skip to main content


Title: Hybrid Simulation and Quasi-linear Theory of Bi-Kappa Proton Instabilities
Abstract

The quasi-steady states of collisionless plasmas in space (e.g., in the solar wind and planetary environments) are governed by the interactions of charged particles with wave fluctuations. These interactions are responsible not only for the dissipation of plasma waves but also for their excitation. The present analysis focuses on two instabilities, mirror and electromagnetic ion cyclotron instabilities, associated with the same proton temperature anisotropyT>T(where ⊥, ∥ are directions defined with respect to the local magnetic field vector). Theories relying on standard Maxwellian models fail to link these two instabilities (i.e., predicted thresholds) to the proton quasi-stable anisotropies measured in situ in a completely satisfactory manner. Here we revisit these instabilities by modeling protons with the generalized bi-Kappa (bi-κpower-law) distribution, and by a comparative analysis of a 2D hybrid simulation with the velocity-moment-based quasi-linear (QL) theory. It is shown that the two methods feature qualitative and, even to some extent, quantitative agreement. The reduced QL analysis based upon the assumption of a time-dependent bi-Kappa model thus becomes a valuable theoretical approach that can be incorporated into the present studies of solar wind dynamics.

 
more » « less
Award ID(s):
2203321
NSF-PAR ID:
10458211
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
DOI PREFIX: 10.3847
Date Published:
Journal Name:
The Astrophysical Journal
Volume:
954
Issue:
2
ISSN:
0004-637X
Format(s):
Medium: X Size: Article No. 191
Size(s):
["Article No. 191"]
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    The charged particles in the solar wind are often observed to possess a nonthermal tail in the velocity distribution function, a feature that can be fitted with the Kappa model. The anisotropic, or bi-Kappa, model of protons, electrons, and other charged particles is thus adopted in the literature for interpreting the data as well as in the context of the analysis of wave–particle interactions. The present paper develops an approximate but efficient theory of the mirror and cyclotron instabilities excited by the bi-Kappa protons in the solar wind. A velocity moment-based quasi-linear theory of these instabilities is also formulated in order to investigate the saturation behavior. Applications of the formalism are made for instabilities close to the marginally unstable state, which is typical of the solar wind near 1 au.

     
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT Various plasma waves and instabilities are abundantly present in the solar wind plasma, as evidenced by spacecraft observations. Among these, propagating modes and instabilities driven by temperature anisotropies are known to play a significant role in the solar wind dynamics. In situ measurements reveal that the threshold conditions for these instabilities adequately explain the solar wind conditions at large heliocentric distances. This paper pays attention to the combined effects of electron firehose instability driven by excessive parallel electron temperature anisotropy (T⊥e < T∥e) at high beta conditions, and electromagnetic ion cyclotron instability driven by excessive perpendicular proton temperature anisotropy (T⊥i > T∥i). By employing quasilinear kinetic theory based upon the assumption of bi-Maxwellian velocity distribution functions for protons and electrons, the dynamical evolution of the combined instabilities and their mutual interactions mediated by the particles is explored in depth. It is found that while in some cases, the two unstable modes are excited and saturated at distinct spatial and temporal scales, in other cases, the two unstable modes are intermingled such that a straightforward interpretation is not so easy. This shows that when the dynamics of protons and electrons are mutually coupled and when multiple unstable modes are excited in the system, the dynamical consequences can be quite complex. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    We conduct two-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations to investigate the scattering of electron heat flux by self-generated oblique electromagnetic waves. The heat flux is modeled as a bi-kappa distribution with aT>Ttemperature anisotropy maintained by continuous injection at the boundaries. The anisotropic distribution excites oblique whistler waves and filamentary-like Weibel instabilities. Electron velocity distributions taken after the system has reached a steady state show that these instabilities inhibit the heat flux and drive the total distributions toward isotropy. Electron trajectories in velocity space show a circular-like diffusion along constant energy surfaces in the wave frame. The key parameter controlling the scattering rate is the average speed, or drift speedvd, of the heat flux compared with the electron Alfvén speedvAe, with higher drift speeds producing stronger fluctuations and a more significant reduction of the heat flux. Reducing the density of the electrons carrying the heat flux by 50% does not significantly affect the scattering rate. A scaling law for the electron scattering rate versusvd/vAeis deduced from the simulations. The implications of these results for understanding energetic electron transport during energy release in solar flares are discussed.

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    We investigate a secondary proton beam instability coexisting with the ambient solar wind turbulence at 50R. Three-dimensional hybrid numerical simulations (particle ions and a quasi-neutralizing electron fluid) are carried out with the plasma parameters in the observed range. In the turbulent background, the particle distribution function, in particular the slope of the “bump-on-tail” responsible for the instability, is time-dependent and inhomogeneous. The presence of the turbulence substantially reduces the growth rate and saturation level of the instability. We derive magnetic power spectra from the observational data and perform a statistical analysis to evaluate the average turbulence intensity at 50R. This information is used to link the observed frequency spectrum to the wavenumber spectrum in the simulations. We verify that Taylor’s frozen-in hypothesis is valid for this purpose to a sufficient extent. To reproduce the typical magnetic power spectrum of the instability observed concurrently with the background turbulence, an artificial spacecraft probe is run through the simulation box. The thermal-ion instabilities are often seen as power elevations in the kinetic range of scales above an extrapolation of the turbulence spectrum from larger scales. We show that the elevated power in the simulations is much higher than the background level. Therefore, the turbulence at the average intensity does not obscure the secondary proton beam instability, as opposed to the solar wind at 1 au, in which the ambient turbulence typically obscures thermal-ion instabilities.

     
    more » « less
  5. ABSTRACT

    The solar wind plasma is characterized by unequal effective kinetic temperatures defined in perpendicular and parallel directions with respect to the ambient magnetic field. For electrons, the excessive perpendicular temperature anisotropy leads to quasi-parallel electromagnetic electron cyclotron (or whistler) instability and aperiodic electron-mirror instability with oblique wave vectors. The present paper carries out a direct side-by-side comparison of quasi-linear (QL) theory and particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation of combined mirror and cyclotron instabilities acting upon the initially anisotropic electron temperatures, and find that the QL theory satisfactorily encapsulates the non-linear aspect of the combined instability effects. However, a discrepancy between the present study and a previous PIC simulation result is also found, which points to the need for further investigation to resolve such an issue.

     
    more » « less