing a modeling agent to remove or reduce the weight of observed data from its training set, based on interactive context cues. We evaluate this method in a series of simulation experiments comparing different approaches to continual and multitask learning on simulated student data. We expect this method to substantially improve learning in Gaussian Process models in dynamic domains, establishing Gaussian Processes as another flexible modeling tool for Long-term Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) Studies. 
    more » « less
  5. SUMMARY Repeatedly recording seismic data over a period of months or years is one way to identify trapped oil and gas and to monitor CO2 injection in underground storage reservoirs and saline aquifers. This process of recording data over time and then differencing the images assumes the recording of the data over a particular subsurface region is repeatable. In other words, the hope is that one can recover changes in the Earth when the survey parameters are held fixed between data collection times. Unfortunately, perfect experimental repeatability almost never occurs. Acquisition inconsistencies such as changes in weather (currents, wind) for marine seismic data are inevitable, resulting in source and receiver location differences between surveys at the very least. Thus, data processing aimed at improving repeatability between baseline and monitor surveys is extremely useful. One such processing tool is regularization (or binning) that aligns multiple surveys with different source or receiver configurations onto a common grid. Data binned onto a regular grid can be stored in a high-dimensional data structure called a tensor with, for example, x and y receiver coordinates and time as indices of the tensor. Such a higher-order data structure describing a subsection of the Earth often exhibits redundancies which one can exploit to fill in gaps caused by sampling the surveys onto the common grid. In fact, since data gaps and noise increase the rank of the tensor, seeking to recover the original data by reducing the rank (low-rank tensor-based completion) successfully fills in gaps caused by binning. The tensor nuclear norm (TNN) is defined by the tensor singular value decomposition (tSVD) which generalizes the matrix SVD. In this work we complete missing time-lapse data caused by binning using the alternating direction method of multipliers (or ADMM) to minimize the TNN. For a synthetic experiment with three parabolic events in which the time-lapse difference involves an amplitude increase in one of these events between baseline and monitor data sets, the binning and reconstruction algorithm (TNN-ADMM) correctly recovers this time-lapse change. We also apply this workflow of binning and TNN-ADMM reconstruction to a real marine survey from offshore Western Australia in which the binning onto a regular grid results in significant data gaps. The data after reconstruction varies continuously without the large gaps caused by the binning process. 
    more » « less