An official website of the United States government
Does the head tilt observed in many domesticated dogs index lateralized language processing? To answer this question, the present study evaluated household dogs responding to four conditions in which owners provided an increasing number of communicative cues. These cues ranged from no communicative/affective cues to rich affective cues coupled with dog-directed speech. Dogs’ facial responses were first coded manually using the Dog Facial Action Coding System (DogFACS), followed by an in-depth investigation of head tilt behavior, in which AI-based automated analysis of head tilt and audio analysis of acoustic features extracted from communicative cues were implemented. In a sample of 103 dogs representing seven breed groups and mixed-breed dogs, we found significant differences in the number of head tilts occurring between conditions, with the most communicative (last) condition eliciting the most head tilts. There were also significant differences in the direction of the head tilts and between sex groups. Dogs were more likely to tilt their heads to the right, and neutered male dogs were more likely to tilt their heads than spayed female dogs. The right-tilt bias is consistent with left-hemisphere language processing in humans, with males processing language in a more lateralized manner, and females processing language more bilaterally—a pattern also observed in humans. Understanding the canine brain is important to both evolutionary research through a comparative lens, and in understanding our interspecies relationship.
more »
« less
ManyDogs 1: A Multi-Lab Replication Study of Dogs’ Pointing Comprehension
To promote collaboration across canine science, address replicability issues, and advance open science practices within animal cognition, we have launched the ManyDogs consortium, modeled on similar ManyX projects in other fields. We aimed to create a collaborative network that (a) uses large, diverse samples to investigate and replicate findings, (b) promotes open science practices of pre-registering hypotheses, methods, and analysis plans, (c) investigates the influence of differences across populations and breeds, and (d) examines how different research methods and testing environments influence the robustness of results. Our first study combines a phenomenon that appears to be highly reliable—dogs’ ability to follow human pointing—with a question that remains controversial: do dogs interpret pointing as a social communicative gesture or as a simple associative cue? We collected data (N = 455) from 20 research sites on two conditions of a 2-alternative object choice task: (1) Ostensive (pointing to a baited cup after making eye-contact and saying the dog’s name); (2) Non-ostensive (pointing without eye-contact, after a throat-clearing auditory control cue). Comparing performance between conditions, while both were significantly above chance, there was no significant difference in dogs’ responses. This result was consistent across sites. Further, we found that dogs followed contralateral, momentary pointing at lower rates than has been reported in prior research, suggesting that there are limits to the robustness of point-following behavior: not all pointing styles are equally likely to elicit a response. Together, these findings underscore the important role of procedural details in study design and the broader need for replication studies in canine science.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1658837
- PAR ID:
- 10447086
- Author(s) / Creator(s):
- ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; more »
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Animal Behavior and Cognition
- Volume:
- 10
- Issue:
- 3
- ISSN:
- 2372-4323
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 232 to 286
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract Dogs and humans have co-evolved for millennia. This provides an opportunity to examine neural adaptations supporting cross-species communication. Previous canine fMRI studies have identified functional activations in response to human voice perception. However, the specific neural pathways involved in dogs’ ability to process and respond to human language remain unknown. This study takes a data-driven approach to examine the brain connectivity supporting bidirectional communication in a large sample of dogs. We examine white matter pathways linking temporal regions, involved in the perception of communicative signals, and frontal regions, responsible for generating communicative responses. Using cortical regions with known axonal connectivity from tract tracing studies as a foundation, we applied probabilistic tractography to measure connectivity patterns in a diverse cohort of dogs (n = 110, 16 breeds). Our findings reveal that, beyond short-range intra-regional connections, consistent large-scale tracts connect the prefrontal, somatosensory, premotor, motor, and temporal lobes across subjects. Hierarchical clustering analysis revealed distinct structural organization, with sylvian regions strongly connected to motor regions and ectosylvian regions linked to higher-order frontal and prefrontal regions. This organization may suggest that the ectosylvian gyrus plays a key role in integrating auditory input with complex cognitive functions, potentially underlying cross-species communication and language processing in dogs. This study elucidates cortico-cortical communication pathways in dogs and contributes to our understanding of the neural basis of lexical processing in the canine brain.more » « less
-
Abstract Visual-world eye-tracking has long been a useful tool for measuring young children’s real-time interpretation of words and sentences. Recently, researchers have extended this method to virtual platforms to reduce equipment costs and recruit more diverse participants. However, there is currently limited guidance on best practices, which require individual researchers to invent their own methodologies and may prevent broader adoption. Here, we present three broad approaches for implementing nine remote visual-world eye-tracking studies, and show that this method is highly feasible for assessing fine-grained language processing across populations of varying ages, clinical statuses, and socioeconomic status backgrounds. We outline strategic methods for conducting this research effectively, including strategies for experimental design, data collection, and data analysis given the variable conditions outside of a lab setting. We adopt four criteria for evaluating success for this method: 1) Minimal subject attrition relative to in-person studies, 2) Minimal track loss relative to conventional eye-tracking, 3) Conceptual replication of previous findings, and 4) Evidence of broadening participation. These case studies provide a thorough guide to future researchers looking to conduct remote eye-tracking research with developmental populations. Ultimately, we conclude that visual-world eye-tracking using internet-based methods is feasible for research with young children and may provide a relatively inexpensive option that can reach a broader, more diverse set of participants.more » « less
-
This report summarizes findings from the summative evaluation of the NSF-AISL funded Narrative Elements Shaping Engineering Engagement design-based research project led by NYSCI. The evaluation examined if and how narrative design elements experimented with by NYSCI and partner teams impacted 7-14-year-old girls’ expressions of empathy and engagement with engineering across different museum activities and settings. Using observation and semi-structured interview methods with 202 girls across three museum settings, the evaluation was designed to: 1) understand whether and how narrative-based elements influence engagement in engineering activities for 7 to 14-year-old girls across three engineering design activities;2) highlight whether and how museum settings influence engagement with engineering practices for 7 to 14-year-old girls; 3) investigate the relationship between engineering practices, narrative practices, and empathy markers for 7 to 14-year-old girls within the designed engineering activities; 4) research how activity designs influence girls’ narrative practices, engineering practices, and empathy markers across activities and museums. To study these related goals involving the intertwined relationship between narrative, engineering, empathy, two conditions (i.e., initially defined as narrative and non-narrative) of three select engineering design activities were observed within one museum, and one activity was implemented across two additional museum sites.more » « less
-
Abstract Objective The aim of this study was to evaluate the functional, systemic, synovial and articular changes after intra-articular administration of a synthetic lubricin within healthy canine stifles. Study Design A prospective randomized blinded placebo-controlled study composed of 10 dogs equally divided into either a treatment group (intra-articular synthetic lubricin injection, n = 5) or control group (saline, n = 5). Clinical (orthopaedic examination, gait observation, gait analysis), biochemical (complete blood count and biochemistry profile) and local tissue outcomes (joint fluid analysis, joint capsule and articular cartilage histopathology) were evaluated over a time period of 3 months. Results No significant differences between the treatment group and control group were identified with regard to baseline patient parameters. No clinically significant orthopaedic examination abnormalities, gait abnormalities, biochemical alterations, joint fluid alterations or histopathological alterations were identified over the course of the study. Conclusion The synthetic lubricin studied herein is both biocompatible and safe for a single administration within the canine stifle joint. Further research is necessary to evaluate the clinical efficacy of the synthetic lubricin in canine osteoarthritic joints.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.26451/abc.10.03.03.2023
