skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: How Variable Are Cold Pools?
Abstract Cold pools formed by precipitating convective clouds are an important source of mesoscale temperature variability. However, their sub‐mesoscale (100 m–10 km) structure has not been quantified, impeding validation of numerical models and understanding of their atmospheric and societal impacts. We assess temperature variability in observed and simulated cold pools using variograms calculated from dense network observations collected during a field experiment and in high‐resolution case‐study and idealized simulations. The temperature variance in cold pools is enhanced for spatial scales between ∼5 and 15 km compared to pre‐cold pool conditions, but the magnitude varies strongly with cold pool evolution and environment. Simulations capture the overall cold pool variogram shape well but underestimate the magnitude of the variability, irrespective of model resolution. Temperature variograms outside of cold pool periods are represented by the range of simulations evaluated here, suggesting that models misrepresent cold pool formation and/or dissipation processes.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2029611 2105938
PAR ID:
10496080
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
DOI PREFIX: 10.1029
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Geophysical Research Letters
Volume:
51
Issue:
6
ISSN:
0094-8276
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract Cold pools play a range of important roles in quasi-linear convective systems (QLCSs), including maintenance via the development of new convective cells as well as baroclinic generation of horizontal vorticity. Although a number of QLCS cold pools have been characterized in the literature using one or a few sensors, their variability (both internally and across a range of environments) has still not been widely studied. This gap in knowledge extends particularly to high-shear low-CAPE (HSLC) convective environments common to the cool season in the southeastern United States, where the Propagation, Evolution, and Rotation in Linear Storms (PERiLS) field campaign was focused. PERiLS specifically targeted environmental and storm-scale processes in QLCSs, including their cold pools. Our analysis focuses on the heterogeneity and temporal variability of cold pools across short time and spatial scales using numerous surface and sounding observations across five PERiLS QLCSs. The PERiLS cold pools are generally weaker than those previously studied in warm-season, midlatitude QLCSs, likely due to the lower CAPE and higher relative humidity values common to HSLC environments during PERiLS. Nevertheless, the distributions of most PERiLS cold pool variables at least partially overlap with those of previously studied QLCSs. The median PERiLS measurement reveals a cold pool that is ≈2.5 km deep, having a surface temperature decrease of ≈−6°C, and a peak outflow wind gust of ≈13 m s−1. In the spirit of a “cold pool audit,” we present the internal and case-to-case variability of these particularly well-observed QLCSs. Significance StatementEvaporatively cooled air masses (“cold pools”) are created by quasi-linear convective systems (“QLCSs,” also called “squall lines”), and they in turn play important roles in the maintenance and structures of QLCSs. There have been relatively few direct measurements of cold pool variability, especially for the frequently severe QLCSs occurring during the cool season in the southeastern United States. Numerous surface and upper-air measurements from the recent Propagation, Evolution, and Rotation in Linear Storms (“PERiLS”) field experiment are used to document Southeastern QLCS cold pools. The PERiLS cold pools were surprisingly similar to, albeit somewhat weaker than, those found in prior studies of warm-season QLCSs in other regions. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract Cold pools can initiate new convection by increasing vertical velocity (mechanical forcing) and locally enhancing moisture content (thermodynamic forcing). This study investigates the impact of the environment on mechanical and thermodynamic forcing from cold pool collisions. An ensemble of high-resolution numerical simulations was conducted that tested the sensitivity of cold pool collisions to three parameters: 1) the initial temperature deficit of cold pools, 2) the initial distance between cold pools, and 3) the static stability and moisture content of the environment. These parameters are tested in the absence of condensation, surface fluxes, radiation, and wind shear. Colder initial cold pools increase mechanical and thermodynamic forcing owing to greater horizontal winds during collisions. For all environments tested, mechanical forcing peaked robustly at an optimal initial distance between the cold pools due to a balance between the creation and dissipation of kinetic energy, and the different phases of density current evolution. Thermodynamic forcing peaked for greater initial cold pool distances than those associated with mechanical forcing. Decreased low-level static stability and an increased vertical gradient in low-level moisture enhanced mechanical and thermodynamic forcing, respectively. It is also shown that the initial temperature deficit had the greatest impact on mechanical and thermodynamic forcing, followed by the environment, and finally the initial separation distance. Finally, cold pool collisions are classified as “mechanically strong” or “mechanically weak,” where mechanically strong collisions increased mechanical forcing beyond that driven by the initial outward spreading of the cold pools. An analogous classification of “thermodynamically strong/weak” is also presented. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract The intensity of deep convective storms is driven in part by the strength of their updrafts and cold pools. In spite of the importance of these storm features, they can be poorly represented within numerical models. This has been attributed to model parameterizations, grid resolution, and the lack of appropriate observations with which to evaluate such simulations. The overarching goal of the Colorado State University Convective CLoud Outflows and UpDrafts Experiment (C 3 LOUD-Ex) was to enhance our understanding of deep convective storm processes and their representation within numerical models. To address this goal, a field campaign was conducted during July 2016 and May–June 2017 over northeastern Colorado, southeastern Wyoming, and southwestern Nebraska. Pivotal to the experiment was a novel “Flying Curtain” strategy designed around simultaneously employing a fleet of uncrewed aerial systems (UAS; or drones), high-frequency radiosonde launches, and surface observations to obtain detailed measurements of the spatial and temporal heterogeneities of cold pools. Updraft velocities were observed using targeted radiosondes and radars. Extensive datasets were successfully collected for 16 cold pool–focused and seven updraft-focused case studies. The updraft characteristics for all seven supercell updraft cases are compared and provide a useful database for model evaluation. An overview of the 16 cold pools’ characteristics is presented, and an in-depth analysis of one of the cold pool cases suggests that spatial variations in cold pool properties occur on spatial scales from O (100) m through to O (1) km. Processes responsible for the cold pool observations are explored and support recent high-resolution modeling results. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract Previous research has shown that 3-km horizontal grid spacing simulations depicting clusters of cells often change to showing linear structures when grid spacing is refined to 1 km. This increase in linear structures at finer horizontal grid spacings may be due simply to the resolving of stronger vertical motion along the leading edge of the MCS cold pool resulting in more continuous zones of convection in higher-resolution runs. However, prior work has suggested that the cold pools themselves are stronger with finer grid spacing, enhancing lift to grow linear morphologies faster. In the present study, Cloud Model 1 was used to simulate an array of MCSs with varying wind profiles and a constant thermodynamic profile (Weisman–Klemp analytic sounding) at both 1- and 3-km horizontal grid spacings and with 50 and 100 vertical levels. A line of seven randomly spaced warm bubbles was used to initiate convection. In 1-km Δxsimulations, gravity waves dominated in initiating new convection for growth into lines, and the ascent associated with them was much greater than in 3-km runs. Upscale growth into lines in 3-km Δxsimulations was driven more by ascent caused by the collision of convective cold pools. 
    more » « less
  5. During the Plains Elevated Convection at Night (PECAN) field campaign, 15 mesoscale convective system (MCS) environments were sampled by an array of instruments including radiosondes launched by three mobile sounding teams. Additional soundings were collected by fixed and mobile PECAN integrated sounding array (PISA) groups for a number of cases. Cluster analysis of observed vertical profiles established three primary preconvective categories: 1) those with an elevated maximum in equivalent potential temperature below a layer of potential instability; 2) those that maintain a daytime-like planetary boundary layer (PBL) and nearly potentially neutral low levels, sometimes even well after sunset despite the existence of a southerly low-level wind maximum; and 3) those that are potentially neutral at low levels, but have very weak or no southerly low-level winds. Profiles of equivalent potential temperature in elevated instability cases tend to evolve rapidly in time, while cases in the potentially neutral categories do not. Analysis of composite Rapid Refresh (RAP) environments indicate greater moisture content and moisture advection in an elevated layer in the elevated instability cases than in their potentially neutral counterparts. Postconvective soundings demonstrate significantly more variability, but cold pools were observed in nearly every PECAN MCS case. Following convection, perturbations range between −1.9 and −9.1 K over depths between 150 m and 4.35 km, but stronger, deeper stable layers lead to structures where the largest cold pool temperature perturbation is observed above the surface. 
    more » « less