skip to main content

Title: SEESAW: a tool for detecting memory vulnerabilities in protocol stack implementations
As the number of Internet of Things (IoT) devices proliferate, an in-depth understanding of the IoT attack surface has become quintessential for dealing with the security and reliability risks. IoT devices and components execute implementations of various communication protocols. Vulnerabilities in the protocol stack implementations form an important part of the IoT attack surface. Therefore, finding memory errors in such implementations is essential for improving the IoT security and reliability. This paper presents a tool, SEESAW, that is built on top of a static analysis tool and a symbolic execution engine to achieve scalable analysis of protocol stack implementations. SEESAW leverages the API model of the analyzed code base to perform component-level analysis. SEESAW has been applied to the USB and Bluetooth modules within the Linux kernel. SEESAW can reproduce known memory vulnerabilities in a more scalable way compared to baseline symbolic execution.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Page Range / eLocation ID:
126 to 133
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Universal Serial Bus (USB) is the de facto protocol supported by peripherals and mobile devices, such as USB thumb drives and smartphones. For many devices, USB Type-C ports are the primary interface for charging, file transfer, audio, video, etc. Accordingly, attackers have exploited different vulnerabilities within USB stacks, compromising host machines via BadUSB attacks or jailbreaking iPhones from USB connections. While there exist fuzzing frameworks dedicated to USB vulnerability discovery, all of them focus on USB host stacks and ignore USB gadget stacks, which enable all the features within modern peripherals and smart devices. In this paper, we propose FUZZUSB, the first fuzzing framework for the USB gadget stack within commodity OS kernels, leveraging static analysis, symbolic execution, and stateful fuzzing. FUZZUSB combines static analysis and symbolic execution to extract internal state machines from USB gadget drivers, and uses them to achieve state-guided fuzzing through multi-channel in- puts. We have implemented FUZZUSB upon the syzkaller kernel fuzzer and applied it to the most recent mainline Linux, Android, and FreeBSD kernels. As a result, we have found 34 previously unknown bugs within the Linux and Android kernels, and opened 7 CVEs. Furthermore, compared to the baseline, FUZZUSB has also demonstrated different improvements, including 3× higher code coverage, 50× improved bug-finding efficiency for Linux USB gadget stacks, 2× higher code coverage for FreeBSD USB gadget stacks, and reproducing known bugs that could not be detected by the baseline fuzzers. We believe FUZZUSB provides developers a powerful tool to thwart USB-related vulnerabilities within modern devices and complete the current USB fuzzing scope. 
    more » « less
  2. With the rapid expansion of the Internet of Things, a vast number of microcontroller-based IoT devices are now susceptible to attacks through the Internet. Vulnerabilities within the firmware are one of the most important attack surfaces. Fuzzing has emerged as one of the most effective techniques for identifying such vulnerabilities. However, when applied to IoT firmware, several challenges arise, including: (1) the inability of firmware to execute properly in the absence of peripherals, (2) the lack of support for exploring input spaces of multiple peripherals, (3) difficulties in instrumenting and gathering feedback, and (4) the absence of a fault detection mechanism. To address these challenges, we have developed and implemented an innovative peripheral-independent hybrid fuzzing tool called . This tool enables testing of microcontroller-based firmware without reliance on specific peripheral hardware. First, a unified virtual peripheral was integrated to model the behaviors of various peripherals, thus enabling the physical devices-agnostic firmware execution. Then, a hybrid event generation approach was used to generate inputs for different peripheral accesses. Furthermore, two-level coverage feedback was collected to optimize the testcase generation. Finally, a plugin-based fault detection mechanism was implemented to identify typical memory corruption vulnerabilities. A Large-scale experimental evaluation has been performed to show ’s effectiveness and efficiency. 
    more » « less
  3. The recent paradigm shift introduced by the Internet of Things (IoT) has brought embedded systems into focus as a target for both security analysts and malicious adversaries. Typified by their lack of standardized hardware, diverse software, and opaque functionality, IoT devices present unique challenges to security analysts due to the tight coupling between their firmware and the hardware for which it was designed. In order to take advantage of modern program analysis techniques, such as fuzzing or symbolic execution, with any kind of scale or depth, analysts must have the ability to execute firmware code in emulated (or virtualized) environments. However, these emulation environments are rarely available and cumbersome to create through manual reverse engineering, greatly limiting the analysis of binary firmware. In this work, we explore the problem of firmware re-hosting, the process by which firmware is migrated from its original hardware environment into a virtualized one. We show that an approach capable of creating virtual, interactive environments in an automated manner is a necessity to enable firmware analysis at scale. We present the first proof-of-concept system aiming to achieve this goal, called PRETENDER, which uses observations of the interactions between the original hardware and the firmware to automatically create models of peripherals, and allows for the execution of the firmware in a fully-emulated environment. Unlike previous approaches, these models are interactive, stateful, and transferable, meaning they are designed to allow the program to receive and process new input, a requirement of many analyses. We demonstrate our approach on multiple hardware platforms and firmware samples, and show that the models are flexible enough to allow for virtualized code execution, the exploration of new code paths, and the identification of security vulnerabilities. 
    more » « less
  4. Heap metadata attacks have become one of the primary ways in which attackers exploit memory corruption vulnerabilities. While heap implementation developers have introduced mitigations to prevent and detect corruption, it is still possible for attackers to work around them. In part, this is because these mitigations are created and evaluated without a principled foundation, resulting, in many cases, in complex, inefficient, and ineffective attempts at heap metadata defenses. In this paper, we present HEAPHOPPER, an automated approach, based on model checking and symbolic execution, to analyze the exploitability of heap implementations in the presence of memory corruption. Using HEAPHOPPER, we were able to perform a systematic analysis of different, widely used heap implementations, finding surprising weaknesses in them. Our results show, for instance, how a newly introduced caching mechanism in ptmalloc (the heap allocator implementation used by most of the Linux distributions) significantly weakens its security. Moreover, HEAPHOPPER guided us in implementing and evaluating improvements to the security of ptmalloc, replacing an ineffective recent attempt at the mitigation of a specific form of heap metadata corruption with an effective defense. 
    more » « less
  5. In the recent past, there has been a rapid increase in attacks on consumer Internet-of-Things (IoT) devices. Several attacks currently focus on easy targets for exploitation, such as weak configurations (weak default passwords). However, with governments, industries, and organizations proposing new laws and regulations to reduce and prevent such easy targets in the IoT space, attackers will move to more subtle exploits in these devices. Memory corruption vulnerabilities are a significant class of vulnerabilities in software security through which attackers can gain control of the entire system. Numerous memory corruption vulnerabilities have been found in IoT firmware already deployed in the consumer market. This paper presents an approach for exploiting stack-based buffer-overflow attacks in IoT firmware, to hijack the device remotely. To show the feasibility of this approach, we demonstrate exploiting a common network software application, Connman, used widely in IoT firmware such as Samsung smart TVs. A series of experiments are reported on, including: crashing and executing arbitrary code in the targeted software application in a controlled environment, adopting the attacks in uncontrolled environments (with standard software defenses such as W⊕X and ASLR enabled), and installing publicly available IoT firmware that uses this software application on a Raspberry Pi. The presented exploits demonstrate the ease in which an adversary can control IoT devices. 
    more » « less