An official website of the United States government
Abstract In recent work, we provide computational arguments for expanding the class of proper cones recognized by conic optimization solvers, to permit simpler, smaller, more natural conic formulations. We define an exotic cone as a proper cone for which we can implement a small set of tractable (i.e. fast, numerically stable, analytic) oracles for a logarithmically homogeneous self-concordant barrier for the cone or for its dual cone. Our extensible, open-source conic interior point solver, Hypatia, allows modeling and solving any conic problem over a Cartesian product of exotic cones. In this paper, we introduce Hypatia’s interior point algorithm, which generalizes that of Skajaa and Ye (Math. Program. 150(2):391–422, 2015) by handling exotic cones without tractable primal oracles. To improve iteration count and solve time in practice, we propose four enhancements to the interior point stepping procedure of Skajaa and Ye: (1) loosening the central path proximity conditions, (2) adjusting the directions using a third order directional derivative barrier oracle, (3) performing a backtracking search on a curve, and (4) combining the prediction and centering directions. We implement 23 useful exotic cones in Hypatia. We summarize the complexity of computing oracles for these cones and show that our new third order oracle is not a bottleneck. From 37 applied examples, we generate a diverse benchmark set of 379 problems. Our computational testing shows that each stepping enhancement improves Hypatia’s iteration count and solve time. Altogether, the enhancements reduce the geometric means of iteration count and solve time by over 80% and 70% respectively.
more »
« less
Solving Natural Conic Formulations with Hypatia.jl
Many convex optimization problems can be represented through conic extended formulations (EFs) using only the small number of standard cones recognized by advanced conic solvers such as MOSEK 9. However, EFs are often significantly larger and more complex than equivalent conic natural formulations (NFs) represented using the much broader class of exotic cones. We define an exotic cone as a proper cone for which we can implement easily computable logarithmically homogeneous self-concordant barrier oracles for either the cone or its dual cone. Our goal is to establish whether a generic conic interior point solver supporting NFs can outperform an advanced conic solver specialized for EFs across a variety of applied problems. We introduce Hypatia, a highly configurable open-source conic primal-dual interior point solver written in Julia and accessible through JuMP. Hypatia has a generic interface for exotic cones, some of which we define here. For seven applied problems, we introduce NFs using these cones and construct EFs that are necessarily larger and more complex. Our computational experiments demonstrate the advantages, especially in terms of solve time and memory usage, of solving the NFs with Hypatia compared with solving the EFs with either Hypatia or MOSEK 9.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1835443
- PAR ID:
- 10387772
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- INFORMS Journal on Computing
- Volume:
- 34
- Issue:
- 5
- ISSN:
- 1091-9856
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 2686 to 2699
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Spectral functions on Euclidean Jordan algebras arise frequently in convex optimization models. Despite the success of primal-dual conic interior point solvers, there has been little work on enabling direct support for spectral cones, that is, proper nonsymmetric cones defined from epigraphs and perspectives of spectral functions. We propose simple logarithmically homogeneous barriers for spectral cones and we derive efficient, numerically stable procedures for evaluating barrier oracles such as inverse Hessian operators. For two useful classes of spectral cones—the root-determinant cones and the matrix monotone derivative cones—we show that the barriers are self-concordant, with nearly optimal parameters. We implement these cones and oracles in our open-source solver Hypatia, and we write simple, natural formulations for four applied problems. Our computational benchmarks demonstrate that Hypatia often solves the natural formulations more efficiently than advanced solvers such as MOSEK 9 solve equivalent extended formulations written using only the cones these solvers support. Funding: This work was supported by Office of Naval Research [Grant N00014-18-1-2079] and the National Science Foundation [Grant OAC-1835443].more » « less
-
We present alfonso, an open-source Matlab package for solving conic optimization problems over nonsymmetric convex cones. The implementation is based on the authors’ corrected analysis of a method of Skajaa and Ye. It enables optimization over any convex cone as long as a logarithmically homogeneous self-concordant barrier is available for the cone or its dual. This includes many nonsymmetric cones, for example, hyperbolicity cones and their duals (such as sum-of-squares cones), semidefinite and second-order cone representable cones, power cones, and the exponential cone. Besides enabling the solution of problems that cannot be cast as optimization problems over a symmetric cone, algorithms for nonsymmetric conic optimization also offer performance advantages for problems whose symmetric cone programming representation requires a large number of auxiliary variables or has a special structure that can be exploited in the barrier computation. The worst-case iteration complexity of alfonso is the best known for nonsymmetric cone optimization: [Formula: see text] iterations to reach an ε-optimal solution, where ν is the barrier parameter of the barrier function used in the optimization. Alfonso can be interfaced with a Matlab function (supplied by the user) that computes the Hessian of a barrier function for the cone. A simplified interface is also available to optimize over the direct product of cones for which a barrier function has already been built into the software. This interface can be easily extended to include new cones. Both interfaces are illustrated by solving linear programs. The oracle interface and the efficiency of alfonso are also demonstrated using an optimal design of experiments problem in which the tailored barrier computation greatly decreases the solution time compared with using state-of-the-art, off-the-shelf conic optimization software. Summary of Contribution: The paper describes an open-source Matlab package for optimization over nonsymmetric cones. A particularly important feature of this software is that, unlike other conic optimization software, it enables optimization over any convex cone as long as a suitable barrier function is available for the cone or its dual, not limiting the user to a small number of specific cones. Nonsymmetric cones for which such barriers are already known include, for example, hyperbolicity cones and their duals (such as sum-of-squares cones), semidefinite and second-order cone representable cones, power cones, and the exponential cone. Thus, the scope of this software is far larger than most current conic optimization software. This does not come at the price of efficiency, as the worst-case iteration complexity of our algorithm matches the iteration complexity of the most successful interior-point methods for symmetric cones. Besides enabling the solution of problems that cannot be cast as optimization problems over a symmetric cone, our software can also offer performance advantages for problems whose symmetric cone programming representation requires a large number of auxiliary variables or has a special structure that can be exploited in the barrier computation. This is also demonstrated in this paper via an example in which our code significantly outperforms Mosek 9 and SCS 2.more » « less
-
Quantum relative entropy (QRE) programming is a recently popular and challenging class of convex optimization problems with significant applications in quantum computing and quantum information theory. We are interested in modern interior-point (IP) methods based on optimal self-concordant barriers for the QRE cone. A range of theoretical and numerical challenges associated with such barrier functions and the QRE cones have hindered the scalability of IP methods. To address these challenges, we propose a series of numerical and linear algebraic techniques and heuristics aimed at enhancing the efficiency of gradient and Hessian computations for the self-concordant barrier function, solving linear systems, and performing matrix-vector products. We also introduce and deliberate about some interesting concepts related to QRE such as symmetric quantum relative entropy. We design a two-phase method for performing facial reduction that can significantly improve the performance of QRE programming. Our new techniques have been implemented in the latest version (DDS 2.2) of the software package Domain-Driven Solver (DDS). In addition to handling QRE constraints, DDS accepts any combination of several other conic and nonconic convex constraints. Our comprehensive numerical experiments encompass several parts, including (1) a comparison of DDS 2.2 with Hypatia for the nearest correlation matrix problem, (2) using DDS 2.2 for combining QRE constraints with various other constraint types, and (3) calculating the key rate for quantum key distribution (QKD) channels and presenting results for several QKD protocols.more » « less
-
Abstract Polynomial nonnegativity constraints can often be handled using thesum of squarescondition. This can be efficiently enforced using semidefinite programming formulations, or as more recently proposed by Papp and Yildiz (Papp D in SIAM J O 29: 822–851, 2019), using the sum of squares cone directly in an interior point algorithm. Beyond nonnegativity, more complicated polynomial constraints (in particular, generalizations of the positive semidefinite, second order and$$\ell _1$$ -norm cones) can also be modeled through structured sum of squares programs. We take a different approach and propose using more specialized cones instead. This can result in lower dimensional formulations, more efficient oracles for interior point methods, or self-concordant barriers with smaller parameters.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1287/ijoc.2022.1202
