skip to main content

Title: Delocalized states in three-terminal superconductor-semiconductor nanowire devices
We fabricate three-terminal hybrid devices consisting of a semiconductor nanowire segment proximitized by a grounded superconductor and having tunnel probe contacts on both sides. By performing simultaneous tunneling measurements, we identify delocalized states, which can be observed from both ends, and states localized near one of the tunnel barriers. The delocalized states can be traced from zero magnetic field to fields beyond 0.5 T. Within the regime that supports delocalized states, we search for correlated low-energy features consistent with the presence of Majorana zero modes. While both sides of the device exhibit ubiquitous low-energy features at high fields, no correlation is inferred. Simulations using a one-dimensional effective model suggest that the delocalized states, which extend throughout the whole system, have large characteristic wave vectors, while the lower momentum states expected to give rise to Majorana physics are localized by disorder. To avoid such localization and realize Majorana zero modes, disorder needs to be reduced significantly. We propose a method for estimating the disorder strength based on analyzing the level spacing between delocalized states.

more » « less
Award ID(s):
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
SciPost Foundation
Date Published:
Journal Name:
SciPost Physics
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. We use the available transportmeasurements in the literature to develop a dataset for the likely amount of disorder in semiconductor (InAs and InSb) materials which are used in fabricating the superconductor-semiconductor nanowire samples in the experimental search for Majorana zero modes. Using the estimated disorder in direct Majorana simulations, we conclude that the current level of disorder in semiconductor Majorana nanowires is at least an order of magnitude higher than that necessary for the emergence of topological Majorana zero modes. In agreement with existing results, we find that our estimated disorder leads to the occasional emergence of trivial zero modes, which can be post-selected and then further fine-tuned by varying system parameters (e.g., tunnel barrier), leading to trivial zero-bias conductance peaks in tunneling spectroscopy with ∼2e2/h magnitude. Most calculated tunnel spectra in these disordered systems, however, manifest essentially no significant features, which is also consistent with the current experimental status, where zero-bias peaks are found only occasionally in some samples under careful fine-tuning. 
    more » « less
  2. We consider theoretically the physics of bulk topological superconductivity accompanied by boundary non- Abelian Majorana zero modes in semiconductor-superconductor (SM-SC) hybrid systems consisting of finite wires in the presence of correlated disorder arising from random charged impurities. We find the system to manifest a highly complex behavior due to the subtle interplay between finite wire length and finite disorder, leading to copious low-energy in-gap states throughout the wire and considerably complicating the interpretation of tunneling spectroscopic transport measurements used extensively to search forMajorana modes. The presence of disorder-induced low-energy states may lead to the nonexistence of end Majorana zero modes even when tunneling spectroscopy manifests zero-bias conductance peaks in local tunneling and signatures of bulk gap closing/reopening in the nonlocal transport. In short wires within the intermediate disorder regime, apparent topology may manifest in small ranges (“patches”) of parameter values, which may or may not survive the longwire limit depending on various details. Because of the dominance of disorder-induced in-gap states, the system may even occasionally have an appropriate topological invariant without manifesting isolated end Majorana zero modes. We discuss our findings in the context of a recent breakthrough experiment from Microsoft reporting the simultaneous observations of zero-bias conductance peaks in local tunneling and gap opening in nonlocal transport within small patches of parameter space. Based on our analysis, we believe that the disorder strength to SC-gap ratio must decrease further for the definitive realization of non-Abelian Majorana zero modes in SM-SC devices. 
    more » « less
  3. We address an outstanding problem that represents a critical roadblock in the development of the Majorana-based topological qubit using semiconductor-superconductor hybrid structures: the quantitative characterization of disorder effects generated by the unintentional presence of charge impurities within the hybrid device. Given that disorder can have far-reaching consequences for the Majorana physics but is intrinsically difficult to probe experimentally in a hybrid structure, providing a quantitative theoretical description of disorder effects becomes essential. To accomplish this task, we develop a microscopic theory that (i) provides a quantitative characterization of the effective potential generated by a charge impurity embedded inside a semiconductor wire proximity coupled to a superconductor layer by solving selfconsistently the associated three-dimensional Schrödinger-Poisson problem, (ii) describes the low-energy physics of the hybrid structure in the presence of s-wave superconductivity, spin-orbit coupling, Zeeman splitting, and disorder arising from multiple charge impurities by using the results of (i) within a standard free-fermion approach, and (iii) links the microscopic results to experimentally observable features by generating tunneling differential-conductance maps as a function of the control parameters (e.g., Zeeman field and chemical potential). We find that charge impurities lead to serious complications regarding the realization and observation of Majorana zero modes, which have direct implications for the development of Majorana-based qubits. More importantly, our work provides a clear direction regarding what needs to be done for progress in the field, including specific materials-quality and semiconductor-purity targets that must be achieved to create a topological qubit. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Vibrational energy transport in disordered media is of fundamental importance to several fields spanning from sustainable energy to biomedicine to thermal management. This work investigates hybrid ordered/disordered nanocomposites that consist of crystalline membranes decorated by regularly patterned disordered regions formed by ion beam irradiation. The presence of the disordered regions results in reduced thermal conductivity, rendering these systems of interest for use as nanostructured thermoelectrics and thermal device components, yet their vibrational properties are not well understood. Here, the mechanism of vibrational transport and the reason underlying the observed reduction is established in detail. The hybrid systems are found to exhibit glass‐crystal duality in vibrational transport. Lattice dynamics reveals substantial hybridization between the localized and delocalized modes, which induces avoided crossings and harmonic broadening in the dispersion. Allen/Feldman theory shows that the hybridization and avoided crossings are the dominant drivers of the reduction. Anharmonic scattering is also enhanced in the patterned nanocomposites, further contributing to the reduction. The systems exhibit features reminiscent of both nanophononic materials and locally resonant nanophononic metamaterials, but operate in a manner distinct to both. These findings indicate that such “patterned disorder” can be a promising strategy to tailor vibrational transport through hybrid nanostructures.

    more » « less
  5. BACKGROUND The past decade has witnessed considerable progress toward the creation of new quantum technologies. Substantial advances in present leading qubit technologies, which are based on superconductors, semiconductors, trapped ions, or neutral atoms, will undoubtedly be made in the years ahead. Beyond these present technologies, there exist blueprints for topological qubits, which leverage fundamentally different physics for improved qubit performance. These qubits exploit the fact that quasiparticles of topological quantum states allow quantum information to be encoded and processed in a nonlocal manner, providing inherent protection against decoherence and potentially overcoming a major challenge of the present generation of qubits. Although still far from being experimentally realized, the potential benefits of this approach are evident. The inherent protection against decoherence implies better scalability, promising a considerable reduction in the number of qubits needed for error correction. Transcending possible technological applications, the underlying physics is rife with exciting concepts and challenges, including topological superconductors, non-abelian anyons such as Majorana zero modes (MZMs), and non-abelian quantum statistics.­­ ADVANCES In a wide-ranging and ongoing effort, numerous potential material platforms are being explored that may realize the required topological quantum states. Non-abelian anyons were first predicted as quasiparticles of topological states known as fractional quantum Hall states, which are formed when electrons move in a plane subject to a strong perpendicular magnetic field. The prediction that hybrid materials that combine topological insulators and conventional superconductors can support localized MZMs, the simplest type of non-abelian anyon, brought entirely new material platforms into view. These include, among others, semiconductor-superconductor hybrids, magnetic adatoms on superconducting substrates, and Fe-based superconductors. One-dimensional systems are playing a particularly prominent role, with blueprints for quantum information applications being most developed for hybrid semiconductor-superconductor systems. There have been numerous attempts to observe non-abelian anyons in the laboratory. Several experimental efforts observed signatures that are consistent with some of the theoretical predictions for MZMs. A few extensively studied platforms were subjected to intense scrutiny and in-depth analyses of alternative interpretations, revealing a more complex reality than anticipated, with multiple possible interpretations of the data. Because advances in our understanding of a physical system often rely on discrepancies between experiment and theory, this has already led to an improved understanding of Majorana signatures; however, our ability to detect and manipulate non-abelian anyons such as MZMs remains in its infancy. Future work can build on improved materials in some of the existing platforms but may also exploit new materials such as van der Waals heterostructures, including twisted layers, which promise many new options for engineering topological phases of matter. OUTLOOK Experimentally establishing the existence of non-abelian anyons constitutes an outstandingly worthwhile goal, not only from the point of view of fundamental physics but also because of their potential applications. Future progress will be accelerated if claims of Majorana discoveries are based on experimental tests that go substantially beyond indicators such as zero-bias peaks that, at best, suggest consistency with a Majorana interpretation. It will be equally important that these discoveries build on an excellent understanding of the underlying material systems. Most likely, further material improvements of existing platforms and the exploration of new material platforms will both be important avenues for progress toward obtaining solid evidence for MZMs. Once that has been achieved, we can hope to explore—and harness—the fascinating physics of non-abelian anyons such as the topologically protected ground state manifold and non-abelian statistics. Proposed topological platforms. (Left) Proposed state of electrons in a high magnetic field (even-denominator fractional quantum Hall states) are predicted to host Majorana quasiparticles. (Right) Hybrid structures of superconductors and other materials have also been proposed to host such quasiparticles and can be tailored to create topological quantum bits based on Majoranas. 
    more » « less