An official website of the United States government
Abstract Some bird species exhibit a flight behavior known as whiffling, in which the bird flies upside-down during landing, predator evasion, or courtship displays. Flying inverted causes the flight feathers to twist, creating gaps in the wing’s trailing edge. It has been suggested that these gaps decrease lift at a potentially lower energy cost, enabling the bird to maneuver and rapidly descend. Thus, avian whiffling has parallels to an uncrewed aerial vehicle (UAV) using spoilers for rapid descent and ailerons for roll control. However, while whiffling has been previously described in the biological literature, it has yet to directly inspire aerodynamic design. In the current research, we investigated if gaps in a wing’s trailing edge, similar to those caused by feather rotation during whiffling, could provide an effective mechanism for UAV control, particularly rapid descent and banking. To address this question, we performed a wind tunnel test of 3D printed wings with a varying amount of trailing edge gaps and compared the lift and rolling moment coefficients generated by the gapped wings to a traditional spoiler and aileron. Next, we used an analytical analysis to estimate the force and work required to actuate gaps, spoiler, and aileron. Our results showed that gapped wings did not reduce lift as much as a spoiler and required more work. However, we found that at high angles of attack, the gapped wings produced rolling moment coefficients equivalent to upwards aileron deflections of up to 32.7° while requiring substantially less actuation force and work. Thus, while the gapped wings did not provide a noticeable benefit over spoilers for rapid descent, a whiffling-inspired control surface could provide an effective alternative to ailerons for roll control. These findings suggest a novel control mechanism that may be advantageous for small fixed-wing UAVs, particularly energy-constrained aircraft.
more »
« less
Energy considerations and flow fields over whiffling-inspired wings
Abstract Some bird species fly inverted, or whiffle, to lose altitude. Inverted flight twists the primary flight feathers, creating gaps along the wing’s trailing edge and decreasing lift. It is speculated that feather rotation-inspired gaps could be used as control surfaces on uncrewed aerial vehicles (UAVs). When implemented on one semi-span of a UAV wing, the gaps produce roll due to the asymmetric lift distribution. However, the understanding of the fluid mechanics and actuation requirements of this novel gapped wing were rudimentary. Here, we use a commercial computational fluid dynamics solver to model a gapped wing, compare its analytically estimated work requirements to an aileron, and identify the impacts of key aerodynamic mechanisms. An experimental validation shows that the results agree well with previous findings. We also find that the gaps re-energize the boundary layer over the suction side of the trailing edge, delaying stall of the gapped wing. Further, the gaps produce vortices distributed along the wingspan. This vortex behavior creates a beneficial lift distribution that produces comparable roll and less yaw than the aileron. The gap vortices also inform the change in the control surface’s roll effectiveness across angle of attack. Finally, the flow within a gap recirculates and creates negative pressure coefficients on the majority of the gap face. The result is a suction force on the gap face that increases with angle of attack and requires work to hold the gaps open. Overall, the gapped wing requires higher actuation work than the aileron at low rolling moment coefficients. However, above rolling moment coefficients of 0.0182, the gapped wing requires less work and ultimately produces a higher maximum rolling moment coefficient. Despite the variable control effectiveness, the data suggest that the gapped wing could be a useful roll control surface for energy-constrained UAVs at high lift coefficients.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1935216
- PAR ID:
- 10414365
- Publisher / Repository:
- IOP Publishing
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Bioinspiration & Biomimetics
- Volume:
- 18
- Issue:
- 4
- ISSN:
- 1748-3182
- Format(s):
- Medium: X Size: Article No. 046007
- Size(s):
- Article No. 046007
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
null (Ed.)Birds dynamically adapt to disparate flight behaviours and unpredictable environments by actively manipulating their skeletal joints to change their wing shape. This in-flight adaptability has inspired many unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) wings, which predominately morph within a single geometric plane. By contrast, avian joint-driven wing morphing produces a diverse set of non-planar wing shapes. Here, we investigated if joint-driven wing morphing is desirable for UAVs by quantifying the longitudinal aerodynamic characteristics of gull-inspired wing-body configurations. We used a numerical lifting-line algorithm (MachUpX) to determine the aerodynamic loads across the range of motion of the elbow and wrist, which was validated with wind tunnel tests using three-dimensional printed wing-body models. We found that joint-driven wing morphing effectively controls lift, pitching moment and static margin, but other mechanisms are required to trim. Within the range of wing extension capability, specific paths of joint motion (trajectories) permit distinct longitudinal flight control strategies. We identified two unique trajectories that decoupled stability from lift and pitching moment generation. Further, extension along the trajectory inherent to the musculoskeletal linkage system produced the largest changes to the investigated aerodynamic properties. Collectively, our results show that gull-inspired joint-driven wing morphing allows adaptive longitudinal flight control and could promote multifunctional UAV designs.more » « less
-
The goal of this paper is to design a stabilizing feedback controller of roll instability near stall. This problem becomes immensely challenging since the aileron sensitivity is vanishes and even reversed sign at stall. This challenge is overcome by employing the recently developed Lie Bracket Roll Augmentation (LIBRA) mechanism. In this mechanism,the nonlinear dynamics of the airplane near stall is exploited to achieve a rolling motion that is independent of the aileron sensitivity. Rather, it depends on the variation of the aileron sensitivity with the angle of attack which is non-zero at stall. The open loop characteristics of the LIBRA mechanism have been studied previously. The contribution of the current manuscript lies in using the LIBRA mechanism in a feedback fashion to stabilize the roll unstable dynamics near stall using a stabilization scheme based on motion planning techniques for highly oscillatory inputs.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)ABSTRACT Flying snakes flatten their body to form a roughly triangular cross-sectional shape, enabling lift production and horizontal acceleration. While gliding, they also assume an S-shaped posture, which could promote aerodynamic interactions between the fore and the aft body. Such interactions have been studied experimentally; however, very coarse models of the snake's cross-sectional shape were used, and the effects were measured only for the downstream model. In this study, the aerodynamic interactions resulting from the snake's posture were approximated using two-dimensional anatomically accurate airfoils positioned in tandem to mimic the snake's geometry during flight. Load cells were used to measure the lift and drag forces, and flow field data were obtained using digital particle image velocimetry (DPIV). The results showed a strong dependence of the aerodynamic performance on the tandem arrangement, with the lift coefficients being generally more influenced than the drag coefficients. Flow field data revealed that the tandem arrangement modified the separated flow and the wake size, and enhanced the lift in cases in which the wake vortices formed closer to the models, producing suction on the dorsal surface. The downforce created by the flow separation from the ventral surface of the models at 0 deg angle of attack was another significant factor contributing to lift production. A number of cases showing large variations of aerodynamic performance included configurations close to the most probable posture of airborne flying snakes, suggesting that small postural variations could be used to control the glide trajectory.more » « less
-
Results of a previous aerodynamics study conducted over a wing that exhibits the Prandtl Bell Spanload were implemented into a simulation environment with the intent of studying unique flight characteristics that are theorized to be presented by this spanload. However, early simulations over the dynamics show that the yawing moment due to roll rate is of higher effect than the yaw moment due to aileron deflection angle. This over-prediction of the roll-yaw coupling term has been called into question. A new method is to be tested, which implements a compact vortex-lattice (CVLM) formulation, to show the difference between the flight dynamics predicted by this new method and the stability derivative method currently in use. The analysis utilizes two initial conditions to test the differences as the dynamics propagate through time. The first, a large initial bank angle, leads to the stabiltiy derivative method diverging while the CVLM results show this to not be the case. The second condition, a wind-field representative of a stable nocturnal boundary layer over the ground, leads to much more agreement between methods before divergence occurs due to a velocity higher than that of the stability derivative linearization point. It is then agreed that, since CVLM cannot predict stall effects and other nonlinear flight regions, a hybrid approach is proposed that takes advantage of the roll-yaw coupling prediction of the CVLM and the range of condition available to the stability derivative method.more » « less
