An official website of the United States government
Firebrand attack has been shown to be one of the key mechanisms of wildfire spread into Wildland-Urban Interface (WUI) communities. The ignition propensity of materials caused by firebrands depends on not only the attributes (e.g., shape, size, numbers) but also the distribution of firebrands after landing on the substrate materials. To help characterize this process, this study aims to first investigate the effects of gap spacing on the burning behaviors of a group of wooden samples. Experiments were conducted using 9 wooden cubes, 19mm-long on each side. These samples were arranged in a 3 by 3 square pattern on suspension wires. The gap spacing (s) between the cube samples varies from 0 to 30 mm. Burning process was recorded using video cameras. Sample mass loss and temperatures were monitored during the flaming and smoldering processes. The results show that when s ≤ 10 mm, flames from individual samples merged. When the gap spacing reduces, the mass loss rate first increases but starts decreasing at s = 10 mm where flame merging occurs. The flame height has a similar non-monotonic dependency on the gap spacing and the maximum flame height occurs at s = 5 mm. Compared to the case with s = 10 mm, cases with a smaller gap spacing (s = 2.5 and 5 mm) have a larger flame height but a smaller sample mass loss rate. This indicates that a reduced air entrainment leads to an increase in the flame height despite of a decreased flame heat feedback to the solid samples. The heating rates of each sample were also calculated to investigate the local burning behaviors. The analysis showed a weaker flame heat feedback to the sample at the center for cases with under-ventilated combustion. Last, gaseous flame height was corelated to the solid burning rate. The correlation was also compared with previous empirical equations concerning liquid pool fires of different heat release rates.
more »
« less
Effects of spacing on flaming and smoldering firebrands in wildland–urban interface fires
Firebrand (ember) attack has been shown to be one of the key mechanisms of wildfire spread into wildland–urban interface communities. After the firebrands land on a substrate material, the ignition propensity of the material depends on not only the attributes (e.g. shape, size, and numbers) but also the distribution of the firebrands. To help characterize this process, this study aims to investigate the effects of gap spacing on the burning behaviors of a group of wooden samples. Experiments are conducted using nine wooden cubes, 19 mm on each side. These samples are arranged in a 3 × 3 square pattern on suspension wires and are ignited by hot coils from the bottom surface. The gap spacing (s) between the samples varies in each test (ranging from 0 to 30 mm). After ignition, the samples are left to burn to completion. The burning process is recorded using video cameras. Sample mass loss and temperatures are monitored during the flaming and smoldering processes. The results show that the flame height and the sample mass loss rate have non-monotonic dependencies on the gap spacing. When the gap spacing reduces, the flame height and the mass loss rate first increase due to enhanced heat input from the adjacent flames to each sample. When s ≤ 10 mm, flames from individual samples are observed to merge into a single large fire. As s further decreases, the air entrainment at the flame bottom decreases and the flame lift-off distance at the flame center increases, resulting in an increased flame height, decreased flame heat feedback to the solid samples, and a decreased mass loss rate. The decreased mass loss rate eventually leads to a decrease in the flame height as well. The gaseous flame height is correlated to the solid burning rate. The correlation generally follows previous empirical equations for continuous fire sources. For the smoldering combustion, compared to a single burning sample, the smoldering temperature and duration significantly increase due to the thermal interactions between adjacent burning samples. To help interpret the results of the burning experiments, thermogravimetric analysis is also performed in air and nitrogen, resulting in heating rates ranging from 10 to 100 K/min.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1836428
- PAR ID:
- 10366714
- Publisher / Repository:
- SAGE Publications
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Fire Sciences
- Volume:
- 40
- Issue:
- 3
- ISSN:
- 0734-9041
- Format(s):
- Medium: X Size: p. 155-174
- Size(s):
- p. 155-174
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Firebrands are known to be able to ignite not only vegetation but also various structures found in wildland-urban interface (WUI) area. Especially, firebrands located close to each other on a combustible substrate increase the likelihood of ignition and the subsequent fire. To elucidate the ignition mechanism of firebrands, experiments are performed using a 3 by 3 square array of flaming firebrands deposited on a 6.35 mm thick birch plywood. The spacing of the firebrand is varied in each experiment, ranging from 10 to 30 mm. The deposited mass of firebrands lies between 13 and 15 g. Ambient wind is imposed parallel to the plywood surface to investigate its effect on the ignition and the subsequent flame spread over the fuel. Three different wind speeds 0, 0.5, and 0.75 m/s are tested. During the experiments, mass loss of the plywood and the deposited firebrands is recorded. Video cameras are used to monitor the burning process. An infrared camera is also used to monitor the temperature of the firebrands and the plywood. The experiment results indicate that the firebrands with the spacing greater than 20 mm are able to burn only the surface of the plywood until the firebrands burn out. When the spacing between firebrands is smaller than 20 mm, the plywood is ignited and continues to burn even after the firebrands are fully consumed. It is also observed that the flame is able to spread downstream at 10 mm spacing under ambient wind speed of 0.5 m/s. Results from this study demonstrate the significant influence of spacing between the firebrands on the ignition and the burning behavior of the substrate materials.more » « less
-
There are no existing experimental studies of flame spread rate trends for ultra-thin solid samples. Previous theory has predicted that for concurrent flame in kinetic regime, the flame spread rate decreases as the sample thickness decreases and there is a critical thickness below which burning is not possible. To test this hypothesis, a series of microgravity experiments of concurrent-flow flame spread over samples of ultra-low area densities are conducted using NASA Glenn Research Center’s Zero Gravity Research Facility (the 5.18 s drop tower). The tested samples are cellulose-based materials of various area densities, ranging from 0.2 mg/cm2 to 13 mg/cm2, as low as one order of magnitude less than those ever tested before. Each sample is 30 cm long by 5 cm wide and is burned in a low-speed concurrent air flow (5 to 30 cm/s). The results show that the concurrent flame spread rate is proportional to the flow velocity relative to the flame and is inversely proportional to the sample area density. A theoretical formulation, provided in this work, suggests that the flame length has a linear relationship with the relative flow speed and has no direct dependency on the sample area density. The experimental data supports this conclusion. From the images recorded in the experiments, a unique flame base tubular structure directed upstream away from the burnout zone is observed for thin samples. This structure is suspected to be due to flame stretching and localized blowoff caused by the oxidative pyrolysis Stefan flows at the sample burnout. This can be an indication that the chemical time becomes comparable to the flow time of the Stefan flow and the tested samples are approaching the kinetically-limited thickness. For the thinnest tested sample (0.2 mg/cm2), flames with concurrent and opposed dual natures are observed when the air flow rate is low (< 20 cm/s). At the lowest tested flow rate (5 cm/s), the flame spread rate exceeds the air flow rate and the flame transits to an opposed flame in the concurrent flow. The dual nature and flame transition are presented and discussed. This study provides detailed examination through high-resolution images of the transition between the concurrent to opposed flame spread modes.more » « less
-
The burning of nine, one-meter tall chamise shrubs with a maximum shrub diameter of 0.7 m, placed in a 3×3 horizontal array arrangement was simulated using WFDS (Mell et al. 2009). All shrubs were simultaneously ignited from their bases by individual ignition zones located on the ground beneath the shrubs. Several simulations were performed by varying the shrub separation distance from zero to the maximum shrub diameter. The burning characteristics of the shrubs were examined for the conditions of no wind and a wind speed of 1 m/s. For the no wind condition, the peak mass loss rate of the shrub situated at the center of the array was found to be significantly higher than the rest of the shrubs. This finding indicated the heat feedback enhancement to be dominant and thereby caused the center shrub to burn intensely and exhibit fire merging. On the other hand, in the presence of wind, the shrub positioned in the middle of the array edge in the downstream direction exhibited the highest peak mass loss rate. This behavior was attributed to the tilting of flames in the downstream direction influenced by wind and thereby enhancing the heat feedback from the flames of the upstream shrubs. For a separation distance equal to the maximum shrub diameter, the effect of heat feedback was significantly reduced and the shrubs exhibited a burning behavior akin to that of an isolated, single shrub.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)A numerical study is pursued to investigate the aerodynamics and thermal interactions between a spreading flame and the surrounding walls as well as their effects on fire behaviors. This is done in support of upcoming microgravity experiments aboard the International Space Station. For the numerical study, a three-dimensional transient Computational Fluid Dynamics combustion model is used to simulate concurrent-flow flame spread over a thin solid sample in a narrow flow duct. The height of the flow duct is the main parameter. The numerical results predict a quenching height for the flow duct below which the flame fails to spread. For duct heights sufficiently larger than the quenching height, the flame reaches a steady spreading state before the sample is fully consumed. The flame spread rate and the pyrolysis length at steady state first increase and then decrease when the flow duct height decreases. The detailed gas and solid profiles show that flow confinement has competing effects on the flame spread process. On one hand, it accelerates flow during thermal expansion from combustion, intensifying the flame. On the other hand, increasing flow confinement reduces the oxygen supply to the flame and increases conductive heat loss to the walls, both of which weaken the flame. These competing effects result in the aforementioned non-monotonic trend of flame spread rate as duct height varies. This work relates to upcoming microgravity experiments, in which flat thin samples will be burned in a low-speed concurrent flow using a small flow duct aboard the International Space Station. Two baffles will be installed parallel to the fuel sample (one on each side of the sample) to create an effective reduction in the height of the flow duct. The concept and setup of the experiments are presented in this work.more » « less
