skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Ten guidelines for designing motor learning studies
Motor learning is a central focus of several disciplines including kinesiology, neuroscience and rehabilitation. However, given the different traditions of these fields, this interdisciplinarity can be a challenge when trying to interpret evidence and claims from motor learning experiments. To address this issue, we offer a set of ten guidelines for designing motor learning experiments starting from task selection to data analysis, primarily from the viewpoint of running lab-based experiments. The guidelines are not intended to serve as rigid rules, but instead to raise awareness about key issues in motor learning. We believe that addressing these issues can increase the robustness of work in the field and its relevance to the real-world.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1654929 1823889
PAR ID:
10398873
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Brazilian Journal of Motor Behavior
Volume:
16
Issue:
2
ISSN:
1980-5586
Page Range / eLocation ID:
112 to 133
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Designing effective rehabilitation strategies for upper extremities, particularly hands and fingers, warrants the need for a computational model of human motor learning. The presence of large degrees of freedom (DoFs) available in these systems makes it difficult to balance the trade-off between learning the full dexterity and accomplishing manipulation goals. The motor learning literature argues that humans use motor synergies to reduce the dimension of control space. Using the low-dimensional space spanned by these synergies, we develop a computational model based on the internal model theory of motor control. We analyze the proposed model in terms of its convergence properties and fit it to the data collected from human experiments. We compare the performance of the fitted model to the experimental data and show that it captures human motor learning behavior well. 
    more » « less
  2. Recent work characterized shifts in preparatory activity of the motor cortex during motor learning. The specific shift geometry during learning, washout, and relearning blocks was hypothesized to implement the acquisition, retention, and retrieval of motor memories. We sought to train recurrent neural network (RNN) models that could be used to study these motor learning phenomena. We built an environment for a curl field (CF) motor learning task and trained RNNs with reinforcement learning (RL) with novel regularization terms to perform behaviorally realistic reaching trajectories over the course of learning. Our choice of RL over supervised learning was motivated by the idea that motor adaptation, in the absence of demonstrations, is a process of reoptimization. We find these models, despite lack of supervision, reproduce many behavioral findings from monkey CF adaptation experiments. These models also captured key neurophysiological findings.We found that the model’s preparatory activity existed in a force-predictive subspace that remained stable across learning, washout, and relearning. Additionally, preparatory activity shifted uniformly, independently of the distance to the CF trained target. Finally, we found that the washout shift became more orthogonal to the learning shift, and hence more brain-like, when the RNNs were pretrained to have prior experience with CF dynamics. We argue the increased fit to neurophysiological recordings is driven by more generalizable and structured dynamical motifs in the model with more prior experience. This suggests that prior experience could organize preparatory neural activity underlying motor memory to have more orthogonal characteristics, by forming structured dynamical motifs in the motor cortex circuitry. 
    more » « less
  3. Bodily expressed emotion understanding (BEEU) aims to automatically recognize human emotional expressions from body movements. Psychological research has demonstrated that people often move using specific motor elements to convey emotions. This work takes three steps to integrate human motor elements to study BEEU. First, we introduce BoME (body motor elements), a highly precise dataset for human motor elements. Second, we apply baseline models to estimate these elements on BoME, showing that deep learning methods are capable of learning effective representations of human movement. Finally, we propose a dual-source solution to enhance the BEEU model with the BoME dataset, which trains with both motor element and emotion labels and simultaneously produces predictions for both. Through experiments on the BoLD in-the-wild emotion understanding benchmark, we showcase the significant benefit of our approach. These results may inspire further research utilizing human motor elements for emotion understanding and mental health analysis. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract This article studies fine motor strategies for precise spatial manipulation in close-to-body interactions. Our innate ability for precise work is the result of the confluence of visuo-tactile perception, proprioception, and bi-manual motor control. Contrary to this, most mixed-reality (MR) systems are designed for interactions at arms length. To develop guidelines for precise manipulations in MR systems, there is a need for a systematic study of motor strategies including physical indexing, bi-manual coordination, and the relationship between visual and tactile feedback. To address this need, we present a series of experiments using three variations of a tablet-based MR interface using a close-range motion capture system and motion-tracked shape proxies. We investigate an elaborate version of the classic peg-and-hole task that our results strongly suggests the critical need for high precision tracking to enable precise manipulation. 
    more » « less
  5. Precise timing underlies many behaviors, from musical performance to navigating a dynamic environment. This study examined how stable temporal patterns that emerge during goal-directed movements influence timing acuity in perceptual discrimination. Rather than relying on explicitly timed actions, we used a selfpaced throwing task in which temporal structure develops implicitly with practice. Across three experiments, participants were trained for four days, developing stable motor timing reflected in consistent ‘‘ball release times.’’ This emergent timing selectively enhanced sensitivity to matching temporal intervals in a perceptual discrimination task. Importantly, this effect was not explained by perceptual learning and persisted over several weeks, suggesting a durable motor-perceptual linkage. The results point to a shared representation of time in action and perception, an emergent timing primitive that arises through experience in spatiotemporal movements. These findings shed light on how motor learning can shape temporal perception in ecologically relevant contexts, with implications for rehabilitation and sensorimotor integration. 
    more » « less