Adaptive bitrate (ABR) algorithms aim to make optimal bitrate de- cisions in dynamically changing network conditions to ensure a high quality of experience (QoE) for the users during video stream- ing. However, most of the existing ABRs share the limitations of predefined rules and incorrect assumptions about streaming pa- rameters. They also come short to consider the perceived quality in their QoE model, target higher bitrates regardless, and ignore the corresponding energy consumption. This joint approach results in additional energy consumption and becomes a burden, especially for mobile device users. This paper proposes GreenABR, a new deep reinforcement learning-based ABR scheme that optimizes the energy consumption during video streaming without sacrificing the user QoE. GreenABR employs a standard perceived quality metric, VMAF, and real power measurements collected through a streaming application. GreenABR’s deep reinforcement learning model makes no assumptions about the streaming environment and learns how to adapt to the dynamically changing conditions in a wide range of real network scenarios. GreenABR outperforms the existing state-of-the-art ABR algorithms by saving up to 57% in streaming energy consumption and 60% in data consumption while achieving up to 22% more perceptual QoE due to up to 84% less rebuffering time and near-zero capacity violations.
more »
« less
GreenABR: Energy-aware Adaptive Bitrate Streaming with Deep Reinforcement Learning
Adaptive bitrate (ABR) algorithms aim to make optimal bitrate decisions in dynamically changing network conditions to ensure a high quality of experience (QoE) for the users during video streaming. However, most of the existing ABRs share the limitations of predefined rules and incorrect assumptions about streaming parameters. They also come short to consider the perceived quality in their QoE model, target higher bitrates regardless, and ignore the corresponding energy consumption. This joint approach results in additional energy consumption and becomes a burden, especially for mobile device users. This paper proposes GreenABR, a new deep reinforcement learning-based ABR scheme that optimizes the energy consumption during video streaming without sacrificing the user QoE. GreenABR employs a standard perceived quality metric, VMAF, and real power measurements collected through a streaming application. GreenABR's deep reinforcement learning model makes no assumptions about the streaming environment and learns how to adapt to the dynamically changing conditions in a wide range of real network scenarios. GreenABR outperforms the existing state-of-the-art ABR algorithms by saving up to 57% in streaming energy consumption and 60% in data consumption while achieving up to 22% more perceptual QoE due to up to 84% less rebuffering time and near-zero capacity violations.
more »
« less
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10389393
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Proceedings of the 13th ACM Multimedia Systems Conference (MMSys) 2022
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
The adaptive bitrate selection (ABR) mechanism, which decides the bitrate for each video chunk is an important part of video streaming. There has been significant interest in developing Reinforcement-Learning (RL) based ABR algorithms because of their ability to learn efficient bitrate actions based on past data and their demonstrated improvements over wired, 3G and 4G networks. However, the Quality of Experience (QoE), especially video stall time, of state-of-the-art ABR algorithms including the RL-based approaches falls short of expectations over commercial mmWave 5G networks, due to widely and wildly fluctuating throughput. These algorithms find optimal policies for a multi-objective unconstrained problem where the policies inherently depend on the predefined weight parameters of the multiple objectives (e.g., bitrate maximization, stall-time minimization). Our empirical evaluation suggests that such a policy cannot adequately adapt to the high variations of 5G throughput, resulting in long stall times. To address these issues, we formulate the ABR selection problem as a constrained Markov Decision Process where the objective is to maximize the QoE subject to a stall-time constraint. The strength of this formulation is that it helps mitigate the stall time while maintaining high bitrates. We propose COREL, a primal-dual actor-critic RL algorithm, which incorporates an additional critic network to estimate stall time compared to existing RL-based approaches and can tune the optimal dual variable or weight to guide the policy towards minimizing stall time. Our experiment results across various commercial mmWave 5G traces reveal that COREL reduces the average stall time by a factor of 4 and the 95th percentile by a factor of 2.more » « less
-
The HTTP adaptive streaming technique opened the door to cope with the fluctuating network conditions during the streaming process by dynamically adjusting the volume of the future chunks to be downloaded. The bitrate selection in this adjustment inevitably involves the task of predicting the future throughput of a video session, owing to which various heuristic solutions have been explored. The ultimate goal of the present work is to explore the theoretical upper bounds of the QoE that any ABR algorithm can possibly reach, therefore providing an essential step to benchmarking the performance evaluation of ABR algorithms. In our setting, the QoE is defined in terms of a linear combination of the average perceptual quality and the buffering ratio. The optimization problem is proven to be NP-hard when the perceptual quality is defined by chunk size and conditions are given under which the problem becomes polynomially solvable. Enriched by a global lower bound, a pseudo-polynomial time algorithm along the dynamic programming approach is presented. When the minimum buffering is given higher priority over higher perceptual quality, the problem is shown to be also NP-hard, and the above algorithm is simplified and enhanced by a sequence of lower bounds on the completion time of chunk downloading, which, according to our experiment, brings a 36.0% performance improvement in terms of computation time. To handle large amounts of data more efficiently, a polynomial-time algorithm is also introduced to approximate the optimal values when minimum buffering is prioritized. Besides its performance guarantee, this algorithm is shown to reach 99.938% close to the optimal results, while taking only 0.024% of the computation time compared to the exact algorithm in dynamic programming.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)Video streaming commonly uses Dynamic Adaptive Streaming over HTTP (DASH) to deliver good Quality of Experience (QoE) to users. Videos used in DASH are predominantly encoded by single-layered video coding such as H.264/AVC. In comparison, multi-layered video coding such as H.264/SVC provides more flexibility for up- grading the quality of buffered video segments and has the potential to further improve QoE. However, there are two challenges for us- ing SVC in DASH: (i) the complexity in designing ABR algorithms; and (ii) the negative impact of SVC’s coding overhead. In this work, we propose a deep reinforcement learning method called Grad for designing ABR algorithms that take advantage of the quality up- grade mechanism of SVC. Additionally, we quantify the impact of coding overhead on the achievable QoE of SVC in DASH, and propose jump-enabled hybrid coding (HYBJ) to mitigate the impact. Through emulation, we demonstrate that Grad-HYBJ, an ABR algo- rithm for HYBJ learned by Grad, outperforms the best performing state-of-the-art ABR algorithm by 17% in QoE.more » « less
-
The performance of Adaptive Bitrate (ABR) algorithms for video streaming depends on accurately predicting the download time of video chunks. Existing prediction approaches (i) assume chunk download times are dominated by network throughput; and (ii) apriori cluster sessions (e.g., based on ISP and CDN) and only learn from sessions in the same cluster. We make three contributions. First, through analysis of data from real-world video streaming sessions, we show (i) apriori clustering prevents learning from related clusters; and (ii) factors such as the Time to First Byte (TTFB) are key components of chunk download times but not easily incorporated into existing prediction approaches. Second, we propose Xatu, a new prediction approach that jointly learns a neural network sequence model with an interpretable automatic session clustering method. Xatu learns clustering rules across all sessions it deems relevant, and models sequences with multiple chunk-dependent features (e.g., TTFB) rather than just throughput. Third, evaluations using the above datasets and emulation experiments show that Xatu significantly improves prediction accuracies by 23.8% relative to CS2P (a state-of-the-art predictor). We show Xatu provides substantial performance benefits when integrated with multiple ABR algorithms including MPC (a well studied ABR algorithm), and FuguABR (a recent algorithm using stochastic control) relative to their default predictors (CS2P and a fully connected neural network respectively). Further, Xatu combined with MPC outperforms Pensieve, an ABR based on deep reinforcement learning.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- The DOI is not currently available.
