Attention:The NSF Public Access Repository (PAR) system and access will be unavailable from 5:00 PM ET until 8:00 PM ET on Friday, September 11 due to maintenance. We apologize for the inconvenience.


Title: Vulnerability of northern rocky mountain forests under future drought, fire, and harvest
Novel climate and disturbance regimes in the 21st century threaten to increase the vulnerability of some western U.S. forests to loss of biomass and function. However, the timing and magnitude of forest vulnerabilities are uncertain and will be highly variable across the complex biophysical landscape of the region. Assessing future forest trajectories and potential management impacts under novel conditions requires place-specific and mechanistic model projections. Stakeholders in the high-carbon density forests of the northern U.S. Rocky Mountains (NRM) currently seek to understand and mitigate climate risks to these diverse conifer forests, which experienced profound 20th century disturbance from the 1910 “Big Burn” and timber harvest. Present forest management plan revisions consider approaches including increases in timber harvest that are intended to shift species compositions and increase forest stress tolerance. We utilize CLM-FATES, a dynamic vegetation model (DVM) coupled to an Earth Systems Model (ESM), to model shifting NRM forest carbon stocks and cover, production, and disturbance through 2100 under unprecedented climate and management. Across all 21st century scenarios, domain forest C-stocks and canopy cover face decline after 2090 due to the interaction of intermittent drought and fire mortality with declining Net Primary Production (NPP) and post-disturbance recovery. However, mid-century increases in forest vulnerability to fire and drought impacts are not consistently projected across climate models due to increases in precipitation that buffer warming impacts. Under all climate scenarios, increased harvest regimes diminish forest carbon stocks and increase period mortality over business-as-usual, despite some late-century reductions in forest stress. Results indicate that existing forest carbon stocks and functions are moderately persistent and that increased near-term removals may be mistimed for effectively increasing resilience.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1553049 1655183
PAR ID:
10469636
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Frontiers
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Frontiers in Forests and Global Change
Volume:
6
ISSN:
2624-893X
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Climate change increases fire-favorable weather in forests, but fire trends are also affected by multiple other controlling factors that are difficult to untangle. We use machine learning to systematically group forest ecoregions into 12 global forest pyromes, with each showing distinct sensitivities to climatic, human, and vegetation controls. This delineation revealed that rapidly increasing forest fire emissions in extratropical pyromes, linked to climate change, offset declining emissions in tropical pyromes during 2001 to 2023. Annual emissions tripled in one extratropical pyrome due to increases in fire-favorable weather, compounded by increased forest cover and productivity. This contributed to a 60% increase in forest fire carbon emissions from forest ecoregions globally. Our results highlight the increasing vulnerability of forests and their carbon stocks to fire disturbance under climate change. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract Increases in the frequency and severity of climate-sensitive disturbances like wildfire, drought, and insect outbreaks pose an imminent threat to Earth’s forests, including their status as a net carbon sink. Forest treatments including thinning and prescribed fire are increasingly viewed as key tools for mitigating disturbance impacts, but their efficacy in stabilizing carbon stocks and reducing mortality, especially for drought and insect outbreaks, remains uncertain. Moreover, we have limited understanding of whether the moderating effect of forest treatments provides a net benefit to vegetation carbon stocks, or if the initial carbon loss required to implement treatments outweighs potential reductions in carbon losses during subsequent disturbance. Here we conduct a systematic meta-analysis of published literature to understand how thinning, prescribed fire, and combined treatments impact survival and carbon stocks following wildfires, droughts, and insect outbreaks. We found that treatments improved survival following wildfires, but had only marginal impacts on survival following drought and insect outbreaks. While thinning had a modest positive effect on carbon stocks following wildfire, treatments generally reduced carbon stocks following drought and had no impact following insect outbreaks. Overall, our findings suggest that the benefits of forest treatments for vegetation carbon stocks are limited, especially following drought and insect disturbances. These findings have important policy implications for carbon credit programs. 
    more » « less
  3. Lucash, Melissa S (Ed.)
    Boreal forests are found at high northern latitudes and form the largest terrestrial biome in the world. They comprise 30-50% of the world’s forest carbon stocks (vs. 14% in temperate forests. Temperatures are increasing rapidly in high northern latitudes (IPCC 2021), resulting in modified disturbance regimes and thawing of permafrost, and the socio-economic pressure to harvest timber is growing in currently unharvested areas. Attempts to predict how these changes will affect boreal forests must account for interactions among multiple disturbances (e.g., wind, insects, fire, harvest), seed dispersal, species growth and competition, and changing climate, and therefore uncertainty persists about how these changes will affect composition and function of this biome. Our objectives for this research were to 1) Use LANDIS-II to project forest dynamics under a range of climate and disturbance scenarios across a latitudinal gradient spanning the Siberian taiga from the arctic tundra to steppe ecotones, 2) Quantify the change in albedo and harvesting across bioclimatic zones and climates, 3) Identify the factor(s) that are the strongest drivers of these changes 
    more » « less
  4. functions and services for human societies. Temperatures are increasing most rapidly in high northern latitudes, altering tree growth and competition dynamics, and modifying disturbance regimes. The effect of these cumulative changes on the ecosystem functions provided by boreal forests is difficult to predict. We used the process-based LANDIS-II forest landscape model to evaluate how climate change and timber harvesting will interact to alter the production of ecosystem functions and services in boreal forests on three study areas across a large latitudinal gradient (11°) in central Siberia. We found that the relative importance of wood harvesting as a disturbance type varied depending on latitude and its impact was always far less than that of fire. Moderate climate change increased the availability of wood for harvest in the northern landscape, but wood availability declined in the southern landscapes under any amount of climate change likely because of an increase in the frequency of fire that kept forests too young for harvest. Modest climate change (RCP6.0) increased productivity and the storage of carbon in all landscapes but severe climate change (RCP8.5) reduced both in the southernmost landscape. Harvesting as a specific driver of change in these boreal forests is likely to be relatively minor except as a forest fragmentation process. Our results provide compelling evidence that status quo forest management in these landscapes is likely not sustainable, suggesting that climate-smart forestry will be needed. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract Forests are a large carbon sink and could serve as natural climate solutions that help moderate future warming. Thus, establishing forest carbon baselines is essential for tracking climate‐mitigation targets. Western US forests are natural climate solution hotspots but are profoundly threatened by drought and altered disturbance regimes. How these factors shape spatial patterns of carbon storage and carbon change over time is poorly resolved. Here, we estimate live and dead forest carbon density in 19 forested western US ecoregions with national inventory data (2005–2019) to determine: (a) current carbon distributions, (b) underpinning drivers, and (c) recent trends. Potential drivers of current carbon included harvest, wildfire, insect and disease, topography, and climate. Using random forests, we evaluated driver importance and relationships with current live and dead carbon within ecoregions. We assessed trends using linear models. Pacific Northwest (PNW) and Southwest (SW) ecoregions were most and least carbon dense, respectively. Climate was an important carbon driver in the SW and Lower Rockies. Fire reduced live and increased dead carbon, and was most important in the Upper Rockies and California. No ecoregion was unaffected by fire. Harvest and private ownership reduced carbon, particularly in the PNW. Since 2005, live carbon declined across much of the western US, likely from drought and fire. Carbon has increased in PNW ecoregions, likely recovering from past harvest, but recent record fire years may alter trajectories. Our results provide insight into western US forest carbon function and future vulnerabilities, which is vital for effective climate change mitigation strategies. 
    more » « less