An official website of the United States government
Research on socio-scientific issues (SSI) has revealed that it is critical for learners to develop a systematic understanding of the underlying issue. In this paper, we explore how modeling can facilitate students’ systems thinking in the context of SSI. Building on evidence from prior research in promoting systems thinking skills through modeling in scientific contexts, we hypothesize that a similar modeling approach could effectively foster students’ systematic understanding of complex societal issues. In particular, we investigate the affordances of socio-scientific models in promoting students’ systems thinking in the context of COVID-19. We examine learners’ experiences and reflections concerning three unique epistemic features of socio-scientific models, (1) knowledge representation, (2) knowledge justification, and (3) systems thinking. The findings of this study demonstrate that, due to the epistemic differences from traditional scientific modeling approach, engaging learners in developing socio-scientific models presents unique opportunities and challenges for SSI teaching and learning. It provides evidence that, socio-scientific models can serve as not only an effective but also an equitable tool for addressing this issue.
more »
« less
The Lake Urmia vignette: a tool to assess understanding of complexity in socio‐environmental systems
Abstract We introduce the Lake Urmia Vignette (LUV) as a tool to assess individuals' understanding of complexity in socio‐environmental systems. LUV is based on a real‐world case and includes a short vignette describing an environmental catastrophe involving a lake. Over a few decades, significant issues have manifested themselves at the lake because of various social, political, economic, and environmental factors. We design a rubric for assessing responses to a prompt. A pilot test with a sample of 30 engineering graduate students is conducted. We compare responses to LUV with other measures. Our findings suggest that students' understanding of complexity is positively associated with their understanding of systems concepts such as feedback loops but not with other possible variables such as self‐reported systems thinking skills or systems‐related coursework. Based on the provided instructions, researchers can use LUV as a novel assessment tool to examine understanding of complexity in socio‐environmental systems. © 2020 System Dynamics Society
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1824594
- PAR ID:
- 10457052
- Publisher / Repository:
- Wiley Blackwell (John Wiley & Sons)
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- System Dynamics Review
- Volume:
- 36
- Issue:
- 2
- ISSN:
- 0883-7066
- Format(s):
- Medium: X Size: p. 191-222
- Size(s):
- p. 191-222
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract A variety of classification approaches are used to facilitate understanding, prediction, monitoring, and the management of lakes. However, broad‐scale applicability of current approaches is limited by either the need for in situ lake data, incompatibilities among approaches, or a lack of empirical testing of approaches based on ex situ data. We developed a new geographic classification approach for 476,697 lakes ≥ 1 ha in the conterminous U.S. based on lake archetypes representing end members along gradients of multiple geographic features. We identified seven lake archetypes with distinct combinations of climate, hydrologic, geologic, topographic, and morphometric properties. Individual lakes were assigned weights for each of the seven archetypes such that groups of lakes with similar combinations of archetype weights tended to cluster spatially (although not strictly contiguous) and to have similar limnological properties (e.g., concentrations of nutrients, chlorophylla(Chla), and dissolved organic carbon). Further, archetype lake classification improved commonly measured limnological relationships (e.g., between nutrients and Chla) compared to a global model; a discrete archetype classification slightly outperformed an ecoregion classification; and considering lakes as continuous mixtures of archetypes in a more complex model further improved fit. Overall, archetype classification of US lakes as continuous mixtures of geographic features improved understanding and prediction of lake responses to limnological drivers and should help researchers and managers better characterize and forecast lake states and responses to environmental change.more » « less
-
This full research paper contributes to current work on fostering professional dispositions in computing and engineering education by identifying the categories of behaviors that students associate with dispositions while doing course work. Professional dispositions, demonstrated through desirable behaviors in the workplace, such as being persistent or self-directed, are explicitly sought by employers. Fostering dispositions among students has been identified in various curricular recommendations as an important goal. In prior work, the authors used reflection exercises, in which students were presented with the definition of a disposition and asked to answer an open-ended reflection prompt on how they applied the disposition in their own work. Thematic analysis of student responses to reflection exercises resulted in categories of behaviors that students associated with dispositions. In the work discussed in this paper, the authors used vignette exercises to collect and analyze similar data and gain further insight into behavioral categories and students’ perceptions of dispositions. Vignettes include short scenarios that demonstrate the application of dispositions in real life. A vignette exercise involves students reading a vignette scenario, identifying the disposition demonstrated by the scenario, and answering the same open-ended reflection prompt as in the reflection exercises from the earlier studies. The research question for this study is: Which behavioral categories obtained from analyzing student responses to reflection exercises were confirmed using vignette exercises (and which were not confirmed), and which behavioral categories were refined? To answer this question, researchers from four different institutions of higher education collected data in multiple courses over two semesters. The student open-ended responses to vignettes were thematically analyzed to identify behavioral categories for four dispositions: collaborative, meticulous, persistent and self-directed. The ultimate goal of this work is to create classroom interventions and learning activities that foster dispositions among students based on behavioral categories. This study supports this goal in two ways. It provides another iteration of behavioral category analysis and introduces vignettes to encourage students to reflect candidly and communicate clearly how they apply dispositions in terms of behaviors. The study results and their implications for fostering dispositions in a classroom setting are presented and discussed.more » « less
-
Abstract Assessment of socio-environmental problems and the search for solutions often require intersecting geospatial data on environmental factors and human population densities. In the United States, Census data is the most common source for information on population. However, timely acquisition of such data at sufficient spatial resolution can be problematic, especially in cases where the analysis area spans urban-rural gradients. With this data release, we provide a 30-m resolution population estimate for the contiguous United States. The workflow dasymetrically distributes Census block level population estimates across all non-transportation impervious surfaces within each Census block. The methodology is updatable using the most recent Census data and remote sensing-based observations of impervious surface area. The dataset, known as the U.G.L.I (updatable gridded lightweight impervious) population dataset, compares favorably against other population data sources, and provides a useful balance between resolution and complexity.more » « less
-
Abstract Chlorophyll and total phosphorus (TP) concentrations are key indicators of lake water quality and the relationship between them is a common tool for assessing lake trophic status. Despite the application of the chlorophyll–TP relationship in management settings, there is still an absence of a mechanistic understanding underlying its shape. We leveraged a process‐based model that focuses primarily on biogeochemical and physiological mechanisms to develop a framework that reconciles interactions between multiscale drivers of the chlorophyll–TP relationship, such as hydrologic P loads, lake shape, and algal physiology. We found that combinations of lake shape and hydrologic P load induce broad shifts in algal limitation status that underly the shape of the chlorophyll–TP relationship. Furthermore, we highlight the importance of algal traits in controlling shifts in limitation. Our framework ties key landscape and ecosystem features to biological limitation and provides a synthetic and process‐based understanding of the chlorophyll–TP relationship.more » « less
