skip to main content


Title: Modeling Benthic Versus Hyporheic Nutrient Uptake in Unshaded Streams With Varying Substrates
Abstract

Assessments of riverine ecosystem health and water quality require knowledge of how headwater streams transport and transform nutrients. Estimates of nutrient demand at the watershed scale are commonly inferred from reach‐scale solute injections, which are typically reported as uptake velocities (vf). Multiple interacting processes controlvf, making it challenging to predict howvfresponds to physical changes in the stream. In this study, we linkvfto a continuous time random walk model to quantify howvfis controlled by in‐stream (velocity, dispersion, and benthic reaction) and hyporheic processes (exchange rate, residence times, and hyporheic reaction). We fit the model to conservative (NaCl) and nitrate (NO3‐N) pulse tracer injections in unshaded replicate streams at the Notre Dame Linked Experimental Ecosystem Facility, which differed only in substrate size and distribution. Experiments were conducted over the first 25 days of biofilm colonization to examine how the interaction between substrate type and biofilm growth influenced modeled processes andvf. Model fits of benthic reaction rates were ∼8× greater than hyporheic reaction rates for all experiments and did not vary with substrate type or over time. High benthic reactivity was associated with filamentous green algae coverage on the streambed, which dominated total algal biomass. Finally,vfwas most sensitive to benthic reaction rate and stream velocity, and sensitivity varied with stream conditions due to its nonlinear dependence on all modeled processes. Together, these results demonstrate how reach‐scale nutrient demand reflects the relative contributions of biotic and abiotic processes in the benthic layer and the hyporheic zone.

 
more » « less
Award ID(s):
1705770
NSF-PAR ID:
10460167
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
DOI PREFIX: 10.1029
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences
Volume:
124
Issue:
2
ISSN:
2169-8953
Page Range / eLocation ID:
p. 367-383
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    Dissolved organic carbon (DOC) is a key variable impacting stream biogeochemical processes. The relationship between DOC concentration (C) and stream discharge (q) can elucidate spatial and temporal DOC source dynamics in watersheds. In the ephemeral glacial meltwater streams of the McMurdo Dry Valleys (MDV), Antarctica, the C‐qrelationship has been applied to dissolved inorganic nitrogen and weathering solutes including silica, which all exhibit chemostatic C‐qbehavior; but DOC‐qdynamics have not been studied. DOC concentrations here are low compared to temperate streams, in the range of 0.1–2 mg C l−1, and their chemical signal clearly indicates derivation from microbial biomass (benthic mats and hyporheic biofilm). To investigate whether the DOC generation rate from these autochthonous organic matter pools was sufficient to maintain chemostasis for DOC, despite these streams' large diel and interannual fluctuations in discharge, we fit the long‐term DOC‐qdata to a power law and an advection‐reaction model. Model outputs and coefficients of variation characterize the DOC‐qrelationship as chemostatic for several MDV streams. We propose a conceptual model in which hyporheic carbon storage, hyporheic exchange rates, and net DOC generation rates are key interacting components that enable chemostatic DOC‐qbehavior in MDV streams. This model clarifies the role of autochthonous carbon stores in maintaining DOC chemostasis and may be useful for examining these relationships in temperate systems, which typically have larger sources of bioavailable autochthonous organic carbon than MDV streams but where this autochthonous signal could be masked by a stronger allochthonous contribution.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Urbanization increases stormwater runoff into streams, resulting in channel erosion, and increases in sediment and nutrient delivery to receiving water bodies. Stream restoration is widely used as a Best Management Practice to stabilize banks and reduce sediment and nutrient loads. While most instream nutrient retention measurements are often limited to low flow conditions, most of the nutrient load is mobilized at high stream flows in urban settings. We, therefore, use a process‐based stream ecosystem model in conjunction with measurements at low flows and focus on estimation of stream nitrogen retention over the full streamflow distribution. The model provides a theoretical framework to evaluate the geomorphic, hydrologic, and ecological factors that are manipulated by stream restoration, and drive nitrogen retention. We set a model for a pool‐riffle sequence restored stream (190 m) in Baltimore County, Maryland and calibrated the model to thein situmeasured primary production (Nash–Sutcliffe model efficiency coefficient [NSE] NSE = 0.89), respiration (NSE = 0.74), and nitrate uptake lengths (R2 = 0.88). At the daily scale, simulations showed low nitrogen retention during high flows due to high transport rates, mobilization of stored hyporheic nitrogen, and scouring of periphyton biomass. This result underscores the need to reduce contributing watershed runoff flashiness to promote aquatic nutrient cycling and retention. At monthly and yearly time scale, model predicted a higher percent reduction in summer than in winter and estimated 5.7%–9.5% of annual nitrate reductions. While the model was tested in a pool‐riffle sequence restoration design, the approach can be adapted to evaluate a range of channel restoration design characteristics, and the effects of upland watershed restoration to mitigate stormwater loading through both restored and unrestored streams.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Inland waters are an important component of the global carbon budget. However, our ability to predict carbon fluxes from stream systems remains uncertain, aspCO2varies within streams at scales of 1–100 m. This makes direct monitoring of large‐scale CO2fluxes impractical. We incorporate CO2input and output fluxes into a stream network advection‐reaction model, representing the first process‐based representation of stream CO2dynamics at watershed scales. This model includes groundwater (GW) CO2inputs, water column (WC), benthic hyporheic zone (BHZ) respiration, downstream advection, and atmospheric exchange. We evaluate this model against existing statistical methods including upscaling and multiple linear regressions through comparisons to high‐resolution streampCO2data collected across the East River Watershed in the Colorado Rocky Mountains (USA). The stream network model accurately captures GW, evasion, and respiration‐drivenpCO2variability and significantly outperforms multiple linear regressions for predictingpCO2. Further, the model provides estimates of CO2contributions from internal versus external sources suggesting that streams transition from GW‐ to BHZ‐dominated sources between 3rd and 4th Strahler orders, with GW, BHZ, and WC accounting for 49.3%, 50.6%, and 0.1% of CO2fluxes from the watershed, respectively. Lastly, stream network model atmospheric CO2fluxes are 4‐12x times smaller than upscaling technique predictions, largely due to relationships between streampCO2and gas exchange velocities. Taken together, this stream network model improves our ability to predict stream CO2dynamics and efflux. Furthermore, future applications to regional and global scales may result in a significant downward revision of global flux estimates.

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Current understanding of the relationship between nitrate (NO3) uptake and energy cycling in lotic environments comes from studies conducted in low‐nutrient (NO3 < 1 mg‐N L−1), small (discharge <1 m3s−1) systems. Recent advances in sensor technology have allowed for continuous estimates of whole‐river NO3uptake, allowing us to address how the relationship between nutrient uptake and metabolism changes over time and space in larger rivers. We used a six‐month, controlled nitrogen (N) waste release into the eighth order Kansas River (USA) as an ecosystem level nutrient addition experiment. We deployed four NO3and dissolved oxygen sensors along a 33 km study reach, from February to May 2018, to assess the spatiotemporal relationship between nutrient uptake and stream metabolism during the waste addition. Contrary to our prediction, we did not find evidence of uptake saturation despite an extreme increase in nutrient supply during winter, a period of generally lower biological activity. Although high uptake rates were observed across the study reach, they were uncorrelated to gross primary production. Overall, despite winter temperatures, NO3uptake rates were high compared to small streams and rivers. We provide evidence that large rivers can be effective ecosystems for retaining and transforming nutrients, while showing that the fine‐scale mechanisms that regulate nutrient retention in large rivers are still largely unknown.

     
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Hydropsychid (net‐spinning caddisfly) larvae are aquatic macroinvertebrate ecosystem engineers, altering streambed properties by creating silk nets and retreats. Recent research has shown that caddisfly silk binds stream sediments and alters streambed cohesion, yet potential influences of caddisfly activity on streambed hydrologic properties have not received similar scrutiny. Utilizing a novel downward flow permeameter, we demonstrate how net‐spinning caddisfly colonization of the streambed interstitia at moderate but common densities (2000 m−2) can reduce vertical hydraulic conductivity (KV) by up to 55% in streambed sediments (coarse sand—medium gravel; median diameter = 12.91 mm). Additionally, organic matter content within sediment columns showed that occupation by caddisflies resulted in twice the ash‐free dry mass (AFDM) of noncaddisfly (primarily microbial) organic matter at the end of our experiments relative to control systems that lack caddisflies. These results suggest that net‐spinning caddisflies may restrict hyporheic exchange, alter streambed hydrologic residence time distributions and increase per‐unit‐volume biotic metabolic demand for stream solutes in the hyporheic zone, with the potential to alter whole‐stream biogeochemical processes.

     
    more » « less