More Like this

1. Temperature and co-crystallization effects on Zr isotopes

   https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2023.05.004  

   Kirkpatrick, Heather M.; Harrison, T. Mark; Ibañez-Mejia, Mauricio; Tissot, François L.H.; MacLennan, Scott A.; Bell, Elizabeth A. (July 2023, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta)

   We undertook Zr isotope measurements on zircon, titanite, biotite, amphibole, and whole rocks from the La Posta pluton (Peninsular Ranges, southern California) together with trace element analyses and U-Pb age measurements to understand the controls on Zr isotope fractionation in igneous rocks, including temperature, crystallization sequence, and kinetic effects. We find large (>0.6‰) Zr isotope fractionations (expressed as δ94/90Zr) between titanite and zircon forming at approximately the same temperature. Using equilibrium fractionation factors calculated from ionic and ab initio models, we infer the controls on Zr isotope evolution to include the relative order in which phases appear on the liquidus, with titanite fractionation resulting in isotopically lighter melt and zircon fractionation resulting in isotopically heavier melt. While these models of Zr fractionation can explain δ94/90Zr variations in zircon of up to ∼1.5‰, crystallization order, temperature and presence of co-crystallizing phases do not explain all aspects of the intracrystalline Zr isotopic distribution in zircons in the La Posta pluton or the large range of Zr isotopic values among zircons (>2‰). Without additional constraints, such as knowledge of co-crystallizing phases and a better understand of the true causes of Zr isotope fractionation, Zr isotopes in zircon remains an ambiguous proxy of magmatic evolution. 

   more » « less
2. Extreme Zr stable isotope fractionation during magmatic fractional crystallization

   https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aax8648  

   Ibañez-Mejia, Mauricio; Tissot, François L. (December 2019, Science Advances)

   Zirconium is a commonly used elemental tracer of silicate differentiation, yet its stable isotope systematics remain poorly known. Accessory phases rich in Zr 4+ such as zircon and baddeleyite may preserve a unique record of Zr isotope behavior in magmatic environments, acting both as potential drivers of isotopic fractionation and recorders of melt compositional evolution. To test this potential, we measured the stable Zr isotope composition of 70 single zircon and baddeleyite crystals from a well-characterized gabbroic igneous cumulate. We show that (i) closed-system magmatic crystallization can fractionate Zr stable isotopes at the >0.5% level, and (ii) zircon and baddeleyite are isotopically heavy relative to the melt from which they crystallize, thus driving chemically differentiated liquids toward isotopically light compositions. Because these effects are contrary to first-order expectations based on mineral-melt bonding environment differences, Zr stable isotope fractionation during zircon crystallization may not solely be a result of closed-system thermodynamic equilibrium. 

   more » « less
3. Significant Zr isotope variations in single zircon grains recording magma evolution history

   https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2002053117  

   Guo, Jing-Liang; Wang, Zaicong; Zhang, Wen; Moynier, Frédéric; Cui, Dandan; Hu, Zhaochu; Ducea, Mihai N. (September 2020, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences)

   null (Ed.)

   Zircons widely occur in magmatic rocks and often display internal zonation finely recording the magmatic history. Here, we presented in situ high-precision (2SD <0.15‰ for δ 94 Zr) and high–spatial-resolution (20 µm) stable Zr isotope compositions of magmatic zircons in a suite of calc-alkaline plutonic rocks from the juvenile part of the Gangdese arc, southern Tibet. These zircon grains are internally zoned with Zr isotopically light cores and increasingly heavier rims. Our data suggest the preferential incorporation of lighter Zr isotopes in zircon from the melt, which would drive the residual melt to heavier values. The Rayleigh distillation model can well explain the observed internal zoning in single zircon grains, and the best-fit models gave average zircon–melt fractionation factors for each sample ranging from 0.99955 to 0.99988. The average fractionation factors are positively correlated with the median Ti-in-zircon temperatures, indicating a strong temperature dependence of Zr isotopic fractionation. The results demonstrate that in situ Zr isotope analyses would be another powerful contribution to the geochemical toolbox related to zircon. The findings of this study solve the fundamental issue on how zircon fractionates Zr isotopes in calc-alkaline magmas, the major type of magmas that led to forming continental crust over time. The results also show the great potential of stable Zr isotopes in tracing magmatic thermal and chemical evolution and thus possibly continental crustal differentiation. 

   more » « less
4. Zirconium stable isotope analysis of zircon by MC-ICP-MS: methods and application to evaluating intra-crystalline zonation in a zircon megacryst

   https://doi.org/10.1039/C9JA00315K  

   Tompkins, Hannah G.; Zieman, Lisa J.; Ibañez-Mejia, Mauricio; Tissot, François L. (June 2020, Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry)

   Zirconium (Zr) plays a key role in the development of phases like zircon (ZrSiO 4 ) and baddeleyite (ZrO 2 ) in magmatic systems. These minerals are crucial for the study of geologic time and crustal evolution, and their high resistivity to weathering and erosion results in their preservation on timescales of billions of years. Although zircon and baddeleyite may also preserve a robust record of Zr isotope behavior in high-temperature terrestrial environments, little is known about the factors that control Zr isotope partitioning in magmatic systems, the petrogenetic significance of fractionated compositions, or how these variations are recorded in Zr-rich accessory phases. Here, we describe a new analytical protocol for accurately determining the Zr stable isotope composition of zircon by multicollector-inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (MC-ICP-MS), using the double-spike method to correct for procedural and instrumental mass bias. We apply this technique to test whether zircon crystallization in carbonatite magmatic systems is a driver of Zr isotope fractionation by interrogating the internal zonation of a zircon megacryst from the Mud Tank carbonatite (MTUR1). We find the MTUR1 megacryst to lack internal zoning within analytical uncertainties with a mean μ 94/90 Zr NIST = −55 ± 28 ppm (2 SD, n = 151), which suggests that zircon crystallization is not a driver of Zr isotope fractionation in carbonatite magmas. This observation is in stark contrast with those made in silicate magmatic systems, raising the possibility that the bonding environment of Zr 4+ ions may be fundamentally different in carbonatite vs. silicate melts. Because of its remarkable homogeneity, the MTUR1 megacryst is an ideal natural reference material for Zr isotopic analysis of zircon using both solution and spatially resolved methods. The reproducibility of a pure Zr solution and our chemically purified zircon fractions indicate that the external reproducibility of our method is on the order of ±28 ppm for μ 94/90 Zr, or ±7 ppm per amu, at 95% confidence. 

   more » « less
5. Equilibrium Silicon Isotope Fractionation in Eclogites and Granites Constrained by Single Crystal X‐Ray Diffraction and the Force Constants Approach

   https://doi.org/10.1029/2023GL107954  

   Zhang, Dongzhou; Xu, Jingui; Dera, Przemyslaw K; Chen, Bin; Chen, Ming (April 2025, Geophysical Research Letters)

   Abstract Using our recently developed X‐ray diffraction basedforce constantsapproach, we have determined the equilibrium Si isotope fractionation between omphacite/garnet, quartz/kyanite, and quartz/zircon at temperatures relevant to the petrogenesis. We find that Na strongly affects the Si isotope fractionation between omphacite and garnet. Our results have suggested that the omphacite and garnet in eclogite collected in the Dabie Mountain, as well as the kyanite and its host quartz veins, are isotopically in equilibrium, which further suggests that the Dabie Mountain eclogites and its host veins underwent the same high pressure‐temperature condition during their formation. The Si isotope fractionation determined by our methods, together with published mass spectroscopy measurements, DFT‐CIPW calculations and sigmoid fitting on various felsic granites, have suggested that the Si isotope fraction between zircon and whole rock “saturates” at ∼0.45‰ at 1000 K when the SiO₂content in the granite is above ∼70 wt%. 

   more » « less