skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


  • NSF Public Access
  • Search Results
  • WIP Teaching Engineers to Sketch: Impacts of Feedback from an Intelligent Tutoring Software on Engineers’ Sketching Skill Development
Title: WIP Teaching Engineers to Sketch: Impacts of Feedback from an Intelligent Tutoring Software on Engineers’ Sketching Skill Development
This Research Work In Progress Paper examines empirical evidence on the impacts of feedback from an intelligent tutoring software on sketching skill development. Sketching is a vital skill for engineering design, but sketching is only taught limitedly in engineering education. Teaching sketching usually involves one-on-one feedback which limits its application in large classrooms. To meet the demands of feedback for sketching instruction, SketchTivity was developed as an intelligent tutoring software. SketchTivity provides immediate personalized feedback on sketching freehand practice. The current study examines the effectiveness of the feedback of SketchTivity by comparing students practicing with the feedback and without. Students were evaluated on their motivation for practicing sketching, the development of their skills, and their perceptions of the software. This work in progress paper examines preliminary analysis in all three of these areas.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2013612
PAR ID:
10405696
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
2022 IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference (FIE)
Page Range / eLocation ID:
1 to 5
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; ; ; ; (, International journal of engineering education)
    Freehand sketching equips engineers to rapidly represent ideas in the design process, but most engineering curriculums fall short of equipping students with adequate sketching skills. This paper is focused on methods to improve engineers’ sketching skill through type of instruction, length of instruction, and delivery of and feedback for assignments using Sketchtivity, an intelligent sketch-tutoring software. We answer several key questions for providing better sketching education for engineers. Does perspective training improve freehand drawing ability? Can an intelligent tutoring software improve education outcomes? And how much sketching instruction is necessary for engineers? Analyzing the changes in sketching skill from pre- to post-sketching instruction between different instruction types (n = 116), we found that perspective sketching instruction significantly improved freehand sketching ability compared to traditional engineering sketching methods. When comparing pre to post sketching skill of students using Sketchtivity (n = 135), there was no significant difference in improvement between students using the intelligent tutoring software and those that exclusively practiced on paper – both groups improved equally. However, completing sketching tasks on tablets did not hinder students’ skill development even when measured on paper. Future work will more directly explore the influence of Sketchtivity on sketching skill development. Additionally, we found that five weeks of sketching instruction greatly improves sketching skill compared to only three weeks of instruction (n = 108), but both approaches significantly improve sketching self-efficacy. These outcomes support more extensive sketching instruction in engineering classrooms, and changes in instruction type to promote more freehand sketching skills. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ; ; ; ; (, IJEE International Journal of Engineering Education)
    Freehand sketching equips engineers to represent ideas rapidly in the design process, but most engineering curriculums fall short of equipping students with adequate sketching skills. This paper is focused on methods to improve engineers’ sketching skill through type of instruction, length of instruction, and delivery of and feedback for assignments using Sketchtivity, an intelligent sketch-tutoring software. We answer several key questions for providing better sketching education for engineers. Does perspective training improve freehand drawing ability? Can an intelligent tutoring software improve education outcomes? And how much sketching instruction is necessary for engineers? Analyzing the changes in sketching skill from pre- to post-sketching instruction between different instruction types (n = 116), we found that perspective sketching instruction significantly improved freehand sketching ability compared to traditional engineering sketching methods. When comparing pre to post sketching skill of students using Sketchtivity (n = 135), there was no significant difference in improvement between students using the intelligent tutoring software and those that exclusively practiced on paper – both groups improved equally. However, completing sketching tasks on tablets did not hinder students’ skill development even when measured on paper. Future work will more directly explore the influence of Sketchtivity on sketching skill development. Additionally, we found that five weeks of sketching instruction greatly improves sketching skill compared to only three weeks of instruction (n = 108), but both approaches significantly improve sketching self-efficacy. These outcomes support more extensive sketching instruction in engineering classrooms, and changes in instruction type to promote more freehand sketching skills. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; ; ; ; (, 2022 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition)
    Freehand sketching is a powerful skill in engineering design [1, 2]. Freehand sketching empowers designers in the early stages of design to express ideas, communicate with stakeholders, and evaluate concepts at a rapid pace. However, teaching sketching in engineering education poses unique challenges for the classroom. Sketching in other domains is often taught in studio-style courses where instructors can provide personalized feedback on technique. This type of feedback is not possible in typical large entry-level engineering graphics courses. To address this problem, Sketchtivity was developed as an intelligent tutoring software to aid instructors in providing feedback on sketching. Using a tablet and smart pen, learners receive real-time personalized feedback on sketching practice. The main goals of this project are to improve sketching instruction methods, understand the educational efficacy of Sketchtivity, and work towards improving the feedback and content of Sketchtivity. 
    more » « less
  4. (, Joint Proceedings of the ACM IUI Workshops 2023)
    Perspective sketching is a skill that is required for a variety of jobs including, but not limited to, architectural design, graphic design, and engineering. Sketching however, is a difficult skill to grasp for people early and can take a while to learn. Recently, there have been many intelligent tutoring systems (ITSs) designed to help improve people’s drawing skills. The feedback system for the perspective drawing lessons in SketchTivity, one such ITS, is currently limited to smoothness, speed, and accuracy of the lines. Our team plans to improve upon this feedback system so that the feedback provided to a user is now more nuanced as well as more actionable to reaffirm future learning. To evaluate our system we will conduct a user study with 40 students that involves going through several sketching lessons and then sketching a street corner in 2-D perspective. We plan to run a between-subjects user study with our participants to determine if our adjustment has any effect on the improvement of sketching skills and the usability of the application. We hope to determine that providing the user with data for their smoothness, speed, and accuracy after four sketching prompts can cause an overall improvement in the students’ scores in comparison to at the end of their sketching session. The algorithm that we created to identify a student’s potential issue we hope will be able to provide accurate, actionable feedback in most situations. The visual alterations we made to SketchTivity we expect to have a positive impact on the perspective feedback system and alter the students sketching performance. In future iterations the algorithm should be further refined and the data collected from the students sketches should be further developed to provide more data to create more actionable recommendations for improved sketching performance and retention. 
    more » « less
  5. (, Joint Proceedings of the ACM IUI Workshops 2023)
    Sketching skills are developed over time through practice, requiring students to stay motivated to continue improving. Gamification has been shown to be helpful in keeping users motivated, so this work seeks to investigate the impact of gamification on the user’s motivation to practice sketching skills in the intelligent tutoring system, SketchTivity. Specifically, this work will evaluate the impact of gamified elements including achievement banners, star ratings, and performance statistics to give users feedback about their level of success after a sketching lesson. This concept will be explored through within subjects focus group testing where participants will interact with each version of the interface, describe their experiences in a think-aloud fashion, and discuss their preferences in a post-interview. The motivational impact of the gamified elements will be synthesized through thematic analysis of the think-aloud comments and interview data as well as statistical analysis of performance differences in terms of SketchTivity’s sketch quality metrics. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email