An official website of the United States government
Abstract Previous studies found conflicting results on the importance of temperature and precipitation versus geochemical variables for predicting soil organic carbon (SOC) concentrations and trends with depth, and most utilized linear statistical models. To reconcile the controversy, we used data from 2574 mineral horizons from 675 pits from National Ecological Observatory Network sites across North America, typically collected to 1 m depth. Climate was a fundamental predictor of SOC and played similarly important roles as some geochemical predictors. Yet, this only emerged in the generalized additive mixed model and random forest model and was obscured in the linear mixed model. Relationships between water availability and SOC were strongest in very dry ecosystems and SOC increased most strongly at mean annual temperature < 0°C. In all models, depth, oxalate‐extractable Al (Alox), pH, and exchangeable calcium plus exchangeable magnesium were important while silt + clay, oxalate‐extractable Fe (Feox), and vegetation type were weaker predictors. Climate and pH were independently related to SOC and also interacted with geochemical composition: Feoxand Aloxrelated more strongly to SOC in wet or cold climates. Most predictors had nonlinear threshold relationships with SOC, and a saturating response to increasing reactive metals indicates soils where SOC might be limited by C inputs. We observed a mostly constant relative importance of geochemical and climate predictors of SOC with increasing depth, challenging previous statements. Overall, our findings challenge the notion that climate is redundant after accounting for geochemistry and demonstrate that considering their nonlinearities and interactions improves spatial predictions of SOC.
more »
« less
What do relationships between extractable metals and soil organic carbon concentrations mean?
Abstract Aluminum (Al)‐bearing and iron (Fe)‐bearing minerals, especially short‐range‐ordered (SRO) phases, are thought to protect soil organic C (SOC). However, it remains methodologically challenging to assess the influence of Al vs. Fe minerals or metal complexes. Whereas SRO Al and Fe phases share some properties, Al dissolved by oxalate (Alox) often correlates stronger with SOC than Fe dissolved by oxalate (Feox) or citrate–dithionite (Fecd). To further evaluate these relationships, we analyzed a large North American soil dataset from the National Ecological Observatory Network. A strong relationship between Aloxand SOC (and weaker Feox‐SOC relationship) persisted even after excluding soils rich in SRO minerals (Andisols and Spodosols). Al dissolved by oxalate was strongly correlated with citrate–dithionite‐extractable Al (Alcd; slope = 0.92,R2 = .69), and discrepancies could be explained (R2 = .87) by greater dissolution of Al‐substituted Fe phases by citrate–dithionite and greater dissolution of aluminosilicates by oxalate. Aluminum dissolved by oxalate and Alcdwere both strong SOC predictors despite their differing relationships with silicon (Si). Al dissolved by oxalate and Sioxstrongly covaried (R2 = .79), but Alcdwas inconsistently related to Sicd(R2 = .18). Similar relationships of Aloxand Alcdwith SOC, despite differences in minerals extracted by oxalate and citrate–dithionite, suggest that Al‐OC complexes (as opposed to aluminosilicate or iron‐bearing minerals) were the best SOC predictor. This raises important questions: do Al‐OC complexes indicate protection from decomposition or simply reflect greater intensity of mineral weathering by organic acids; and, if the latter, then perhaps SOC input is driving Aloxand SOC correlations rather than Al phase composition or abundance.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1802745
- PAR ID:
- 10366855
- Publisher / Repository:
- Wiley Blackwell (John Wiley & Sons)
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Soil Science Society of America Journal
- Volume:
- 86
- Issue:
- 2
- ISSN:
- 0361-5995
- Format(s):
- Medium: X Size: p. 195-208
- Size(s):
- p. 195-208
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Radiocarbon time series of archived litter and soil samples from Bear Brook (west of watershed 6) at lower elevation from 1998 to 2023. Additional measurements include total carbon and nitrogen for all samples, and selective dissolution metal concentrations for the Oa/A and mineral soil layers. Selective dissolution metals include pyrophosphate-extractable aluminum (Al); iron (Fe), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), and manganese (Mn); oxalate-extractable Al, Fe, Ca, Mg, and Mn; and dithionite-extractable Al, Fe, Ca, Mg, and Mn. All samples are from the Microbial Biomass and Activity Sampling Effort (Groffman and Martel, 2025, https://doi.org/10.6073/pasta/aff4a2074fd56102f62f13a19ce46f2d). These data were gathered as part of the Hubbard Brook Ecosystem Study (HBES). The HBES is a collaborative effort at the Hubbard Brook Experimental Forest, which is operated and maintained by the US Forest Service, Northern Research Station.more » « less
-
Abstract Understanding hydrogen dissolution mechanisms in bridgmanite (Bgm), the most abundant mineral in the lower mantle, is essential for understanding water storage and rheological and transport properties in the region. However, interpretations of O‐H bands in Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) spectra of Bgm crystals remain uncertain. We conducted density functional theory (DFT) calculations on vibrational characteristics of O‐H dipoles and performed polarized FTIR measurements to address this issue. DFT calculations for four substitution models—Mg vacancies, Si vacancies, Al3+ + H+substitution for Si4+, and Al substitution with Mg vacancies—reveal distinct O‐H bands with different polarizations. Deconvolution of polarized FTIR spectra on Mg0.88Fe2+0.035Fe3+0.065Al0.14Si0.90O3and Mg0.95Fe2+0.033Fe3+0.027Al0.04Si0.96O3crystals shows five major O‐H bands with distinct polarizations along principal crystallographic axes. These experimental and calculated results attribute O‐H bands centered at 3,463–3,480, 2,913–2,924, and 2,452–2,470 cm−1to Mg vacancies, Si vacancies, and Al3+ + H+substitution for Si4+, respectively. The total absorbance coefficient of bridgmanite was calculated to be 82,702(6,217) L/mol/cm2. Mg and Si vacancies account for 43%–74% of the total water content, making them dominant hydrogen dissolution mechanisms in Bgm. The band frequencies for the Mg and Si vacancies in Bgm are drastically different from those in olivine and ringwoodite, corresponding to the significant changes in O‐H bond strengths and in the Si and Mg coordination environments from upper‐mantle to lower‐mantle minerals. These results highlight the need to incorporate hydrogen dissolution mechanisms in Bgm for understanding electrical conductivity and rheology of the lower mantle.more » « less
-
Abstract Al(OC(CF3)3)(PhF) reacts with silanols present on partially dehydroxylated silica to form well‐defined ≡SiOAl(OC(CF3)3)2(O(Si≡)2) (1).27Al NMR and DFT calculations with a small cluster model to approximate the silica surface show that the aluminum in1adopts a distorted trigonal bipyramidal coordination geometry by coordinating to a nearby siloxane bridge and a fluorine from the alkoxide. Fluoride ion affinity (FIA) calculations follow experimental trends and show that1is a stronger Lewis acid than B(C6F5)3and Al(OC(CF3)3)(PhF) but is weaker than Al(OC(CF3)3) andiPr3Si+. Cp2Zr(CH3)2reacts with1to form [Cp2ZrCH3][≡SiOAl(OC(CF3)3)2(CH3)] (3) by methide abstraction. This reactivity pattern is similar to reactions of organometallics with the proposed strong Lewis acid sites present on Al2O3.more » « less
-
Abstract The transport of hydrogen into Earth's deep interior may have an impact on lower mantle dynamics as well as on the seismic signature of subducted material. Due to the stability of the hydrous phasesδ‐AlOOH (delta phase), MgSiO2(OH)2(phase H), andε‐FeOOH at high temperatures and pressures, their solid solutions may transport significant amounts of hydrogen as deep as the core‐mantle boundary. We have constrained the equation of state, including the effects of a spin crossover in the Fe3+atoms, of (Al, Fe)‐phase H: Al0.84Fe3+0.07Mg0.02Si0.06OOH, using powder X‐ray diffraction measurements to 125 GPa, supported by synchrotron Mössbauer spectroscopy measurements on (Al, Fe)‐phase H andδ‐(Al, Fe)OOH. The changes in spin state of Fe3+in (Al, Fe)‐phase H results in a significant decrease in bulk sound velocity and occurs over a different pressure range (48–62 GPa) compared withδ‐(Al, Fe)OOH (32–40 GPa). Changes in axial compressibilities indicate a decrease in the compressibility of hydrogen bonds in (Al, Fe)‐phase H near 30 GPa, which may be associated with hydrogen bond symmetrization. The formation of (Al, Fe)‐phase H in subducted oceanic crust may contribute to scattering of seismic waves in the mid‐lower mantle (∼1,100–1,550 km). Accumulation of 1–4 wt.% (Al, Fe)‐phase H could reproduce some of the seismic signatures of large, low seismic‐velocity provinces. Our results suggest that changes in the electronic structure of phases in the (δ‐AlOOH)‐(MgSiO2(OH)2)‐(ε‐FeOOH) solid solution are sensitive to composition and that the presence of these phases in subducted oceanic crust could be seismically detectable throughout the lower mantle.more » « less
