Using density functional theory (DFT) calculations, we investigated the electrochemical reduction of CO 2 and the competing H 2 evolution reaction on ligand-protected Au 25 nanoclusters (NCs) of different charge states, Au 25 (SR) 18 q ( q = −1, 0, +1). Our results showed that regardless of charge state, CO 2 electroreduction over Au 25 (SR) 18 q NCs was not feasible because of the extreme endothermicity to stabilize the carboxyl (COOH) intermediate. When we accounted for the removal of a ligand (both –SR and –R) from Au 25 (SR) 18 q under electrochemical conditions, surprisingly we found that this is a thermodynamically feasible process at the experimentally applied potentials with the generated surface sites becoming active centers for electrocatalysis. In every case, the negatively charged NCs, losing a ligand from their surface during electrochemical conditions, were found to significantly stabilize the COOH intermediate, resulting in dramatically enhanced CO 2 reduction. The generated sites for CO 2 reduction were also found to be active for H 2 evolution, which agrees with experimental observations that these two processes compete. Interestingly, we found that the removal of an –R ligand from the negatively charged NC, resulted in a catalyst that was both active and selective for CO 2 reduction. This work highlights the importance of both the overall charge state and generation of catalytically active surface sites on ligand-protected NCs, while elucidating the CO 2 electroreduction mechanisms. Overall, our work rationalizes a series of experimental observations and demonstrates pathways to convert a very stable and catalytically inactive NC to an active electrocatalyst.
more »
« less
Ligand removal energetics control CO 2 electroreduction selectivity on atomically precise, ligated alloy nanoclusters
Atomically precise, thiolate-protected gold nanoclusters (TPNCs) exhibit remarkable catalytic performance for the electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide (CO 2 R) to CO. The origin of their high CO 2 R activity and selectivity has been attributed to partial ligand removal from the thiolate-covered surfaces of TPNCs to expose catalytically active sulfur atoms. Recently, heterometal doped (alloy) TPNCs have been shown to exhibit enhanced CO 2 R activity and selectivity compared to their monometallic counterparts. However, systematic studies on the effect of doping (metal type and location on TPNC) on active site exposure and CO 2 R activity are missing in literature. Herein, we apply Density Functional Theory calculations to investigate the effect of heterometal (Pt, Pd, Hg and Cd) doping of Au 25 (SR) 18 TPNC on the active site exposure and CO 2 R activity and selectivity. We reveal that doping significantly modifies relevant TPNC electronic properties, such as electron affinity, while also altering partial ligand removal and carboxyl (*COOH) intermediate formation energies. Furthermore, we demonstrate that changing the dopant ( e.g. Hg) position can change the selectivity of the TPNC towards CO (g) or H 2(g) formation, highlighting the importance of dopant locations in TPNC-based CO 2 R. Most notably, we report a universal ( i.e. capturing different dopant types and positions) linear trend between the ligand removal energy and i) the *COOH formation energy, as well as, ii) the hydrogen (*H) formation energy on the different alloy TPNCs. Thus, utilizing the ligand removal energy as a descriptor for CO 2 RR activity and selectivity, our work opens new avenues for accelerated computational screening of different alloy TPNCs for electrocatalytic CO 2 R applications.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1652694
- PAR ID:
- 10407955
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Environmental Science: Nano
- Volume:
- 9
- Issue:
- 6
- ISSN:
- 2051-8153
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 2032 to 2040
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Dissecting Critical Factors for Electrochemical CO 2 Reduction on Atomically Precise Au Nanoclustersmore » « less
Abstract This work investigates the critical factors impacting electrochemical CO2reduction reaction (CO2RR) using atomically precise Au nanoclusters (NCs) as electrocatalysts. First, the influence of size on CO2RR is studied by precisely controlling NC size in the 1–2.5 nm regime. We find that the electrocatalytic CO partial current density increases for smaller NCs, but the CO Faradaic efficiency (FE) is not directly associated with the NC size. This indicates that the surface‐to‐volume ratio, i.e. the population of active sites, is the dominant factor for determining the catalytic activity, but the selectivity is not directly impacted by size. Second, we compare the CO2RR performance of Au38isomers (Au38Q and Au38T) to reveal that structural rearrangement of identical size NCs can lead to significant changes in both CO2RR activity and selectivity. Au38Q shows higher activity and selectivity towards CO than Au38T, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations reveal that the average formation energy of the key *COOH intermediate on the proposed active sites is significantly lower on Au38Q than Au38T. These results demonstrate how the structural isomerism can impact stabilization of reaction intermediates as well as the overall CO2RR performance of identical size Au NCs. Overall, this work provides important structure–property relationships for tailoring the NCs for CO2RR.
-
Dissecting Critical Factors for Electrochemical CO 2 Reduction on Atomically Precise Au Nanoclustersmore » « less
Abstract This work investigates the critical factors impacting electrochemical CO2reduction reaction (CO2RR) using atomically precise Au nanoclusters (NCs) as electrocatalysts. First, the influence of size on CO2RR is studied by precisely controlling NC size in the 1–2.5 nm regime. We find that the electrocatalytic CO partial current density increases for smaller NCs, but the CO Faradaic efficiency (FE) is not directly associated with the NC size. This indicates that the surface‐to‐volume ratio, i.e. the population of active sites, is the dominant factor for determining the catalytic activity, but the selectivity is not directly impacted by size. Second, we compare the CO2RR performance of Au38isomers (Au38Q and Au38T) to reveal that structural rearrangement of identical size NCs can lead to significant changes in both CO2RR activity and selectivity. Au38Q shows higher activity and selectivity towards CO than Au38T, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations reveal that the average formation energy of the key *COOH intermediate on the proposed active sites is significantly lower on Au38Q than Au38T. These results demonstrate how the structural isomerism can impact stabilization of reaction intermediates as well as the overall CO2RR performance of identical size Au NCs. Overall, this work provides important structure–property relationships for tailoring the NCs for CO2RR.
-
more » « less
Abstract Carbon‐supported nitrogen‐coordinated single‐metal site catalysts (i.e., M−N−C, M: Fe, Co, or Ni) are active for the electrochemical CO2reduction reaction (CO2RR) to CO. Further improving their intrinsic activity and selectivity by tuning their N−M bond structures and coordination is limited. Herein, we expand the coordination environments of M−N−C catalysts by designing dual‐metal active sites. The Ni‐Fe catalyst exhibited the most efficient CO2RR activity and promising stability compared to other combinations. Advanced structural characterization and theoretical prediction suggest that the most active N‐coordinated dual‐metal site configurations are 2N‐bridged (Fe‐Ni)N6, in which FeN4and NiN4moieties are shared with two N atoms. Two metals (i.e., Fe and Ni) in the dual‐metal site likely generate a synergy to enable more optimal *COOH adsorption and *CO desorption than single‐metal sites (FeN4or NiN4) with improved intrinsic catalytic activity and selectivity.
-
more » « less
Abstract Carbon‐supported nitrogen‐coordinated single‐metal site catalysts (i.e., M−N−C, M: Fe, Co, or Ni) are active for the electrochemical CO2reduction reaction (CO2RR) to CO. Further improving their intrinsic activity and selectivity by tuning their N−M bond structures and coordination is limited. Herein, we expand the coordination environments of M−N−C catalysts by designing dual‐metal active sites. The Ni‐Fe catalyst exhibited the most efficient CO2RR activity and promising stability compared to other combinations. Advanced structural characterization and theoretical prediction suggest that the most active N‐coordinated dual‐metal site configurations are 2N‐bridged (Fe‐Ni)N6, in which FeN4and NiN4moieties are shared with two N atoms. Two metals (i.e., Fe and Ni) in the dual‐metal site likely generate a synergy to enable more optimal *COOH adsorption and *CO desorption than single‐metal sites (FeN4or NiN4) with improved intrinsic catalytic activity and selectivity.
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1039/d2en00157h
