An official website of the United States government
Global Internet users increasingly rely on virtual private network (VPN) services to preserve their privacy, circumvent censorship, and access geo-filtered content. Due to their own lack of technical sophistication and the opaque nature of VPN clients, however, the vast majority of users have limited means to verify a given VPN service’s claims along any of these dimensions. We design an active measurement system to test various infrastructural and privacy aspects of VPN services and evaluate 62 commercial providers. Our results suggest that while commercial VPN services seem, on the whole, less likely to intercept or tamper with user traffic than other, previously studied forms of traffic proxying, many VPNs do leak user traffic—perhaps inadvertently—through a variety of means. We also find that a non-trivial fraction of VPN providers transparently proxy traffic, and many misrepresent the physical location of their vantage points: 5–30% of the vantage points, associated with 10% of the providers we study, appear to be hosted on servers located in countries other than those advertised to users.
more »
« less
"All of them claim to be the best": Multi-perspective study of {VPN} users and {VPN} providers
As more users adopt VPNs for a variety of reasons, it is important to develop empirical knowledge of their needs and mental models of what a VPN offers. Moreover, studying VPN users alone is not enough because, by using a VPN, a user essentially transfers trust, say from their network provider, onto the VPN provider. To that end, we are the first to study the VPN ecosystem from both the users' and the providers' perspectives. In this paper, we conduct a quantitative survey of 1,252 VPN users in the U.S. and qualitative interviews of nine providers to answer several research questions regarding the motivations, needs, threat model, and mental model of users, and the key challenges and insights from VPN providers. We create novel insights by augmenting our multi-perspective results, and highlight cases where the user and provider perspectives are misaligned. Alarmingly, we find that users rely on and trust VPN review sites, but VPN providers shed light on how these sites are mostly motivated by money. Worryingly, we find that users have flawed mental models about the protection VPNs provide, and about data collected by VPNs. We present actionable recommendations for technologists and security and privacy advocates by identifying potential areas on which to focus efforts and improve the VPN ecosystem.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2141512
- PAR ID:
- 10510382
- Publisher / Repository:
- USENIX Association
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- 32nd USENIX Security Symposium (USENIX Security 23)
- ISBN:
- 978-1-939133-37-3
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Location:
- Anaheim, CA
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) are increasingly being used to protect online users’ privacy and security. However, there is an ongoing arms race between censors that aim to detect and block VPN usage, and VPN providers that aim to obfuscate their services from these censors. In this paper, we explore the feasibility of a simple, protocol-agnostic VPN detection technique based on identifying encapsulated TCP behaviors in UDP-based tunnels. We derive heuristics to distinguish TCP-over-UDP VPN traffic from plain UDP traffic using RFC-defined TCP behaviors. Our evaluations on realworld traffic show that this technique can achieve a false positive rate (FPR) of 0.11%, an order of magnitude lower than existing machine learning-based VPN detection methods. We suggest defenses to evade our detection technique and encourage VPN providers to proactively defend against such attacks.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)To support remote employees, organizations often use virtual private networks (VPNs) to provide confidential and authenticated tunnels between the organization’s networks and the employees’ systems. With widespread end-to-end application layer encryption and authentication, the cryptographic features of VPNs are often redundant. However, many organizations still rely upon VPNs. We examine the motivations and limitations associated with VPNs and find that VPNs are often used to simplify access control and filtering for enterprise services. To avoid limitations associated with VPNs, we propose an approach that allows straightforward filtering. Our approach provides evidence a remote user belongs in a network, despite the address sharing present in tools like Carrier-Grade Network Address Translation. We preserve simple access control and eliminate the need for VPN servers, redundant cryptography, and VPN packet headers overheads. The approach is incrementally deployable and provides a second factor for authenticating users and systems while minimizing performance overheads.more » « less
-
Virtual private networks (VPNs) allow organizations to support their remote employees by creating tunnels that ensure confidentiality, integrity and authenticity of communicated packets. However, these same services are often provided by the application, in protocols such as TLS. As a result, the historical driving force for VPNs may be in decline. Instead, VPNs are often used to determine whether a communicating host is a legitimate member of the network to simplify filtering and access control. However, this comes with a cost: VPN implementations often introduce performance bottlenecks that affect the user experience. To preserve straightforward filtering without the limitations of VPN deployments, we explore a simple network-level identifier that allows remote users to provide evidence that they have previously been vetted. This approach uniquely identifies each user, even if they are behind Carrier-Grade Network Address Translation, which causes widespread IP address sharing. Such identifiers remove the redundant cryptography, packet header overheads, and need for dedicated servers to implement VPNs. This lightweight approach can achieve access control goals with minimal performance overheads.more » « less
-
Extensive recent research has shown that it is surprisingly easy to infer Amazon Alexa voice commands over their network traffic data. To prevent these traffic analytics (TA)-based inference attacks, smart home owners are considering deploying virtual private networks (VPNs) to safeguard their smart speakers. In this work, we design a new machine learning-powered attack framework—VoiceAttack that could still accurately fingerprint voice commands on VPN-encrypted voice speaker network traffic. We evaluate VoiceAttack under 5 different real-world settings using Amazon Alexa and Google Home. Our results show that VoiceAttack could correctly infer voice command sentences with a Matthews Correlation Coefficient (MCC) of 0.68 in a closed-world setting and infer voice command categories with an MCC of 0.84 in an open-world setting by eavesdropping VPN-encrypted network traffic data. This presents a significant risk to user privacy and security, as it suggests that external on-path attackers could still potentially intercept and decipher users’ voice commands despite the VPN encryption. We then further examine the sensitivity of voice speaker commands to VoiceAttack. We find that 134 voice speaker commands are highly vulnerable to VoiceAttack. We also present a defense approach—VoiceDefense, which could inject inject appropriate traffic “noise” into voice speaker traffic. And our evaluation results show that VoiceDefense could effectively mitigate VoiceAttack on Amazon Echo and Google Home.more » « less
