skip to main content


Title: Comparing solution paths of sparse quadratic minimization with a Stieltjes matrix
Abstract

This paper studies several solution paths of sparse quadratic minimization problems as a function of the weighing parameter of the bi-objective of estimation loss versus solution sparsity. Three such paths are considered: the “$$\ell _0$$0-path” where the discontinuous$$\ell _0$$0-function provides the exact sparsity count; the “$$\ell _1$$1-path” where the$$\ell _1$$1-function provides a convex surrogate of sparsity count; and the “capped$$\ell _1$$1-path” where the nonconvex nondifferentiable capped$$\ell _1$$1-function aims to enhance the$$\ell _1$$1-approximation. Serving different purposes, each of these three formulations is different from each other, both analytically and computationally. Our results deepen the understanding of (old and new) properties of the associated paths, highlight the pros, cons, and tradeoffs of these sparse optimization models, and provide numerical evidence to support the practical superiority of the capped$$\ell _1$$1-path. Our study of the capped$$\ell _1$$1-path is interesting in its own right as the path pertains to computable directionally stationary (= strongly locally minimizing in this context, as opposed to globally optimal) solutions of a parametric nonconvex nondifferentiable optimization problem. Motivated by classical parametric quadratic programming theory and reinforced by modern statistical learning studies, both casting an exponential perspective in fully describing such solution paths, we also aim to address the question of whether some of them can be fully traced in strongly polynomial time in the problem dimensions. A major conclusion of this paper is that a path of directional stationary solutions of the capped$$\ell _1$$1-regularized problem offers interesting theoretical properties and practical compromise between the$$\ell _0$$0-path and the$$\ell _1$$1-path. Indeed, while the$$\ell _0$$0-path is computationally prohibitive and greatly handicapped by the repeated solution of mixed-integer nonlinear programs, the quality of$$\ell _1$$1-path, in terms of the two criteria—loss and sparsity—in the estimation objective, is inferior to the capped$$\ell _1$$1-path; the latter can be obtained efficiently by a combination of a parametric pivoting-like scheme supplemented by an algorithm that takes advantage of the Z-matrix structure of the loss function.

 
more » « less
Award ID(s):
2006762
NSF-PAR ID:
10411443
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Springer Science + Business Media
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Mathematical Programming
Volume:
204
Issue:
1-2
ISSN:
0025-5610
Format(s):
Medium: X Size: p. 517-566
Size(s):
["p. 517-566"]
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    We study the sparsity of the solutions to systems of linear Diophantine equations with and without non-negativity constraints. The sparsity of a solution vector is the number of its nonzero entries, which is referred to as the$$\ell _0$$0-norm of the vector. Our main results are new improved bounds on the minimal$$\ell _0$$0-norm of solutions to systems$$A\varvec{x}=\varvec{b}$$Ax=b, where$$A\in \mathbb {Z}^{m\times n}$$AZm×n,$${\varvec{b}}\in \mathbb {Z}^m$$bZmand$$\varvec{x}$$xis either a general integer vector (lattice case) or a non-negative integer vector (semigroup case). In certain cases, we give polynomial time algorithms for computing solutions with$$\ell _0$$0-norm satisfying the obtained bounds. We show that our bounds are tight. Our bounds can be seen as functions naturally generalizing the rank of a matrix over$$\mathbb {R}$$R, to other subdomains such as$$\mathbb {Z}$$Z. We show that these new rank-like functions are all NP-hard to compute in general, but polynomial-time computable for fixed number of variables.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Sparsity finds applications in diverse areas such as statistics, machine learning, and signal processing. Computations over sparse structures are less complex compared to their dense counterparts and need less storage. This paper proposes a heuristic method for retrieving sparse approximate solutions of optimization problems via minimizing the$$\ell _{p}$$pquasi-norm, where$$00<p<1. An iterative two-block algorithm for minimizing the$$\ell _{p}$$pquasi-norm subject to convex constraints is proposed. The proposed algorithm requires solving for the roots of a scalar degree polynomial as opposed to applying a soft thresholding operator in the case of$$\ell _{1}$$1norm minimization. The algorithm’s merit relies on its ability to solve the$$\ell _{p}$$pquasi-norm minimization subject to any convex constraints set. For the specific case of constraints defined by differentiable functions with Lipschitz continuous gradient, a second, faster algorithm is proposed. Using a proximal gradient step, we mitigate the convex projection step and hence enhance the algorithm’s speed while proving its convergence. We present various applications where the proposed algorithm excels, namely, sparse signal reconstruction, system identification, and matrix completion. The results demonstrate the significant gains obtained by the proposed algorithm compared to other$$\ell _{p}$$pquasi-norm based methods presented in previous literature.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Approximate integer programming is the following: For a given convex body$$K \subseteq {\mathbb {R}}^n$$KRn, either determine whether$$K \cap {\mathbb {Z}}^n$$KZnis empty, or find an integer point in the convex body$$2\cdot (K - c) +c$$2·(K-c)+cwhich isK, scaled by 2 from its center of gravityc. Approximate integer programming can be solved in time$$2^{O(n)}$$2O(n)while the fastest known methods for exact integer programming run in time$$2^{O(n)} \cdot n^n$$2O(n)·nn. So far, there are no efficient methods for integer programming known that are based on approximate integer programming. Our main contribution are two such methods, each yielding novel complexity results. First, we show that an integer point$$x^* \in (K \cap {\mathbb {Z}}^n)$$x(KZn)can be found in time$$2^{O(n)}$$2O(n), provided that theremaindersof each component$$x_i^* \mod \ell $$ximodfor some arbitrarily fixed$$\ell \ge 5(n+1)$$5(n+1)of$$x^*$$xare given. The algorithm is based on acutting-plane technique, iteratively halving the volume of the feasible set. The cutting planes are determined via approximate integer programming. Enumeration of the possible remainders gives a$$2^{O(n)}n^n$$2O(n)nnalgorithm for general integer programming. This matches the current best bound of an algorithm by Dadush (Integer programming, lattice algorithms, and deterministic, vol. Estimation. Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, 2012) that is considerably more involved. Our algorithm also relies on a newasymmetric approximate Carathéodory theoremthat might be of interest on its own. Our second method concerns integer programming problems in equation-standard form$$Ax = b, 0 \le x \le u, \, x \in {\mathbb {Z}}^n$$Ax=b,0xu,xZn. Such a problem can be reduced to the solution of$$\prod _i O(\log u_i +1)$$iO(logui+1)approximate integer programming problems. This implies, for example thatknapsackorsubset-sumproblems withpolynomial variable range$$0 \le x_i \le p(n)$$0xip(n)can be solved in time$$(\log n)^{O(n)}$$(logn)O(n). For these problems, the best running time so far was$$n^n \cdot 2^{O(n)}$$nn·2O(n).

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    There are many ways of measuring and modeling tail-dependence in random vectors: from the general framework of multivariate regular variation and the flexible class of max-stable vectors down to simple and concise summary measures like the matrix of bivariate tail-dependence coefficients. This paper starts by providing a review of existing results from a unifying perspective, which highlights connections between extreme value theory and the theory of cuts and metrics. Our approach leads to some new findings in both areas with some applications to current topics in risk management.

    We begin by using the framework of multivariate regular variation to show that extremal coefficients, or equivalently, the higher-order tail-dependence coefficients of a random vector can simply be understood in terms of random exceedance sets, which allows us to extend the notion of Bernoulli compatibility. In the special but important case of bivariate tail-dependence, we establish a correspondence between tail-dependence matrices and$$L^1$$L1- and$$\ell _1$$1-embeddable finite metric spaces via the spectral distance, which is a metric on the space of jointly 1-Fréchet random variables. Namely, the coefficients of the cut-decomposition of the spectral distance and of the Tawn-Molchanov max-stable model realizing the corresponding bivariate extremal dependence coincide. We show that line metrics are rigid and if the spectral distance corresponds to a line metric, the higher order tail-dependence is determined by the bivariate tail-dependence matrix.

    Finally, the correspondence between$$\ell _1$$1-embeddable metric spaces and tail-dependence matrices allows us to revisit the realizability problem, i.e. checking whether a given matrix is a valid tail-dependence matrix. We confirm a conjecture of Shyamalkumar and Tao (2020) that this problem is NP-complete.

     
    more » « less
  5. We show that for primesN,p≥<#comment/>5N, p \geq 5withN≡<#comment/>−<#comment/>1modpN \equiv -1 \bmod p, the class number ofQ(N1/p)\mathbb {Q}(N^{1/p})is divisible bypp. Our methods are via congruences between Eisenstein series and cusp forms. In particular, we show that whenN≡<#comment/>−<#comment/>1modpN \equiv -1 \bmod p, there is always a cusp form of weight22and levelΓ<#comment/>0(N2)\Gamma _0(N^2)whoseℓ<#comment/>\ellth Fourier coefficient is congruent toℓ<#comment/>+1\ell + 1modulo a prime abovepp, for all primesℓ<#comment/>\ell. We use the Galois representation of such a cusp form to explicitly construct an unramified degree-ppextension ofQ(N1/p)\mathbb {Q}(N^{1/p}).

     
    more » « less