skip to main content

Title: Analyzing cases of significant nondynamic correlation with DFT using the atomic populations of effectively localized electrons
Quantum multireference effects are associated with degeneracies and near-degeneracies of the ground state and are critical to a variety of systems. Most approximate functionals of density functional theory (DFT) fail to properly describe such effects. A number of diagnostics have been proposed to estimate in advance the reliability of a given single-reference solution in this respect. Some of these diagnostics, however, lack size-consistency while remaining computationally expensive. In this work, we propose the DFT method of atomic populations of effectively localized electrons (APELE) as a novel diagnostic in this vein. It is compared with existing diagnostics of nondynamic correlation on select exemplary systems. The APELE method is on average in good agreement with the popular T1 index, while being size-consistent and less costly. It becomes particularly informative in cases involving bond stretching or bond breaking. The APELE method is applied next to organic diradicals like the bis-acridine dimer and the p-quinodimethane molecule which possess unusually high nonlinear optical response, and to the reaction of ethylene addition to Ni dithiolene. Our results for this reaction are consistent with the T1 diagnostics and in addition, shed some light on the degree of d-electron localization at the Ni center.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Theoretical Chemistry Accounts
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. The synthesis of alkylphosphine-substituted α-diimine (DI) ligands and their subsequent addition to Ni(COD) 2 allowed for the preparation of ( iPr2PPr DI)Ni and ( tBu2PPr DI)Ni . The solid state structures of both compounds were found to feature a distorted tetrahedral geometry that is largely consistent with the reported structure of the diphenylphosphine-substituted variant, ( Ph2PPr DI)Ni . To explore and optimize the synthetic utility of this catalyst class, all three compounds were screened for benzaldehyde hydrosilylation activity at 1.0 mol% loading over 3 h at 25 °C. Notably, ( Ph2PPr DI)Ni was found to be the most efficient catalyst while phenyl silane was the most effective reductant. A broad scope of aldehydes and ketones were then hydrosilylated, and the silyl ether products were hydrolyzed to afford alcohols in good yield. When attempts were made to explore ester reduction, inefficient dihydrosilylation was noted for ethyl acetate and no reaction was observed for several additional substrates. However, when an equimolar solution of allyl acetate and phenyl silane was added to 1.0 mol% ( Ph2PPr DI)Ni , complete ester C–O bond hydrosilylation was observed within 30 min at 25 °C to generate propylene and PhSi(OAc) 3 . The scope of this reaction was expanded to include six additional allyl esters, and under neat conditions, turnover frequencies of up to 990 h −1 were achieved. This activity is believed to be the highest reported for transition metal-catalyzed ester C–O bond hydrosilylation. Proposed mechanisms for ( Ph2PPr DI)Ni -mediated carbonyl and allyl ester C–O bond hydrosilylation are also discussed. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Transition metal chalcogenide nanoparticles (NPs) are of interest for energy applications, including batteries, supercapacitors, and electrocatalysis. Many methods have been established for synthesizing Ni NPs, and conversion chemistry to form Ni oxide and phosphides from template Ni NPs is well‐understood. Sulfidation and selenidation of Ni NPs have been much less explored, however. We report a method for the conversion of Ni template NPs into sulfide and selenide product NPs using elemental sulfur, 1‐hexadecanthiol, thiourea, trioctylphosphine sulfide, elemental selenium, and selenourea. While maintaining mole ratios of 2 mmol sulfur/selenium precursor: mmol Ni, products with phases of Ni3S2, Ni9S8, NiS, NiSO4·6H2O, Ni3S4, Ni3Se2, and NiSe have been obtained. The products have voids that form through the Kirkendall effect during interdiffusion. Trends relating the chemical properties of the precursors to the phases of the products have been identified. While some precursors contained phosphorus, there was no significant incorporation of phosphorus in any of the products. An increase of the NP size during sulfidation and selenidation is consistent with ripening. The application of Ni sulfide and selenide NPs as electrocatalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction is also demonstrated.

    more » « less
  3. The density functional theory method is used to elucidate the elementary steps of Ni( ii )-catalyzed C(sp 2 )–H iodination with I 2 and substrates bearing N , N ′-bidentate directing centers, amide-oxazoline (AO) and 8-aminoquinoline (AQ). The relative stability of the lowest energy high- and low-spin electronic states of the catalyst and intermediates is found to be an important factor for all of the steps in the reaction. As a result, two-state reactivity for these systems is reported, where the reaction is initiated on the triplet surface and generates a high energy singlet nickelacycle. It is shown that the addition of Na 2 CO 3 base to the reaction mixture facilitates C–H activation. The presence of I 2 in the reaction provides the much needed driving force for the C–H activation and nickelacycle formation and ultimately reacts to form a new C–I bond through either a redox neutral electrophilic cleavage (EC) pathway or a one-electron reductive cleavage (REC) pathway. The previously proposed Ni( ii )/Ni( iv ) and homolytic cleavage pathways are found to be higher in energy. The nature of the substrate is found to have a large impact on the relative stability of the lowest electronic states and on the stability of the nickelacycle resulting from C–H activation. 
    more » « less
  4. Nickel and nitrogen co-doped carbon (Ni–N–C) has emerged as a promising catalyst for the CO 2 reduction reaction (CO 2 RR); however, the chemical nature of its active sites has remained elusive. Herein, we report the exploration of the reactivity and active sites of Ni–N–C for the CO 2 RR. Single atom Ni coordinated with N confined in a carbon matrix was prepared through thermal activation of chemically Ni-doped zeolitic imidazolate frameworks (ZIFs) and directly visualized by aberration-corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy. Electrochemical results show the enhanced intrinsic reactivity and selectivity of Ni–N sites for the reduction of CO 2 to CO, delivering a maximum CO faradaic efficiency of 96% at a low overpotential of 570 mV. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations predict that the edge-located Ni–N 2+2 sites with dangling bond-containing carbon atoms are the active sites facilitating the dissociation of the C–O bond of the *COOH intermediate, while bulk-hosted Ni–N 4 is kinetically inactive. Furthermore, the high capability of edge-located Ni–N 4 being able to thermodynamically suppress the competitive hydrogen evolution is also explained. The proposal of edge-hosed Ni–N 2+2 sites provides new insight into designing high-efficiency Ni–N–C for CO 2 reduction. 
    more » « less
  5. Radical cations generated from the oxidation of CC π-bonds are synthetically useful reactive intermediates for C–C and C–X bond formation. Radical cation formation, induced by sub-stoichiometric amounts of external oxidant, are important intermediates in the Woodward–Hoffmann thermally disallowed [2 + 2] cycloaddition of electron-rich alkenes. Using density functional theory (DFT), we report the detailed mechanisms underlying the intermolecular heterodimerisation of anethole and β-methylstyrene to give unsymmetrical, tetra-substituted cyclobutanes. Reactions between trans -alkenes favour the all-trans adduct, resulting from a kinetic preference for anti -addition reinforced by reversibility at ambient temperatures since this is also the thermodynamic product; on the other hand, reactions between a trans -alkene and a cis -alkene favour syn -addition, while exocyclic rotation in the acyclic radical cation intermediate is also possible since C–C forming barriers are higher. Computations are consistent with the experimental observation that hexafluoroisopropanol ( HFIP ) is a better solvent than acetonitrile, in part due to its ability to stabilise the reduced form of the hypervalent iodine initiator by hydrogen bonding, but also through the stabilisation of radical cationic intermediates along the reaction coordinate. 
    more » « less