Title: Understory plant communities show resistance to drought, hurricanes, and experimental warming in a wet tropical forest
Global climate change has led to rising temperatures and to more frequent and intense climatic events, such as storms and droughts. Changes in climate and disturbance regimes can have non-additive effects on plant communities and result in complicated legacies we have yet to understand. This is especially true for tropical forests, which play a significant role in regulating global climate. We used understory vegetation data from the Tropical Responses to Altered Climate Experiment (TRACE) in Puerto Rico to evaluate how plant communities responded to climate warming and disturbance. The TRACE understory vegetation was exposed to a severe drought (2015), 2 years of experimental warming (4°C above ambient in half of the plots, 2016–2017 and 2018–2019), and two major hurricanes (Irma and María, September 2017). Woody seedlings and saplings were censused yearly from 2015 to 2019, with an additional census in 2015 after the drought ended. We evaluated disturbance-driven changes in species richness, diversity, and composition across ontogeny. We then used Bayesian predictive trait modeling to assess how species responded to disturbance and how this might influence the functional structure of the plant community. Our results show decreased seedling richness after hurricane disturbance, as well as increased sapling richness and diversity after warming. We found a shift in species composition through time for both seedlings and saplings, yet the individual effects of each disturbance were not significant. At both ontogenetic stages, we observed about twice as many species responding to experimental warming as those responding to drought and hurricanes. Predicted changes in functional structure point to disturbance-driven functional shifts toward a mixture of fast-growing and drought-tolerant species. Our findings demonstrate that the tropical forest understory community is more resistant to climatic stressors than expected, especially at the sapling stage. However, early signs of changes in species composition suggest that, in a warming climate with frequent droughts and hurricanes, plant communities might shift over time toward fast-growing or drought-tolerant species.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2120085 1754713
PAR ID:
10383451
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Frontiers in Forests and Global Change
Volume:
5
ISSN:
2624-893X
Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract Disturbances play a central role in shaping biodiversity, influencing both community structure and ecosystem function. The responses of biodiversity to disturbance are inherently multidimensional, often leading to shifts in taxonomic composition, functional traits, and evolutionary dynamics within biological communities. Unraveling these dimensions offers valuable insights into ecosystem resilience and how communities adapt under changing disturbance regimes. This study examines the immediate effects of large‐scale hurricane disturbance on the taxonomic, phylogenetic, and functional dimensions of moth biodiversity in a tropical forest. We conducted monthly moth surveys in two forest types within the Luquillo Mountains of Puerto Rico, 5 months before and 6 months after Hurricanes Irma and María (September 2017). We collected 6152 individuals from 244 species across 19 families, performed DNA barcoding for phylogenetic analysis, and classified them by functional traits such as body size, coloration, and proboscis presence. Our findings show that hurricane disturbance reduced species richness across all diversity dimensions, while functional diversity among dominant species increased, suggesting potential stabilization of ecosystem functions despite reduced richness. In addition, the hurricanes altered both taxonomic and phylogenetic composition, with smaller grass‐feeding species increasing in abundance post‐hurricane, while larger arboreal‐feeding species, especially geometrid moths, declined markedly. These shifts highlight potential effects on trophic interactions, given moths' key roles as herbivores, pollinators, and prey. Although these systems have evolved under repeated hurricane disturbances, the long‐term consequences of a changing climate remain uncertain, particularly as more frequent and severe hurricanes may reset successional pathways and hinder forest recovery. By integrating multiple dimensions of biodiversity, our study provides a more holistic understanding of the complex consequences of hurricanes on insect communities and can inform conservation strategies aimed at enhancing ecosystem resilience. 
    more » « less
  2. The future of tropical forests depends on their ability to resist and recover from multiple disturbances. Here, we evaluated how edge effects, experimental fires, extreme droughts, and blowdowns reshaped forest structure, composition, and functional traits over two decades in the Amazon–Cerrado transition. Initially, forests resisted low-intensity fires, but subsequent high-intensity fires during severe droughts sharply increased susceptibility to further disturbances. Along forest edges bordering agriculture, these compound disturbances drove losses of tree species richness, declines in Amazonian forest-specialist species, and shifts toward generalists with broad distributions, indicating increased compositional homogenization (i.e., reduced taxonomic diversity and dominance of generalist species). Once fires ceased, recovery trajectories diverged: Interior forests rapidly regained woody species richness and composition, whereas edge forests recovered more slowly. During postfire recovery, embolism-resistant species (lower P50 values) became more common, yet communities exhibited lower hydraulic safety margins (increased vulnerability to drought). At the same time, generalist species remained abundant, forest-specialist declined, and only a single woody species typical of savanna was established. Although grasses initially colonized fire-altered edges—especially light-demanding exoticAndropogon gayanus—they declined once fires stopped, leaving only small patches of shade-tolerant C3 species. Consequently, we find little evidence that fire-degraded forests transition toward persistent savanna, although recurrent fires or future climatic changes could drive long-lasting degradation or human-derived savannas. Together, these results show that even highly degraded, grass-invaded forests can recover in the absence of new disturbances, but the communities that reassemble remain vulnerable to renewed fire, drought, or windthrow. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract Droughts are predicted to become more frequent and intense in many tropical regions, which may cause shifts in plant community composition. Especially in diverse tropical communities, understanding how traits mediate demographic responses to drought can help provide insight into the effects of climate change on these ecosystems. To understand tropical tree responses to reduced soil moisture, we grew seedlings of eight species across an experimental soil moisture gradient at the Luquillo Experimental Forest, Puerto Rico. We quantified survival and growth over an 8‐month period and characterized demographic responses in terms of tolerance to low soil moisture—defined as survival and growth rates under low soil moisture conditions—and sensitivity to variation in soil moisture—defined as more pronounced changes in demographic rates across the observed range of soil moisture. We then compared demographic responses with interspecific variation in a suite of 11 (root, stem, and leaf) functional traits, measured on individuals that survived the experiment. Lower soil moisture was associated with reduced survival and growth but traits mediated species‐specific responses. Species with relatively conservative traits (e.g., high leaf mass per area), had higher survival at low soil moisture whereas species with more extensive root systems were more sensitive to soil moisture, in that they exhibited more pronounced changes in growth across the experimental soil moisture gradient. Our results suggest that increasing drought will favor species with more conservative traits that confer greater survival in low soil moisture conditions. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract The Arctic is warming four times faster than the global average1and plant communities are responding through shifts in species abundance, composition and distribution2–4. However, the direction and magnitude of local changes in plant diversity in the Arctic have not been quantified. Using a compilation of 42,234 records of 490 vascular plant species from 2,174 plots across the Arctic, here we quantified temporal changes in species richness and composition through repeat surveys between 1981 and 2022. We also identified the geographical, climatic and biotic drivers behind these changes. We found greater species richness at lower latitudes and warmer sites, but no indication that, on average, species richness had changed directionally over time. However, species turnover was widespread, with 59% of plots gaining and/or losing species. Proportions of species gains and losses were greater where temperatures had increased the most. Shrub expansion, particularly of erect shrubs, was associated with greater species losses and decreasing species richness. Despite changes in plant composition, Arctic plant communities did not become more similar to each other, suggesting no biotic homogenization so far. Overall, Arctic plant communities changed in richness and composition in different directions, with temperature and plant–plant interactions emerging as the main drivers of change. Our findings demonstrate how climate and biotic drivers can act in concert to alter plant composition, which could precede future biodiversity changes that are likely to affect ecosystem function, wildlife habitats and the livelihoods of Arctic peoples5,6. 
    more » « less
  5. Within a forest, differences in landform spatial variation (i.e., geomorphic settings: valley, slope, and ridge) could affect the species richness and distribution present at a particular site. Previous studies have confirmed that plant species richness and biomass changes after a hurricane and such values can vary among geomorphic settings. Understory vegetation, including ferns, herbs, climbers, graminoids, and shrubs, accounts for more than two thirds of flora in tropical ecosystems, but there is limited information of the effect of hurricanes on these communities. We evaluated the structure and composition of understory vegetation in a post-hurricane forest in relation to geomorphic settings. This study was conducted in El Verde Research Area in the Luquillo Experimental Forest, Puerto Rico. We established 1-m2 plots within three geomorphic settings: riparian valley, slope, and ridge. Within each plot we identified species, estimated percent of cover, and collected biomass samples. Additionally, we estimated species accumulation curves and analyzed species composition among geomorphic settings using multivariate ordination. The relative species abundance of vegetation life-forms was similar among geomorphic settings, but graminoids and climbers exhibited differences in species composition. Higher forest understory biomass and percent vegetation cover was observed at this immediate post-hurricane period than what was reported pre-hurricane. The understory of valley areas had a more distinct species composition than what was observed among ridge and slope areas. The understory vegetation patterns observed would need to be followed through time and among the landforms to confirm the hurricane disturbances effects at these understory scale. 
    more » « less