skip to main content


Title: Integrated metabolic strategy: A framework for predicting the evolution of carbon‐water tradeoffs within plant clades
Abstract

The fundamental tradeoff between carbon gain and water loss has long been predicted as an evolutionary driver of plant strategies across environments. Nonetheless, challenges in measuring carbon gain and water loss in ways that integrate over leaf lifetime have limited our understanding of the variation in and mechanistic bases of this tradeoff. Furthermore, the microevolution of plant traits within species versus the macroevolution of strategies among closely related species may not be the same, and accordingly, the latter must be addressed using comparative phylogenetic analyses.

Here we introduce the concept of ‘integrated metabolic strategy’ (IMS) to describe the ratio between carbon isotope composition (δ13C) and oxygen isotope composition above source water (Δ18O) of leaf cellulose. IMS is a measure of leaf‐level conditions that integrate several mechanisms contributing to carbon gain (δ13C) and water loss (Δ18O) over leaf lifespan, with larger values reflecting higher metabolic efficiency and hence less of a tradeoff. We tested how IMS evolves among closely related yet ecologically diverse milkweed species, and subsequently addressed phenotypic plasticity in response to water availability in species with divergent IMS.

Integrated metabolic strategy varied strongly among 20Asclepiasspecies when grown under controlled conditions, and phylogenetic analyses demonstrate species‐specific tradeoffs between carbon gain and water loss. Larger IMS values were associated with species from dry habitats, with larger carboxylation capacity, smaller stomatal conductance and smaller leaves; smaller IMS was associated with wet habitats, smaller carboxylation capacity, larger stomatal conductance and larger leaves. The evolution of IMS was dominated by changes in species’ demand for carbon (δ13C) more so than water conservation (Δ18O). Although some individual physiological traits showed phylogenetic signal, IMS did not.

In response to experimental decreases in soil moisture, three species maintained similar IMS across levels of water availability because of proportional increases inδ13C and Δ18O (or little change in either), while one species increased IMS due to disproportional changes inδ13C relative to Δ18O.

Synthesis.IMS is a broadly applicable mechanistic tool; IMS variation among and within species may shed light on unresolved questions relating to the evolution and ecology of plant ecophysiological strategies.

 
more » « less
Award ID(s):
1645256
NSF-PAR ID:
10461576
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley-Blackwell
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Ecology
Volume:
107
Issue:
4
ISSN:
0022-0477
Page Range / eLocation ID:
p. 1633-1644
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    Nitrogen (N)‐fixing trees are thought to break a basic rule of leaf economics: higher leaf N concentrations do not translate into higher rates of carbon assimilation. Understanding how leaf N affects photosynthesis and water use efficiency (WUE) in this ecologically important group is critical.

    We grew six N‐fixing and four non‐fixing tree species for 4–5 years at four fertilization treatments in field experiments in temperate and tropical regions to assess how functional type (N fixer vs. non‐fixer) and N limitation affected leaf N and how leaf N affected light‐saturated photosynthesis (Asat), stomatal conductance (gsw) and WUE (WUEiand δ13C).

    Asat, WUEiand δ13C, but notgsw, increased with higher leaf N. Surprisingly, N‐fixing and non‐fixing trees displayed similar scaling between leaf N and these physiological variables, and this finding was supported by reanalysis of a global dataset. N fixers generally had higher leaf N than non‐fixers, even when non‐fixers were not N‐limited at the leaf level. Leaf‐level N limitation did not alter the relationship ofAsat,gsw, WUEiand δ13C with leaf N, although it did affect the photosynthetic N use efficiency. Higher WUE was associated with higher productivity, whereas higherAsatwas not.

    Synthesis: The ecological success of N‐fixing trees depends on the effect of leaf N on carbon gain and water loss. Using a field fertilization experiment and reanalysis of a global dataset, we show that high leaf‐level photosynthesis and WUE in N fixers stems from their higher average leaf N, rather than a difference between N fixers and non‐fixers in the scaling of photosynthesis and WUE with leaf N. By clarifying the mechanism by which N fixers achieve and benefit from high WUE, our results further the understanding of global N fixer distributions.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Leaf energy balance may influence plant performance and community composition. While biophysical theory can link leaf energy balance to many traits and environment variables, predicting leaf temperature and key driver traits with incomplete parameterizations remains challenging. Predicting thermal offsets (δ,Tleaf − Tairdifference) or thermal coupling strengths (β,Tleafvs.Tairslope) is challenging.

    We ask: (a) whether environmental gradients predict variation in energy balance traits (absorptance, leaf angle, stomatal distribution, maximum stomatal conductance, leaf area, leaf height); (b) whether commonly measured leaf functional traits (dry matter content, mass per area, nitrogen fraction, δ13C, height above ground) predict energy balance traits; and (c) how traits and environmental variables predictδandβamong species.

    We address these questions with diurnal measurements of 41 species co‐occurring along a 1,100 m elevation gradient spanning desert to alpine biomes. We show that (a) energy balance traits are only weakly associated with environmental gradients and (b) are not well predicted by common functional traits. We also show that (c)δandβcan be partially approximated using interactions among site environment and traits, with a much larger role for environment than traits. The heterogeneity in leaf temperature metrics and energy balance traits challenges larger‐scale predictive models of plant performance under environmental change.

    A freePlain Language Summarycan be found within the Supporting Information of this article.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    In seasonally dry tropical forests, plant functional type can be classified as deciduous low wood density, deciduous high wood density, or evergreen high wood density species. While deciduousness is often associated with drought‐avoidance and low wood density is often associated with tissue water storage, the degree to which these functional types may correspond to diverging and unique water use strategies has not been extensively tested.

    We examined (a) tolerance to water stress, measured by predawn and mid‐day leaf water potential; (b) water use efficiency, measured via foliar δ13C; and (c) access to soil water, measured via stem water δ18O.

    We found that deciduous low wood density species maintain high leaf water potential and low water use efficiency. Deciduous high wood density species have lower leaf water potential and variable water use efficiency. Both groups rely on shallow soil water. Evergreen high wood density species have low leaf water potential, higher water use efficiency, and access alternative water sources. These findings indicate that deciduous low wood density species are drought avoiders, with a specialized strategy for storing root and stem water. Deciduous high wood density species are moderately drought tolerant, and evergreen high wood density species are the most drought tolerant group.

    Synthesis. Our results broadly support the plant functional type framework as a way to understand water use strategies, but also highlight species‐level differences.

     
    more » « less
  4. Summary

    Mesophyll conductance (gm) is the diffusion ofCO2from intercellular air spaces (IAS) to the first site of carboxylation in the mesophyll cells. In C3species,gmis influenced by diverse leaf structural and anatomical traits; however, little is known about traits affectinggmin C4species.

    To address this knowledge gap, we used online oxygen isotope discrimination measurements to estimategmand microscopy techniques to measure leaf structural and anatomical traits potentially related togmin 18 C4grasses.

    In this study,gmscaled positively with photosynthesis and intrinsic water‐use efficiency (TEi), but not with stomatal conductance. Also,gmwas not determined by a single trait but was positively correlated with adaxial stomatal densities (SDada), stomatal ratio (SR), mesophyll surface area exposed toIAS(Smes) and leaf thickness. However,gmwas not related to abaxial stomatal densities (SDaba) and mesophyll cell wall thickness (TCW).

    Our study suggests that greaterSDadaandSRincreasedgmby increasingSmesand creating additional parallel pathways forCO2diffusion inside mesophyll cells. Thus,SDada,SRandSmesare important determinants of C4gmand could be the target traits selected or modified for achieving greatergmandTEiin C4species.

     
    more » « less
  5. Summary

    The widely documented phenomenon of nighttime stomatal conductancegsncould lead to substantial water loss with no carbon gain, and thus it remains unclear whether nighttime stomatal conductance confers a functional advantage. Given that studies ofgsnhave focused on controlled environments or small numbers of species in natural environments, a broad phylogenetic and biogeographic context could provide insights into potential adaptive benefits ofgsn.

    We measuredgsnon a diverse suite of species (n = 73) across various functional groups and climates‐of‐origin in a common garden to study the phylogenetic and biogeographic/climatic controls ongsnand further assessed the degree to whichgsnco‐varied with leaf functional traits and daytime gas‐exchange rates.

    Closely related species were more similar ingsnthan expected by chance. Herbaceous species had highergsnthan woody species. Species that typically grow in climates with lower mean annual precipitation – where the fitness cost of water loss should be the highest – generally had highergsn.

    Our results reveal the highestgsnrates in species from environments where neighboring plants compete most strongly for water, suggesting a possible role for the competitive advantage ofgsn.

     
    more » « less