An official website of the United States government
Using narrative analysis, this article examines the relationship between coloniality and racializing characterizations of Puerto Ricans, on the one hand, and taken-for-granted formula stories about U.S. national identity and morality, on the other. Our analysis draws from two data sets: 21 newspaper articles published in a Florida newspaper in the aftermath of Hurricane Maria about the needs and conditions of climate migrants from Puerto Rico and 54 interviews with Puerto Rican climate migrants who relocated to Florida after the hurricane struck the archipelago in 2017. This multilevel analysis explores prevailing colorblind racism frames that circulate across levels of social life embedded in stories that appeal to cultural ways of thinking and feeling about the world. Our findings show how colorblind frames in broadly shared narratives can reinforce racial scripts and perpetuate ethnoracial inequality. They also show that the broad circulation of such narratives at cultural, institutional, and interpersonal levels renders the racialization process less discernible.
more »
« less
The role of disasters in shaping narratives of resilience and transformation in Puerto Rico
Extreme weather events can act as “focusing events” that open windows of opportunity in the policy process for increasing resilience and transforming existing systems to be more sustainable and just. However, due to the multiple and contested meanings of resilience, it is uncertain to what extent a focusing event will foster transformational policy change as opposed to re-entrenching existing systems and structures. We conducted quantitative content and qualitative narrative analyses of Puerto Rican climate and energy policy before and after Hurricane Maria to assess the effect of a climate-induced disaster on the framings of resilience and transformation. We find that these terms are used predominantly in service of changes needed to promote the stability of the existing energy system. This suggests that after Hurricane Maria, achieving stability has been the dominant goal for resilience and transformation. As long as those responsible for the Puerto Rican energy system emphasize stability without actively working to enable longer-term transformational change, Puerto Ricans are unlikely to experience a rapid transition toward a sustainable, inclusive energy system.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1947017
- PAR ID:
- 10507696
- Publisher / Repository:
- Current Research in Environmental Sustainability
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Current Research in Environmental Sustainability
- Volume:
- 6
- Issue:
- C
- ISSN:
- 2666-0490
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 100227
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Based on data from 103 surveys of Puerto Rican migrants living in Florida and 54 in-depth interviews with a subgroup of them, we examine how Puerto Ricans who left the archipelago after Hurricane Maria have navigated settlement in their new homes. In this article, we observed and classified our participants’ descriptions of how they managed opportunities and challenges regarding education, employment, and social relations, the traditional benchmarks for the assessment of societal integration. We also observed how our participants described Covid-19’s interaction with these benchmarks. We found that our participants have experienced a series of cascading disasters since 2017—namely, Hurricane Maria, the earthquakes that affected Puerto Rico starting in late 2019, the humanitarian crises that followed both disasters, and now the global pandemic. These disasters, compounded with migration, have resulted in a process of adaptation to Florida in which social and labor-market integration and the ability to nurture social ties have been significantly diminished.more » « less
-
The communities of Puerto Rico are highly vulnerable to climate change as the archipelago has experienced a multitude of compounding crises and extreme weather events in recent years. To address these issues, the research, analysis, and design of grand challenge solutions for disaster-prone regions like Puerto Rico can utilize collaborative transdisciplinary efforts. Local non-governmental and community-based organizations have a pivotal role in the reconstruction processes and the building of community and environmental resilience in underserved communities. This paper contributes an empirical case study of an online transdisciplinary collaboration between a group of academics and a Puerto Rican non-governmental organization, Caras con Causa. From participant observation, it includes a document analysis of meeting notes with cohort members who were involved in a collaborative National Science Foundation Project, The INFEWS-ER: A Virtual Resource Center Enabling Graduate Innovations at the Nexus of Food, Energy, and Water Systems, with Caras con Causa between October 2020 and April 2021. Caras con Causa focuses on uplifting Puerto Ricans by creating and administering environmental, educational, economic, and community programs, highlighting disaster relief and resilience to help Puerto Rican food, energy, and water systems. Eight key discussion themes emerged from the document analysis: team organization, collaboration with Caras con Causa, deliverables, team contributions, context understanding, participation outcomes, technology setup, and lessons learned. We analyze each of the emerging themes to explain how academics may use transdisciplinary skill sets in addition to standard disciplinary-based approaches or techniques to enhance the institutional capacity of a non-governmental organization doing community resilience work to benefit local food, energy, and water systems. While the learned lessons in this non-governmental organization-academic collaboration may be context-specific, we provide insights that may be generalizable to collaborations in comparable transdisciplinary settings.more » « less
-
The Doppler radar located in Cayey, Puerto Rico is a critical tool in early weather forecasting. During Hurricane Maria in September 2017, the radar was destroyed as the result of the strong winds. An X-band radar was used as a temporary solution. X-band radar have limited range in comparison with Doppler radars. On June 2018, a new Doppler radar was built and forecasting services were fully restored. This paper uses a five-dimensional project management model (5DPM) and complexity maps to identify and manage the sources of complexity in restoring the radar's functionality and maintaining capacity. When looking at the radar individually, it can be concluded that the radar is fully restored. However, rebuilding the radar is different than providing a resilient and sustainable capacity. In order to ensure that the radar remains functional during and after an adverse natural event, ensuring that the radar suffers no damage is not enough. One has to expand the project́s footprint and use a whole systems approach to look at the project within the framework of supporting critical infrastructure, thus increasing the project́s complexity. For example, the radar has a power generator to supply energy in case of an electrical power failure. During a prolonged power failure, the radar may run out of fuel. If the roads and bridges are damaged, access to the site may be blocked, which compromises the radar's functionality. Based on the complexity analysis, it can be concluded that while the reconstruction of the Doppler radar to restore its functionality has finished, ensuring that it maintains capability to adequately warn Puerto Rico residents of weather events during and after a natural disaster still needs to be addressed. Hurricane Maria increased awareness regarding Puerto Rico's critical infrastructure vulnerabilities. The lessons learned from the natural disaster can be used to develop and implement a whole systems approach to design and build resilient and sustainable infrastructure. This paper contributes to the body of knowledge by demonstrating the concept of applying 5DPM to both individual projects and integrated systems. It moves restoration of services from a project specific basis to capacity maintenance mode, which looks at whole systems approach thus expanding the complexity footprint. This global focus ensures that critical infrastructure is resilient and sustainable.more » « less
-
Natural hazard news coverage research has examined frames, sources, and journalistic roles. An examination of place in such coverage is missing. Using the hierarchy of influences model, this study analyzes the coverage of place during Hurricane Maria in three major newspapers in Puerto Rico in the pre-crisis and crisis stages of the event. The study examined the roles of routines, organizational factors, and social systems factors in the coverage of Puerto Rican municipalities and the topics covered. Results show a primary focus on highly populated areas, reliance on governmental sources, and differences across the three newspapers studied. Implications for disaster coverage as well as theoretical arguments about the hierarchy of influences are discussed.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crsust.2023.100227
