The production of ammonia for agricultural and energy demands has accelerated research for more environmentally-friendly synthesis options, particularly the electrocatalytic reduction of molecular nitrogen (nitrogen reduction reaction, NRR). Catalyst activity for NRR, and selectivity for NRR over the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction (HER), are critical issues for which fundamental knowledge remains scarce. Herein, we present results regarding the NRR activity and selectivity of sputter-deposited titanium nitride and titanium oxynitride films for NRR and HER. Electrochemical, fluorescence and UV absorption measurements show that titanium oxynitride exhibits NRR activity under acidic conditions (pH 1.6, 3.2) but is inactive at pH 7. Ti oxynitride is HER inactive at all these pH values. In contrast, TiN – with no oxygen content upon deposition – is both NRR and HER inactive at all the above pH values. This difference in oxynitride/nitride reactivity is observed despite the fact that both films exhibit very similar surface chemical compositions – predominantly Ti IV oxide – upon exposure to ambient, as determined by ex situ X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). XPS, with in situ transfer between electrochemical and UHV environments, however, demonstrates that this Ti IV oxide top layer is unstable under acidic conditions, but stable at pH 7, explaining the inactivity of titanium oxynitride at this pH. The inactivity of TiN at acidic and neutral pH is explained by DFT-based calculations showing that N 2 adsorption at N-ligated Ti centers is energetically significantly less favorable than at O-ligated centers. These calculations also predict that N 2 will not bind to Ti IV centers due to a lack of π-backbonding. Ex situ XPS measurements and electrochemical probe measurements at pH 3.2 demonstrate that Ti oxynitride films undergo gradual dissolution under NRR conditions. The present results demonstrate that the long-term catalyst stability and maintenance of metal cations in intermediate oxidation states for pi-backbonding are critical issues worthy of further examination.
more »
« less
Electrocatalytic selectivity for nitrogen reduction vs. hydrogen evolution: a comparison of vanadium and cobalt oxynitrides at different pH values
The electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) is of significant interest as an environmentally friendly method for NH 3 production for agricultural and clean energy applications. Selectivity of NRR vis-à-vis the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER), however, is thought to adversely impact many potential catalysts, including Earth-abundant transition metal oxynitrides. Relative HER/NRR selectivities are therefore directly compared for two transition metal oxynitrides with different metal oxophilicities—Co and V. Electrocatalytic current–potential measurements, operando fluorescence, absorption, and GC measurements of H 2 and NH 3 production, ex situ X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and density functional theory (DFT) calculations are combined to directly compare NRR and HER activities under identical reaction conditions. Results show that cobalt oxynitrides – with Co primarily in the Co( ii ) oxidation state – are NRR active at pH 10, with electrochemical reduction of both lattice nitrogen and dissolved N 2 , the latter occurring without N incorporation into the lattice. Removal of lattice N then yields Co( ii ) oxide, which is still NRR active. These results are complemented by calculations showing that N 2 binding at Co( ii ) sites is energetically favored over binding at Co( iii ) sites. GC analysis demonstrates that H 2 production occurs in concert with ammonia production but at a far greater rate. In contrast, vanadium oxynitride films are HER inactive under the same (pH 10) conditions, as well as at pH 7, but are NRR active at pH 7. DFT calculations indicate that a major difference in the two materials is hindered O–H dissociation of H 2 O adsorbed at O-ligated Co vs. V cation centers. The combined studies indicate significant variation in HER vs. NRR selectivity as a function of employed transition metal oxynitrides, as well as different HER mechanisms in V and Co oxynitrides.
more »
« less
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10425287
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Materials Chemistry A
- Volume:
- 10
- Issue:
- 40
- ISSN:
- 2050-7488
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 21401 to 21415
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Electro- and photocatalytic reduction of N 2 to NH 3 —the nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR)—is an environmentally- and energy-friendly alternative to the Haber-Bosch process for ammonia production. There is a great demand for the development of novel semiconductor-based electrocatalysts with high efficiency and stability for the direct conversion of inert substrates—including N 2 to ammonia—using visible light irradiation under ambient conditions. Herein we report electro-, and photocatalytic NRR with transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDCs), viz MoS 2 and WS 2 . Improved acid treatment of bulk TMDCs yields exfoliated TMDCs (exTMDCs) only a few layers thick with ∼10% S vacancies. Linear scan voltammograms on exMoS 2 and exWS 2 electrodes reveal significant NRR activity for exTMDC-modified electrodes, which is greatly enhanced by visible light illumination. Spectral measurements confirm ammonia as the main reaction product of electrocatalytic and photocatalytic NRR, and the absence of hydrazine byproduct. Femtosecond-resolved transient absorption studies provide direct evidence of interaction between photo-generated excitons/trions with N 2 adsorbed at S vacancies. DFT calculations corroborate N 2 binding to exMoS 2 at S-vacancies, with substantial π -backbonding to activate dinitrogen. Our findings suggest that chemically functionalized exTMDC materials could fulfill the need for highly-desired, inexpensive catalysts for the sustainable production of NH 3 using Sunlight under neutral pH conditions without appreciable competing production of H 2 .more » « less
-
more » « less
Abstract Ammonia (NH3) electrosynthesis gains significant attention as NH3is essentially important for fertilizer production and fuel utilization. However, electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) remains a great challenge because of low activity and poor selectivity. Herein, a new class of atomically dispersed Ni site electrocatalyst is reported, which exhibits the optimal NH3yield of 115 µg cm−2h−1at –0.8 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE) under neutral conditions. High faradic efficiency of 21 ± 1.9% is achieved at ‐0.2 V versus RHE under alkaline conditions, although the ammonia yield is lower. The Ni sites are stabilized with nitrogen, which is verified by advanced X‐ray absorption spectroscopy and electron microscopy. Density functional theory calculations provide insightful understanding on the possible structure of active sites, relevant reaction pathways, and confirm that the Ni‐N3sites are responsible for the experimentally observed activity and selectivity. Extensive controls strongly suggest that the atomically dispersed NiN3site‐rich catalyst provides more intrinsically active sites than those in N‐doped carbon, instead of possible environmental contamination. This work further indicates that single‐metal site catalysts with optimal nitrogen coordination is very promising for NRR and indeed improves the scaling relationship of transition metals.
-
more » « less
Abstract To achieve efficient ammonia synthesis via electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR), a qualified catalyst should have both high specific activity and large active surface area. However, integrating these two merits into one single material remains a big challenge due to the difficulty in balancing multiple reaction intermediates. Here, it is demonstrated that the boron‐analogues of MXenes, namely “MBenes”, could cope with the challenge and achieve the high activity and large reaction region simultaneously toward NRR. Using extensive density functional theory computations and taking 16 MBenes as representatives, it is identified that seven MBenes (CrB, MoB, WB, Mo2B, V3B4, CrMnB2, and CrFeB2) not only have intrinsic basal plane activity for NRR with limiting potentials ranging from −0.22 to −0.82 V, but also possess superior capability of suppressing the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction. Particularly, different from the MXenes whose surface oxidation may block the active sites, once oxidized, these MBenes can catalyze NRR via the self‐activating process, reducing O*/OH* into H2O* under reaction conditions, and favoring the N2electroreduction. As a result, the exceptional activity and selectivity, high active area (≈1019m−2), and antioxidation nature render these MBenes as pH‐universal catalysts for NH3production without introducing any dopants and defects.
-
The nitrogen electroreduction reaction (NRR) in aqueous solutions under ambient conditions represents an attractive prospect to produce ammonia, but the development of long-term stable and low-cost catalysts with high-efficiency and high-selectivity remains a great challenge. Herein, we investigated the potential of a new class of experimentally available boron-containing materials, i.e. , cubic boron phosphide (BP) and boron arsenide (BAs), as metal-free NRR electrocatalysts by means of density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Our results revealed that gas phase N 2 can be sufficiently activated on the B-terminated (111) polar surfaces of BP and BAs, and effectively reduced to NH 3 via an enzymatic pathway with an extremely low limiting potential (−0.12 V on BP and −0.31 V on BAs, respectively). In particular, the two proposed B-terminated (111) surfaces not only have a large active region for N 2 reduction, but also can significantly inhibit the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction, and thus have rather high efficiency and selectivity for the NRR. Therefore, cubic BP or BAs with mainly exposed (111) facets may serve as promising metal-free NRR catalysts with superior performance.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1039/D2TA05180J
